|
19th March 1932, Page: 277, Column: 2 Coal Mines Act DefendedThe vice-chairman of the West Yorkshire Coalowners' Association, Mr. A. W. Archer, at Goole, on 9th March dealt with the objections recently made to Part I. of the Coal Mines Act of 1930. He said the Act was not, of course, a perfect piece of legislation. flow could it be at the outset? It was necessarily tentative and experimental, and those competent to judge anticipated that defects would be revealed in working. He did not deny that the complicated system of district allocations, standard tonnages for collieries, and quota percentages might, here and there, have caused hardship and inequity, and, in certain respects, require amendment. Again, the basis of fixation of mininmum prices was doubtless capable of improvement. But that was no reason why the instrument which had enabled the coal industry for the first time to begin to organise itself commercially and to attempt the solution of grave domestic and export problems should be flung on one side. No one would dispute that the coal industry was in need of better commercial organisation. The Act had promoted improved organisation, which, but for the Act, would in all probability never have been secured. It had brought the districts into closer touch with one another, and had established among them an understanding and adaptability which, although falling short of what was required, was previously non-existent. But it must not be forgotten that this new organisation was only in its infancy. The Central Council for the marketing schemes under the Coalmines Act decided on 10th March "that a committee be appointed to formulate, for submission to the Council, proposals for the amendment of the existing provisions of Part I. of the Coal Mines Act, 1930." This may be taken as the coalowners' decision in favour of the continuance of this part of the Act (which lapses at the end of the year) with amendments. The Government has asked both owners and miners to state their views. The reply of the Miners' Federation, which suggested various amendments to the Act, while giving it hearty support, had previously been published. If Part I., which established the machinery for regulating production and prices, is not continued by special legislation it will lapse in December. On the coal owners' side, the MANCHESTER GUARDIAN says, there is a good deal of difference of opinion. In South Wales and Scotland the majority vote went in favour of the repeal of Part I., and in other districts there was little enthusiasm. The main amendments which are likely to he discussed affect price regulation, which has been the weakest part of the scheme. In the Miners' Federation Memorandum to the Mines Department the summing up was as follows : Whatever the means adopted to secure them, and irrespective of whether the industry is publicly or privately owned, the underlying principles of output and price control must remain. . . . To-day more than ever before the circumstances of the industry require that the principles of regulation and co-ordination shall be applied to the industry. To-day the "surplus of productive capacity over present demand" is greater than ever before. A return, therefore, to the old conditions of free competition would be disastrous to the industry and to the country. Finally, it is now being widely recognised that the international application of these principles provides the only means by which the industry in Europe can be saved from collapse.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||