|
7th April 1932 Silicosis In MinesTest Case Battle At WhitehavenClaim Of Iron Ore Miner's WidowSample, Which Was Surreptitiously Obtained A test case of considerable interest to iron ore miners, was heard at Whitehaven County Court yesterday, when an application for arbitration under the Workmen's Compensation Act in respect of an iron ore miner who died as the result of silicosis was refused, with costs, by Judge Eustace Hills, KC. There was not a great deal of evidence, and the case resolved itself into a succession of legal arguments between the two counsel and His Honour. Charlotte Atkinson, widow of Joseph Atkinson, iron ore miner, Low Mill, Lowside Quarter, made the application through Mr. F. E. Pritchard, instructed by Messrs Bendle, Sibson and Davidson, solicitors, and the respondents, the Beckermet Mining Company, Ltd., were represented by Messrs Brown, Auld and Brown, solicitors. The applicant alleged that the silicosis from which her husband died was due to the nature of his employment as an iron ore miner, in drilling and blasting in silica rock in, or incidental to, the mining and quarrying of iron ore and other minerals; that her husband had been so employed for five years, and was last so employed within three years of his death. Questions which had arisen were: (a) As to whether he was a workman to whom the Workmen's Compensation Act (1925) applied; (b) As to the liability of the respondents to pay compensation; (c) Whether the disease was contracted while he was in the service of the respondents; (d) Whether the disease was due to the nature of the employment; (e) Whether death was caused by the disease; (f) As to the amount of compensation payable to the dependants; (g) Who were the dependants within the meaning of the Act; (h) As to the apportionment. £300 Claim Mr. Pritchard said that Mr. Atkinson was aged 58 and had been an iron ore miner for 22 years, having been employed all the time at the Beckermet Company. Since 1918 he had been employed at the Winscales Mine. His work consisted of drilling with a dry machine, and then blasting. Samples had been taken of the rock in which he worked and an analyst would tell them that the percentage of silica was very high. Later he was transferred to another part of the mine. The amount claimed by the applicant was £300. There were three schemes concerning compensation in respect of silicosis, dated 1925, 1930 and 1931, each scheme amending the previous one, and Mr. Pritchard dealt with differences in the wording of the three schemes. After hearing lengthy legal arguments between the counsel, His Honour held that application must be made under the 1925 scheme. George Farren, iron ore miner, Vale View, Egremont, said he knew Joseph Atkinson from about 1920. He left his work on November 9th, 1929. From September 1928 until the date of his death Atkinson was working with witness, drilling and blasting iron ore, using dry drills, and there was dust arising. From January to November 9th he worked regularly except for eight weeks due to a sprained ankle, and one weeks sickness. They were working in Beckermet No.2 mine. Mr. C Edmonds, secretary to the iron ore section of the NUGMW, stationed at Cleator Moor, said on March 10th 1931, he went to Winscales mine and took certain samples (produced). He explained the portions of the mine from which the samples were taken. Mr. Pugh: You are the secretary of a trade union? — Yes. You went down the mine with Mr. Highton, with his permission? — Yes. You told Mr. Highton that you would not take samples? — No. How Sample Was Taken Then you gave him an impression that you were not taking samples. Did you take them surreptitiously? — You can put it that way if you like. His Honour might be glad to have fair samples from where the man worked. Mr. Pritchard objected to that remark. Mr. Pugh said that if the case was to depend on samples, they should be taken in a proper way. Have you heard the expression, "dirty ore?" — Yes, often. What is it? — Ore with any extraneous matter, say, ore with less than 30 per cent of iron in it. You know the expression "stone?" — Yes. What is it? — In the ordinary sense it means limestone or sandstone. The general term for very dirty ore is stone. In this mine the ore contained a high percentage of silica. Silica or freestone? — Crystalline quartz. The silica takes a crystalline form. What is your definition of silica rock? — Rock containing 35 or more per cent of free silica. Mr. Pritchard: And if that rock is blasted the silica will fly out in the form of dust together with the other elements? — Yes. Thomas Mann, FIC, Lowther Street, Whitehaven, an analyst, said he examined the samples produced and found 43.5 per cent silica in one and 25 per cent in the other. They would call the samples siliceous iron ore. Mr. Pugh: The danger of silica dust comes from the free silica embedded in the rock? — Yes. Your percentages are only of total silica content and do not represent free silica? — Yes. It is impossible from analysis to say whether the silica is free or not? — Analysis will not show the percentage of free silica, but only the amount of silica free and in combination. But free silica can be seen with the microscope. Too Late To Benefit Mr. Pugh contended that this scheme had come into operation too late for the workmen or his dependants to benefit. The sample of rock proved nothing. It had been taken from a tub, and not necessarily from the place where Atkinson worked. After the adjournment Mr. Pritchard said that if the Judge accepted the samples as prima facie evidence that they would give off a dry silica dust this brought Mr. Atkinson within the meaning of the scheme. The samples indicated that in this mine there was a large percentage of silica. A Government analysis showed that the average of silica in these Beckermet mines was 16 per cent. Even the best ore contained two or three per cent. He asked that if it was not considered that the sample was fair he be granted an adjournment to enable a proper sample to be taken. His Honour: Samples don't prove anything. Mr. Pugh: If this claim is successful, any man who works in iron ore comes within the scheme. Even roadmen could claim that they contracted silicosis from the two or three per cent of silica in ordinary road dust. If this interpretation of the Order was accepted every iron ore miner could claim compensation if he suffered from silicosis. Mr. Pritchard said this was not a reasonable argument. It did not follow that the Order was wrong because it might embrace all iron ore miners. His Honour agreed, and said he might agree to an adjournment for the purpose of obtaining samples if the respondents were agreeable, but only on that condition. It was up to the applicants to produce all the evidence they required and they had failed to do so. Mr. Pritchard said that when Mr. Edmonds went down he was taken to some limestone by the Manager, who asked him to take samples there, and he refused. Mr. Pugh said he would refuse to consent to samples being taken, and His Honour said he could not grant an application for an adjournment. The Judgement His Honour said it was a pity there was no proper evidence in this case. It was admitted that the man died from silicosis, but had this brought him within the 1928 scheme? It was said that the process of drilling and blasting was in silica rock, but witness Farren had given no relevant evidence, but had merely said that Atkinson was engaged in drilling and blasting in iron ore. Then as regards Mr. Edmonds' evidence he took some samples of rock, and it was alleged that these samples showed a high content of silica — between 25 and 43 per cent. But there was no indication of the place from which the sample was taken, except that they were from the Beckermet No.2 (Winscales) Mine. He was not satisfied that the respondents knew that the samples had been taken, and it was improper to take samples without telling the respondents; so there was no proof that Atkinson came within the scheme of 1928. Application had been made to him to admit evidence under other heads of the scheme, but he had come to the conclusion that it would not be right to do so. Without expressing an opinion as to whether it would assist the applicant it would not be right or proper for him as a judge to allow other processes than those relied on in the application to be submitted as an amendment. He was forced to the conclusion that within the relevant dates the workman was not within the scheme, and in those circumstances there must be an award in favour of the respondents with costs on scale B. Costs were also awarded for a technical witness for the respondents, who was not called.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||