|
19th November 1931 Detonator DeathWinscales Mine ExplosionCarelessness AllegedCarelessness on the part of some person unknown was alleged to have contributed to the death at Winscales Mine, Beckermet, on Saturday, of Mr. Stephen Stephenson, aged 50, of 34, Thorny Road, Thornhill, Egremont. The inquest was held at the Co-operative Hall, Thornhill, by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, sitting with a jury, of which MR. W. J. Goode was, appointed foreman. Others present were Major Highton, general manager of the Beckermet Mines, M. C. Booth, manager of the Winscales mines. Mr. R. A. Butler, H.M Inspector of Mines; Major. J. Hope Brown, solicitor for the Beckermet Mining Company, and Mr. C. Edmonds, representing the relatives of the deceased. Joseph Robinson, joiner, 34, Thorny Road, Thornhill, identified the body as that of his father, whom he last saw alive at 9.30pm on Friday. Deceased had been employed at Winscales Mine as an iron ore miner, for 27 years, and left a widow and three sons, one of whom was an invalid. William Sherwen. Mining engineer in the employ of the Beckermet Mining Company produced and explained plans of the working where the fatality occurred. By a juror; The body was found about sixteen feet from the place where shot firing had taken place. Abraham Harrison, iron ore miner, Brookside, Beckermet, said he started work at Winscales at 6am on Saturday and was in Number 18 Company along with Francis Gainford, Robert Farragher, William Harrison and the deceased. Stephenson was shovelling down some loose metal whilst witness and others were filling bogeys. Deceased showed witness some detonators, nine in number, which he had dug up with his pick. They were in a metal box and had been buried under the ore. Deceased had evidently knocked the lid off the box with his pick when digging. The detonators were given to Gainford who had bored a hole and prepared a charge ready for firing. Gainford put all the detonators in the hole to destroy them at the same time as he fired the shot. They looked round for more detonators but none were found. Gainford fired the shot and the detonators were destroyed. They left the working whilst shot firing was being fired, and on their return, deceased again began shovelling down loose metal. Witness asked deceased the time at 9.45am and they arranged to fill another bogey before going for "bait." The bogey was filled and witness was emptying it into a shoot nearby; deceased was climbing up the stope to get his lamp. Witness heard a shot go off and turned round to see deceased rolling down the stope; some smoke was seen. Witness ran back to Stephenson and picked him up — he was dead and had received severe facial injuries. In witness's opinion, deceased, in climbing up the stope for his lamp, had dislodged something, which had dropped on a detonator and had exploded it; deceased had nothing in his hand and had not reached his lamp. The place where they were working was an old working and he thought caps might have been kept there at some time. Witness did not know how long it was since the working was last worked. By the juror: All the caps had been in a box and the lid must have been knocked off by deceased. Nine Detonators Destroyed By Mr. R. Butler: Detonators were issued in small tin boxes and were then put in a wooden store box. It was not the wooden box that was found in the working. The box of detonators were found under the ore. The charge for firing was made by Gainford, who bored and charged the hole and also put in the nine detonators found, by deceased. It was not unusual to destroy detonators in this way. In answer to the Inspector's question as to why the detonators had not been handed into the stores, witness did not reply. By Major Hope Brown: Witness did not know how old the detonators were, but the sawdust in which they were kept was mouldy. They might have been there for years. By Mr. Edmonds: The working was dry. The ammunition store box was some sixty or seventy yards from where the hole was fired. The detonators were identical with those at present used. The explosion was caused by a detonator, certainly not dynamite. By Mr. Butler: Witness had never seen any dynamite lying about. He agreed that it was carelessness on someone's part to leave detonators lying about. Thomas Gainford, iron ore miner, 3, Cross Side, Egremont, corroborated. He was away making the charge when deceased found the detonators, which were given to him on his return by Farragher. He contended that detonators were unsafe after lying about for any length of time, and he thought it best to destroy those found by deceased. All the nine detonators handed to him were buried in the dynamite with which he charged the hole. He thought that the detonator, which caused the fatality, had been lying on something solid and a piece of ore had dropped on it. There was no dynamite lying about, and he did not know how the detonators came to be lying about. Detonators were usually left in the store box at the end of the shift, and if the company was being taken out of the working altogether all gear was usually taken away. By Mr. Butler: I suggest that workmen be told to take great care in looking after explosives. Place Unworked For Four Years Tom Harrington, deputy, Church View, Calderbridge, said he was on duty on Saturday and inspected the working where the fatality occurred. He heard nothing about any caps being found and the working was all right when he inspected it. The working was first opened seven or eight years ago and had stood unworked for four or five years; it was reopened by the present company about twelve months ago. When a working was abandoned, the miners were told by the deputy to bring up all stores and the working was later inspected by a deputy. He never knew store boxes to be kept in that place and had no theory as to how the detonators got there. He was up in the working when it stood idle. Miners had not to account for the numbers of detonators used. He agreed that a piece of metal striking a detonator would be sufficient to explode it. By Mr. Butler: He agreed that the detonators had been left in the working by carelessness, and should have been handed back to the stores when the working was abandoned. The detonators should have all exploded if put in dynamite as stated by Gainford. The detonators must have been in the working more than twelve months. After summing up the evidence the coroner said, "If the jury wish to get evidence, which may attach blame to someone, they are at liberty to do so." The jury, after a short retirement, returned a verdict that "Stephenson met with accidental death due to the explosion of a detonator left lying carelessly about, and are of the opinion that when a company is withdrawn from a working, a careful inspection should be made." The Coroner accepted the jury's finding and recorded a verdict accordingly. Mr. Hope Brown, on behalf of the company, expressed sympathy with the family of the deceased who during his 27 years' service with the company had shown himself an exemplary workman. He deplored the fact that the fatality had occurred through someone's carelessness, but the management felt they had carried out their duties and in this case there was no evidence to show the carelessness on the part of the officials as implied in the jury's rider. The coroner signified his agreement. Mr. W. J. Goode on behalf of the jury expressed sympathy with the family of deceased.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||