West Cumberland Times
Article from the West Cumberland Times, 16th April 1932
Mean and Contemptible
Miner Who Would Have Robbed Fellow Workmen
A Workington miner — William Sawyers, 4 Bolton Street — was on Wednesday at the Workington Police Court, fined £8, or, in default of payment, two months' imprisonment, for what the presiding magistrate described as a mean and
contemptible action. The charge was that Sawyers attempted and endeavoured to obtain by false pretences the sum of 4/7 from the Allerton Coal Co Ltd, by placing his own Colliery token in a tub filled by another man.
Mr. J. N. S. T. George Curwen prosecuted for the Company. Sawyers, he said, was charged with an offence which miners called "tub sticking". On February 25th, the defendant, because there was no other place for him, was put to work, with
two partners, named McCauley and Wilson, on the morning shift. Between them, they filled thirteen tubs. Nine of which belonged to McCauley and Wilson and four to Sawyers. On ascending after their work was done, each man or partnership of
men, was met by the check Weighman, who saw Sawyers and his two mates in the lamp room. Sawyers claimed for six tubs as against four that he had, in fact, worked for with McCauley and Wilson. During that afternoon three tubs had come up the pit with
Sawyers token number (157) on them, and on the following shift three other tubs came up bearing the same number, making the number that the defendant claimed six.
In consequence of something which transpired, the defendant was seen by Mr. MacFarland, the manager, on February 29th. The fraud had been discovered by a man named Cass, who had been losing tubs which he ought to have been credited with.
Besides placing a token in the usual position at the top of the tub, he also put one under the coals — a rather ingenious idea — and when the tub arrived at the top Sawyers token was showing but Cass's token was underneath, at once proving
that somebody had removed Cass's token and substituted No. 157. The men's own delegate was present at the interview, when the defendant was asked how many tubs in all he had claimed for and was entitled to be paid for in that week. He said that he was
entitled to 19. It was then pointed out to him that he had claimed for 25, which he subsequently corrected to 23, and was asked to account for the difference between the tubs claimed for and the tubs he said he was entitled to. He could give no
explanation.
The loss to the Company, Mr. Curwen said, was small, but the main thing was that if the fraud had not been detected, somebody in the pit would have been done out of two tubs. It as impossible to say which tubs Sawyers utilised, and the distressing thing
was that everybody in the pit suspected his neighbour, and it was extremely unpleasant for the check Weighman too, because some miner might have put it down to his carelessness. Joseph McCauley, 30, Derwent Street, Frederick Taylor,
Moorhouse Guards, the men's checkweighman; Joseph Mcwhorter, 45, Blackburn Street, checkweighman for the Company, and Robert MacFarland stated that if the tub had not come up with the other number inside, possibly the fraud would not have
been detected. Tubs had been "missing" for some time.
No evidence was offered on the other two charges, and they were accordingly withdrawn. The decision of the Court was as stated.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cass, — | | | |
| Curwen, J. N. S. T. George | | | |
| MacFarland, — | | | |
| MacFarland, Robert | | | |
| McCauley, — | | | |
| McCauley, Joseph | | | |
| Mcwhorter, Joseph | | | |
| Sawyers, William | | | |
| Taylor, Frederick | | | |
| Wilson, — | | | |