Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

8th January 1932, Page: 89, Column: 2

Notes from the Coal Fields

Scotland

[Local Correspondence].

About 3 o'clock on Saturday morning, while Robert Morton, fireman at Archibald Russell's, Ltd., No. 1 Tannochside Colliery, Uddingston, was going his usual rounds underground he came across an accumulation of gas, which exploded, and he was badly burned on the hands, chest and face, and was removed to Glasgow Royal Infirmary.

Cargo exports from Scotland for the first 10 months of 1931 amounted to 3,575,361 tons, and the declared values to £2,594,584, as compared with 4,703,841 tons and £3,447,505 for the corresponding period in 1930. Decrease in quantity was 1,128,480 tons, and in values of £852,921, a falling off of 24 per cent; The average price in 1931 was 14s. 6¼d. per ton f.o.b., and in 1930 it was 14s. 8d.

A fine of £5, with the alternative of 30 days imprisonment was imposed by the Justices at Hamilton J.P. Court, on January 4, on John Thomson Forbes, 11 Fotheringay-road, Glasgow, secretary of the Summerlee Iron Co., Ltd., 174 West George-street, Glasgow, who pleaded guilty to keeping petroleum spirit, namely, 50 gal. of naphtha, at Dykehead Colliery, Larkhall, the property of the company, without having a licence, contrary to the Petroleum Consolidation Act, 1928. An agent stated that the naphtha was kept for miners' lamps. The fiscal stated that it only came to the notice of the police that collieries were using petroleum spirits without a licence because of serious accidents at Dykeside Colliery. A superintendent of the police, while investigating the accident, discovered the naphtha.

The difficulties confronting the coal industry during 1931 are dealt with in a statement issued by Mr. William Adamson, general secretary of the Fife, Clackmannan and Kinross Miners' Union, and Mr. James Cook, assistant general secretary. It has to be admitted, says the report, that 1931 has been a most disappointing year and has utterly failed to justify the high hopes that centred round the industry as the result of the changes brought about by the Act of 1930. Production was to be co-ordinated to demand by means of the quota principle. An economic price was to be fixed to secure fair profits to the owners and fair wages to the workers. To-day the Act of 1930 is being assailed by criticisms of the most diverse character . . . . A dispassionate view of the Act, we venture to say, will reveal merit as well as demerit. To say that it had failed to reach its intended goal was not to say that it had failed completely. What the industry would be without the Act it was impossible to say. There had certainly been an attempt made to regulate the output in keeping with the demands of the market, and if the output had not been curtailed, he feared that the results would have been more prejudicial than they had been. The Act had not succeeded in bringing about the results aimed at and he thought it would be true to say that this had been partly due to the Act and partly to the inability or unwillingness of ths owners to make the most of the Act by serious co-operative effort. One would be inclined to suggest that the Act in its essential features should stand but that it should be re-examined in the light of recent experience and amended in such a way as to secure greater elasticity and adaptation to the requirements of the export trade. If the complaint is well founded, as we think it is, that many orders are lost because of the limitations of the quota, that defect should be remedied at once. The Act, in our opinion, lays the foundation on which the trade should build. If the principle of closer co-operation and co-ordination between district and district is fostered; if the question of the establishment of selling agencies were to be seriously taken in hand by the coal owners and if the export side of the trade were to be assisted by the imposition of a national levy, one might look to the future of the trade with confidence and faith that the misfortunes of this great and indispensable basic industry had touched bottom, and that brighter and more prosperous times might reasonably be predicted in the near if not the immediate future, always postulating that sound judgment and reason would prevail in the counsels of the coal owners and miners and that there should be no recurrence of the suicidal conflicts that have done so much to destroy the trade and weaken its competitive power in the neutral markets of the world.

Joseph Haddow, a shotfirer, formerly in the employment of James Nimmo and Co., Ltd., in their Broomfield Colliery, was recently successful in arbitration proceedings which he raised against the company for weekly compensation in respect of an accident which he sustained in the colliery on July 8 1930. The employers' defence was that the accident did not arise out of and in the course of the employment, and that it was attributable to the claimant's serious and wilful misconduct. They alleged that the claimant was in breach of the fourth schedule of the Explosives Order of September 1, 1913, in respect that he allowed a naked light to be within a distance of 4 ft. of an explosive which he was handling. On the evidence submitted, Sheriff Brown, K.C, holds that the claimant, who had a naked light and a canister containing powder in his possession, rose from the place where he was sitting to go to a place where his canister was for the purpose of finding out how much powder was left in it, this being part of his duty as a shotfirer; that the claimant first took his lamp out of his cap and placed it on the floor, afterwards turning towards the canister with the intention of opening it, and that the powder was instantly exploded. The sheriff holds that it has not been proved that there was any contravention of any statutory or other regulation or that the accident was caused by an added peril due to the claimant's own conduct. He therefore awards weekly compensation. In a note to his judgment, his lordship said that the primary difficulty was to ascertain the facts. Any conclusion that one might reach as to the cause of the accident must be based not so much upon direct evidence as upon inference from such facts as were known. It need hardly be said that the inference must be reasonable. The cause of ignition has not been ascertained. It was suggested that it might have been due to a lighted cigarette, but his lordship accepted the claimant's statement — of which there was corroboration — that he was not smoking. It was further suggested that it might have been due to a spark from the lamp. The evidence showed that this was a possible explanation, but his lordship was unable to hold it proved. No other definite theory was put forward. What his lordship held to be proved was that the claimant opened the canister, that the powder was ignited, and that an explosion occurred which resulted in his serious and permanent disablement. In discussing the House of Lords' decision in the case of Stephen v. Cooper (1929 S.C. H.L. 85) which was founded upon by the defenders, his lordship said that that case was an illustration of the proposition that the negligence or misconduct of the workman might be so extreme as to take him outside the scope of his employment. It was clear on the authorities that this question was always one of degree (Walkingshaw v. Woodhall Coal Co. (1931 S.C. 406)). In the present case if it had been proved that the workman had brought the naked light into actual contact with the powder, or so near to it as to cause an immediate explosion, it might have been proper to hold that that was an act so different from anything which he was employed to do as to put him outside the sphere of his employment, but there was no basis of fact upon which such an argument could be founded in this case, his lordship being unable to hold it proved that the workman allowed his lamp to be within 4 ft. of the explosive.

The Cadzow Coal Co., Ltd., were successful in a recent application, which they made to the sheriff clerk at . Hamilton to have the question of the capacity of an injured workman referred to the medical referee. The workman, Collins, sustained a strain of his body in the company's Cadzow Colliery on March 13, 1919, and was paid weekly compensation. The employers, having had the claimant medically examined, were advised that he was fit for light work. The workman, however, contended that he was unable for any work. The employers then lodged a minute in court asking that a reference be made to the medical referee to decide the medical point in dispute. The workman objected to a reference being made on the ground that the question was one of difficulty and complexity and that it could be more suitably determined in review proceedings which he alleged had been brought for the purpose. In ordering the reference to proceed, the sheriff clerk said that the question in dispute ex facie appeared a purely medical one and suitable for a reference. There was, however, he thought, a good deal to be said for the workman's objections in view of proceedings which had taken place previously in connection with the claim. The condition of the claimant was the subject of medical references in 1926, 1927, 1928 and 1929. In the first two the workman was found unfit for any work, but in the latter two he was found to be fit for light work on the surface. Following upon the medical referee's report of November 29, 1928, arbitration proceedings were brought in March 1929 by the workman on the ground that he had become totally incapacitated, and in the course of that process the fourth reference was made. After certain procedure under the arbitration claim, a proof was taken in November 1929, with the medical referee sitting as medical assessor, an award of compensation was made in respect of total incapacity up to a certain date and thereafter as for partial incapacity, The workman sought to have this award reviewed in the proceedings referred to in his objections to the reference. Notwithstanding the apparent complexity of the case, looking to the fact that the question raised in the present application was a purely medical one, the sheriff clerk thought that the reference should be allowed.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adamson, William    General Secretary  Whos Who Page
Brown, —    Sheriff  
Collins, —    Miner  
Cook, James    Assistant General Secretary  
Cooper, —      
Forbes, John Thomson    Secretary  
Haddow, Joseph    Shot firer  
Morton, Robert    Fireman  Injured
Stephen, —      
Walkingshaw, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Dykehead Colliery  Dykehead Colliery
Tannochside Colliery  Tannochside Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print