|
8th April 1932, Page: 714, Column: 2 Notes from the Coal FieldsScotland[Local Correspondence.] The mine officials' class at Prestonlodge Higher Grade School, East Lothian, concluded last week when a lecture on "Roof Movements and Roof Control" was given by Dr. A. Winstanley, of the Safety in Mines Research Board. The lecture was supplemented by the showing of two films, one on "Pack Building," and the other on the "Stripping and Support of a Machine Run," and were greatly appreciated. Dr. Briggs, Professor of Mining, University and Heriot-Watt College, Edinburgh, thanked Dr. Winstanley for his very able lecture and remarked that it was a pleasure for him to see so many taking advantage of the mine officials' class. Such a class enabled officials to refresh their knowledge and keep in line with the latest progress. The class was a unique one and of an experimental character and the attendance throughout the session had fully justified the venture. He trusted their enthusiasm would lead them further on in the study of mining. Mr. Gilbert Rowan, agent of the Edinburgh Collieries, had much to do with the inauguration of the class and had all along shown a keen interest in, its work. They were greatly indebted to Mr. Rowan and to the East Lothian Education Committee for their enthusiasm and the provision of the necessary equipment. Mr. J. Wilson, Mining Department, Heriot-Watt College, was the teacher. The position of the coal industry in Britain as a result of the operation of the Coal Mines Act, 1930, was reviewed by Mr. Montague F. Maclean, who presided last week at the annual meeting in Glasgow of the United Collieries, Ltd. There were those, he said, who considered that the industrial tide was beginning to turn and that there were distinct indications of a general improvement all round, but he felt it was very difficult to conceive of any improvement which would be likely to absorb the productive capacity of the British coal fields. We had lost a considerable amount of our export trade to the Continent, and while we were regaining some of it, the requirements of British coal seemed more likely to diminish than to, increase as time went on. It seemed very unlikely our coal fields could during the immediate years ahead expect to find a market for their potential output. If this were so, there would appear to be only two methods of facing the situation — either co-operative action under control or complete and unfettered freedom. It was obvious that if the individual expression of opinion favoured the policy of freedom from any legislative or even voluntary restriction, it would be of little use for the districts to try and formulate any co-ordination schemes with one another, and very difficult for the industry as a whole to take any effective part in international negotiations. Unfortunately it was impossible to expect anything approaching unanimity upon a fundamental issue of such importance, but his impression was that the majority of the owners in the country took the view that Part I of the Act had on the whole been beneficial in spite of many shortcomings, and that they would favour its continuance subject to amendment. The ideal solution of our difficulties, continued Mr. Maclean, would be an agreed voluntary scheme prepared by the trade itself and acceptable to all the various interests concerned, but he feared this was expecting too much, as conditions were so variable and intricate. It would seem inevitable, therefore, that in the formation of any scheme for the future independent assistance would be necessary, and in Part I of the Act there was at any rate, a suitable foundation upon which to build. Nobody on general principle liked the idea of being controlled in his business enterprises, and a coal owner was certainly no exception, but to his mind it was a case of Hobson's choice. The industry was in a starved condition at present, bordering on insolvency, and to plunge it back into the complete freedom of open competition would lead to utter chaos. Mr. Maclean intimated that he had decided to tender his resignation as chairman of the company, a position he had held for 22 years. In connection with the proposed memorial to those who lost their lives in the Bowhill Colliery disaster on October 31 of last year, a further meeting was held at Bowhill, where a committee was appointed to make the necessary arrangements. The following proposals were unanimously agreed to :— (1) That the memorial take the form of a stone on the graves of the deceased; (2) that each organisation represented should subscribe a minimum of £l : (3) that an effort be made to raise a minimum sum of £150. An interesting question in connection with an employer's application for a reference to a medical referee under the Workmen's Compensation Acts was recently before the Sheriff Court at Stirling. The application was made by the Alloa Coal Co., Ltd., owners of Bannockburn Colliery, Stirlingshire, and it narrated that the claimant, Joseph McAteer, drawer, had on April 13, 1931, sustained injuries to his right middle and index fingers while in the course of his employment and that he had been paid weekly compensation. They alleged that the claimant was fit for light work and further that he ought to have the middle finger of the injured hand amputated, and that his refusal to have this done was retarding his recovery. They stated that the workman denied their contention and asked for a reference under s. 19 of the 1925 Act. McAteer objected to the reference being made on the ground that the matters in dispute involved the question of whether his refusal to undergo an operation was reasonable, and that as such a question could be settled by the court only, a reference to a medical referee should not be made. The matter came before the Sheriff Clerk (Registrar), who, after a hearing, rejected the objection and ordered the reference to proceed. It was, he said, desirable to have a report from a medical referee as to the claimant's present condition, and also as to whether the proposed operation would beneficially affect that condition or otherwise. The result of such an examination at this stage might help parties to decide as to whether it would be necessary to incur the expense of further court proceedings. The workman appealed against this deliverance to Sheriff Dean Leslie, who, after a further hearing, has refused the appeal and allowed the reference to proceed. His lordship said that he agreed with the Sheriff Clerk's opinion. If the referee were to decide that amputation would improve the working capacity the claimant might refuse to submit himself to operation. In that event the question of the reasonableness of his refusal might arise, but that was not a question for the referee and was not involved in the reference asked for.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||