|
28th November 1931, Page: 155, Column: 2 Coal Mines ActFor and AgainstMr. A. W. Archer, the chairman of the Export Committee under the Midland (Amalgamated) District Scheme, spoke in Leeds in reply to criticisms of the Coal Mines Act made by the chairman of the London section of the British Coal Exporters' Federation. Mr. Archer said that competition had rendered export prices on the whole uneconomic and that to have satisfied the offers, not necessarily the orders, of the exporters Would have involved enormous financial losses to collieries. There was no advantage, Mr. Archer said, in exporting coal at a loss, unless exporters claimed (1) that, whatever may happen to producers and mine workers, the exporter is entitled to his profit ; and (2) that crushing sacrifices should be made by producers to help to correct our adverse balance of trade. If the second claim Were seriously advanced, then there was an equally good reason why the exporter should pay the colliery an economic price and, by selling the coal at a loss, himself make a contribution to the adjustment of the trade balance. That, however, the exporters did not appear to favour. In order to raise particular brands of coal, mostly for spot orders and short-dated contracts, which was the substance of exporters' complaints, it was necessary to raise various other kinds of coal for which no market is available. More often than not such coal had to be placed in stock and allowed to deteriorate, in which case there Was a further addition to colliery losses. In no circumstances was it possible so to adjust the output of various kinds of coal as to meet demand for all of them exactly. The same was true, of course, before the Act came into force. In pre-Act days, hundreds of thousands of tons of coal for which there was not a ready market had to be sold at a slaughtered price. The Act was designed to prevent economic massacre such as that by regulating output. If the quota were to be abandoned, there was not the slightest doubt that markets would be flooded with coal. Europe was flooded now, and so was Great Britain. What would the position be, then, if collieries drew as much coal as they could ? It would be the collieries' purgatory but the exporters' and distributors' paradise. Even if the Act were repealed it would have to be replaced by voluntary measures, which would be far more detrimental to the public interest, if insolvency and gross labour unrest were to be averted. The view that the Coal Mines' Act has been a disaster for the Tyne area was expressed by Mr. H. P. Everett, when he was re-elected chairman, at the annual meeting of the river improvement Commission in Newcastle. Reviewing the present state of the river, he said the coal trade upon which the Tyne depended had had a terrible year. It would be fortunate if the shipments for the year reached 14,000,000 tons, a reduction of about three and a quarter million tons on last year. After having seen how the Coal Mines Act had worked, he had come to the conclusion that it had been a disaster to the Tyne area. How could the best brains in the coal trade compete abroad when prices were fixed? There was no elasticity, buyers and sellers knew the position, and opportunities were afforded to foreign coalfields to undercut this country whenever they felt inclined. It had been said by a colliery manager that if the industry was left alone it could recapture all trade lost in two years. It appeared that in all negotiations between Government departments and masters and men the interests of the ports and of all the industries bordering upon them were entirely overlooked. The coal trade was something more than miners' wages and coal owners' profits, and the sooner that was realised the better would it be for all.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||