8th January 1932, Page: 89, Column: 1
Notes from the Coal Fields
Bristol and Somerset
[Local Correspondence].
A case of considerable interest in the Somerset coal fields was decided by
Judge Gwynne James, at Frome County Court, recently. Bertram G. Cray applied
for weekly compensation from the Somerset Colliery Co., on the grounds that,
while in that company's employ, he contracted silicosis and was totally
incapacitated from work. Cray told the judge that he commenced work as a
coal-cutter at Writhlington Colliery in 1917, but left later in that year to go
to the war. He was demobilised in January 1919, when he returned to work with
the Writhlington Colliery Company. In February 1926 he became employed by the
Somerset Colliery Company, where he remained until later in 1926, when there
was a general stoppage for 10 months. He returned to work in March 1927. He was
employed as a cutter as well as a brancher. He made roadways in the mine and
did blasting and drilling. Owing to being infected by silicosis he was unable
to follow his employment, which he had to give up in 1931. At Writhlington he
was working among all
sorts of stone, including cliff stone, and while there he used a
power drill as well as a hand drill, After he went to the Somerset Colliery
Company, he did the same class of work — drilling and blasting —
but he only drilled with a hand machine there. He was blasting every day. He
worked a compressed air machine at Writhlington for 18 months, but he used a
piece of gauze, to try and keep out the dust. He drove tunnels through the
rock, and was often working in hard silica rock. When working for the Somerset
Colliery Company he had no appliance to keep out the dust, Cray said he had no
certificate as a firer, but he did blasting without a certificate. The shotman
always left the ammunition for him to use. — Frederick Swift, miners'
agent, said that on December 3 he accompanied Mr. Cray and Mr. Young down
Ludlow's pit, and he took samples of the rock from the place pointed out by
Cray as where he had worked. The samples were sent to Messrs. Cook and Barke
for analysis. He could not go to where Cray had been blasting owing to a fall
of roof. — Mr. Harold Barke, public analyst, Bristol, said he analysed
four samples of stone, but only "B," "C" and "D"
would apply to that case. "B" contained 91.1 per cent. of silica,
"C" 60.1 per cent., and "D" 82.3 per cent. It was
practically all free silica. — Mr. F. E. Metcalfe submitted, for the
respondents, that while employed at the Writhlington Colliery, Cray was exposed
to far greater risk than when at Ludlow's pit, because at Writhlington he
worked hard rock with a compressed air drill, and where the dust must have been
considerable. His Honour would have to consider whether the silicosis did not
start at Writhlington. It was not his duty to do any firing at all, as he had
no certificate. — His Honour said he had come to the conclusion that he
did shotfiring without a certificate, and also that there was no great extent
of it. He added that a man might contract silicosis from the dust made by
another man's work. — Mr. Metcalfe said the onus was on the applicant to
prove that he had been working in silica rock for five years. This period was
broken. — Mr. Ker Lindsay, for the applicant, said the effect of what Mr.
Metcalfe said was that the Act might as well be torn up. — His Honour
said he had come to the conclusion that Cray contracted silicosis in
respondent's employment, but Mr. Lindsay must prove continuous employment.
— Mr. Ker Lindsay said s. 5 stipulated for a period of five years, and
periods must mean added together. The work of a coal-getter in Somerset
included the drilling and moving and handling stone. On November 30 the
respondent was served with a notice to amend the claim to include handling
stone. He argued that if a man contracted silicosis, whether under one or more
employers, if all in the same process, he was entitled to compensation:?
— His Honour said he came to the conclusion that Cray contracted
silicosis in his employment with the respondents. Silicosis was a progressive
malady, and had Cray contracted it at Writhlington one would have expected more
progress. He was against Mr. Metcalfe on s. 4, and found for applicant. —
Mr. Metcalfe asked for a stay of execution, saying that the question of an
appeal would be considered. — His Honour ordered respondents to pay
applicant £1 2s. 10d. per week, with a stay of execution for the amount
from August to date.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Barke, Harold | | Public Analyst | |
| Cook, — | | Public Analyst | |
| Cray, Bertram G. | | Miner | |
| Lindsay, Ker | | Solicitor | |
| Metcalfe, F. E. | | Solicitor | |
| Swift, Frederick | | Miners' Agent | |
| Young, — | | | |