|
11th July 1931, Page: 410, Column: 1 Auchinraith ExplosionPoints Arising at InquiryIn our last issue reference was made to Sir Henry Walker's report on the explosion at Auchinraith Colliery on 30th August, 1930, whereby six persons lost their lives and eight others were injured. Several points arose during the inquiry, and on three of them Sir Henry makes the following comments :— (1) Do Sections 66 (b) of the Coal Mines Act., 1911, and numbers 131 and 132 of the General Regulations in reference to the use of electricity belowground, apply to shot-firing cables? Section 66 (b) requires that once at least in every week a competent person appointed by the manager for the purpose shall examine thoroughly the state of all machinery, gear and appliances of the mine other than those detailed in Section 66 (a)] and shall make a full and accurate report of the result of the examination, and every such report shall be recorded without delay in a hook to be kept at the mine for the purpose and accessible to the workmen, and shall be signed by the person who made the examination. The part of General Regulation 131 relevant to this question requires the appointment in writing by the Manager of an electrician to supervise and be responsible for the thorough examination of all apparatus as often as may be necessary to prevent danger, and to keep at the mine a logbook in the prescribed form and General Regulation 132 requires that in any part of a mine in which inflammable gas, although not normally present, is likely to occur in quantity sufficient to be indicative of danger, all cables, apparatus, signalling wires and signalling instruments shall be constructed, installed, protected, worked and maintained, so that in the normal working thereof there shall be no risk of open sparking. The application to the particular case of shot-firing cables of these wide general provisions is in a state of confusion and doubt which needs to he cleared up. For practical purposes, the correct procedure would be to make the shot-firer responsible for the general condition of the shot-firing cable which he is using. That, however, would not ensure safety. No matter how carefully the cable was examined nor how frequently it was renewed, there would still remain what is the most serious danger attending its use, namely, the possibility of a spark occurring between the bared ends of the leads where attached to the detonator lends, should these leads come in contact and then separate whilst current was flowing. Safety can only be fully ensured by so constructing the exploder that any spark produced in the shot-firing circuit is inherently incapable of igniting firedamp. If this can be ensured, then the insulation of the cable and its periodic examination are relatively unimportant from the safety point of view. (2) Subsection 5 of Section 62 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, requires that the roads shall be examined daily and a report (to be recorded in a book kept at the mine for the purpose made on heir condition as to coal dust and on the steps taken to mitigate danger arising therefrom. The question arose whether this subsection is still in force or not. The position is that the General Regulations of 30th July, 1920, were amended by the General Regulations of 20th November, 1924, which became operative on 1st January, 1925. These amending Regulations required, in addition to posting the results of the tests of dust samples at the pithead as previously required, a record of these results to he kept at the mine in a book to be prescribed for the purpose. For convenience that book as then prescribed embodied the prescribed report under Section 62 (5) of the Act, on the steps taken to mitigate danger arising from coal dust. The contents of the latter report were completely changed as the circumstances in which the previous Report Book was prescribed had been altered by the amended Regulations. (3) In the Auchinraith mine, the firemen Were provided with flame safety-lamps and electric safety-lamps. The question arises whether this is a sound practice. In my view it is. A fireman's duties are not confined to making examinations for gas he has also to examine the roof and to make this examination properly he requires a lamp which can he tilted in any direction, and this he can only obtain by using some kind of electric lamp. The following is a quotation from Memorandum No. 9 of the Miners' Lamps Committee :— "38. The combination of a flame lamp fitted with an internal relighter and a pocket electric lamp seems to us an ideal one for a fireman, and we can think of no objection to such an arrangement that is not far out-weighed by its advantages. The fact that he would not be greatly inconvenienced if he lost his light whilst testing for gas would lend him confidence in making such tests and would in some instances tend towards a more thorough and accurate examination being made. There could be no temptation for him to complete his round with the electric torch alone and he could, in our opinion, be trusted not to relight his lamp when such an action might he dangerous." In view of the great number of accidents from falls of ground, and the necessity for the best possible light to assist towards a reduction in that number, and so, looking at the question from a wider aspect than when giving evidence in 1920 before the Miners Lamps Committee — I am quoted at the end of paragraph 39 of Memorandum No. 9 — I am entirely in agreement with the opinions expressed in paragraph 38 which I have quoted, with the exception that I would add after the words "pocket, electric lamp" the words "or other electric safety-lamp." At Auchinraith mine, the manager at one time supplied the firemen with flame safety-lamps fitted with an internal relighter. They, he said, did not like them because, being longer than the ordinary type of flame safety-lamp, they trailed on the ground when the firemen were crawling along the face with the lamp hung on to the strap round their necks. The firemen were also not very successful in manipulating the relighter. One of the firemen, in his evidence, said that the lamps fitted with relighters were very easily put out by concussion when firing shots. I would like to put on record my admiration of the conduct of the men who were at work in the section and who remained after the explosion to render whatever aid they could — especially in this connection should I mention John Wailes. Also I would like to mention the expedition with which the Rescue Corps at Coatbridge, seven miles distant from the colliery, answered the call for help. The call was received at 9-5 and at 9-30 they were down the pit. I also desire to acknowledge the very helpful assistance given to me by the representatives of all the parties.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||