|
16th May 1931, Page: 348, Column: 1 Grove (Brownhills) ExplosionMines Inspector's FindingThe explosion at Grove (Brownhills) Colliery, Brownhills, Staffs, on 1st October last, when 14 persons were killed, was "caused by a naked light used in connection with smoking, which ignited a considerable accumulation of firedamp." This is the finding of Mr. F. H. Wynne, Deputy Chief Inspector of Mines, who held a formal investigation in pursuance of Section 83 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, into the causes and circumstances of the explosion. At the inquest the jury found that the fourteen men met their deaths as a result of an explosion, but there was not sufficient conclusive evidence to prove how the explosion occurred, adding the rider: "We consider that fireman Ashford carried out his duties efficiently." Mr. Wynne in his report (H.M. Stationery Office, 9d. net) describes the workings in the Shallow Coal seam in which the explosion occurred. During normal working, there were workmen in the Shallow Coal district practically continuously throughout the day and night. There were, therefore, three firemen, one for each shift, day, afternoon and night respectively, but not all of each fireman's time was confined to the machine section. Each fireman had also to look after a small area of workings, in which the coal was hand got, near the foot of the cross-measure drifts, if and when work in that area was proceeding. On the day of the explosion coal getting had been temporarily suspended in the Shallow seam. During the morning shift the extraction of coal from No. 3 panel had been completed. Thereafter, the rest of the shift had been devoted to dismantling the conveyors and removing them from the old No. 3 face. The work of the afternoon shift had been organised with a view to completing the removal of the machinery to, and installing it in, the new face. The conditions before the explosion are dealt with, and it appears that during the afternoon shift of 1st October, the only persons below-ground were the fourteen men engaged in the Shallow Coal, none of whom survived the explosion, and one ostler who was engaged at the stables which are situated near the downcast shaft about 1¼ miles from the Shallow Coal workings. Since none of the effects of the explosion were felt at this distance outbye it is not known exactly at what time the explosion took place. But, judging by the amount of work that had been done, it seems likely that the time was somewhere between 9 and 9-30 p.m. This estimate is borne out to some extent by the fact that a watch found in the clothing of one of the deceased had stopped at 9-18. There was no conflict of opinion as to the point of origin of the explosion. It was agreed on all sides that the indications of the effects both of force and flame led to the new face as the starting point. It was also generally agreed that coal dust played little or no part in the explosion. That coal dust was burnt or partially burnt, however, is indicated by the fact that 11 of the 14 deaths were due, at least in part, to the effects of carbon monoxide and that this gas was present in considerable quantity in the afterdamp. It is perhaps superfluous to point out that before an explosion of firedamp can take place underground two things are essential, viz.: a mixture of firedamp and air in explosive proportions and a flame or other source of heat of sufficient temperature and duration to ignite that mixture. As to the presence of the explosive mixture, no difficulty in accounting for it arises, for although the history of this seam previous to the explosion pointed to almost total freedom from firedamp, experience immediately subsequent to and for a number of days after the explosion left no doubt as to the source of the inflammable gas. Mr. Wynne discusses the possible causes of the explosion, and whilst admitting the circumstantial nature of the evidence leading to his findings he says it was very strong. No spent match or partly smoked cigarette could be found in the new face, but the Inspector regards it as significant that out of a total of 14 persons six should be found to be carrying contraband and of these six, four were working in the new face where the explosion originated. In the face of this evidence and the absence of any other likely cause it is difficult indeed to reach any other conclusion than that firedamp was ignited by flame from a match struck for the purpose of smoking. In the course of his general remarks and conclusions Mr. Wynne says : "I find that the explosion was caused by a naked light, used in connection with smoking, which ignited a considerable accumulation of firedamp, the fringe of which extended into the new face. This accumulation of firedamp existed in the headings on the rise side of the new face and probably also in the goaf of the recently worked out panels to the left thereof. "No evidence was adduced to prove that the ventilation had been inadequate at any time prior to the explosion, or that inflammable gas had ever been detected in these workings. It is impossible to say how or when the accumulation of inflammable gas occurred, i.e., whether it was the result of a slow process of emission over a long period in the absence of ventilation to clear it away, or whether it was the result of a more or less sudden outburst shortly before the actual occurrence of the accident. In either event I associate the presence of the explosive mixture of firedamp and air in the new face with the temporary ventilation arrangements in the main level, i.e., the substitution of a brattice cloth inbye of Spout D for the doors which had been outbye thereof. I feel that it is not merely a coincidence that the firedamp appeared after the alteration had been made. I do not find, however, as I was urged to do by the Miners' Federation, that there is evidence to justify charging the management with a breach of Section 29 (1) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. At the same time, this is not to say that the ventilation arrangements were beyond criticism. On the contrary, I look upon single unchecked doors in a main haulage road as bad mining practice in any circumstances." With reference to the searching of workmen Mr. Wynne adds : "I would strongly recommend that no system of searching should be approved that does not include a provision for a complete search at fairly frequent but not regular intervals. Preferably, the searching should be carried out at the surface before the men enter the cage to descend the shaft. But it is evident that, in a pit working with naked lights, there are practical difficulties in the way of making an effective search at the surface, unless the persons working in safety-lamp areas can be kept entirely apart from their fellow workmen. "Although no evidence in support of the suggestion was adduced, it was urged strongly by the representatives of the Miners' Federation that the practice of using both naked lights and safety-lamps in the same mine should be prohibited, on the ground that confusion and, possibly, danger might arise through persons being drafted indiscriminately to a naked light or a safety-lamp area. On general grounds I have much sympathy with the suggestion. There is, for instance, a feeling among the Inspectors of Mines that discipline is better in a safety-lamp mine than in one in which mixed lights or naked lights are used. At the same time such prohibition would be very drastic and could only be put into force by a radical revision of Section 32 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, which relates to the use of safety-lamps. This Section of the Act appears to have been drafted specifically to permit the use of naked lights in parts of a mine where danger from inflammable gas is negligible, although safety-lamps may be required in other parts. On the whole, I do not think that so drastic a remedy is called for. Where the will to maintain discipline exists it should be possible to maintain it. "There is one further point which was also raised by the representatives of the Miners' Federation. They contended that if the men in the new face had been provided with facilities for testing for firedamp its presence would have been detected by them and they would have withdrawn from the place; or, at any rate, they would not have attempted to smoke, and there would have been no explosion. As a matter of fact, such facilities were provided, but were not used — one of the workmen in the face was a machineman to whom a flame safety-lamp had been issued, but he left the lamp in the main level when his work took him up to the new face. That being so, there appears to me to be nothing more to say as regards the general principle involved."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||