28th January 1931, Page: 5, Column: 7
"Show Your Cards"
High Court Story of Incidents at a Welsh Colliery
Lodge Members Sued
Allegation of Illegal Methods by Pickets
The hearing of the action arising out
of the complaints of "watching and
besetting" the premises of the Bedwas
Navigation Colliery Company (1921),
Ltd., in South Wales, was continued
before Mr. Justice Bennett in the
Chancery Division to-day.
The company asked for an injunction
to restrain Wm. John Milson (secretary
of the Bedwas Lodge of the Miners'
Federation), Wm. Britton, John Blackwell,
Idris Bowen, and 26 other members
of the Bedwas Lodge of the Miners'
Federation from watching and besetting
the company's premises, from obstructing
men desirous of working for the
company, and from procuring breaches
of contract on the part of the company's
employees.
Plaintiff's case was that all 30
defendants were engaged in an organised
conspiracy to prevent men going
down the pits unless they could satisfy
the pickets, and that what took place
was an abuse of the custom of show
cards, which had been held to be
impliedly incorporated in the men's
contract of service by the Conciliation
Board agreement, 1926.
The defendants contended that they
did nothing that was not authorised by
the Conciliation Board agreement, and
they denied the alleged conspiracy.
Lamp-House Picketed
Sir Gerald Hurst, for plaintiffs, said
that on February 24, when the show
of cards was to be held, Mr. Connick,
the company's manager, arrived at the
colliery at 5.25 a.m. he found the
lamp-house strongly picketed, and men
were unable to obtain their lamps.
That, in his submission, was the use
of an illegal means to cause the company
to break its contract with employees
who were entitled to draw lamps. All
the pickets were entitled to do was to
say to each workman, "Show me your
card? Are you a member of our lodge?
Are you in arrears?"
Counsel added that at the clock-house
where the surface workmen clocked-on
on February 24, similar scenes occurred.
A craftsman, named Rowles, was
told that "if he did not pay up his
arrears he would be thrown into the
reservoir."
The "show cards" continued until
February 29, and it was not until
March 1st that the colliery was clear of
pickets. On February 25 there was
"organised terrorism" which in one
case took the form of physical brutality.
A cripple, employed as a re-lighter
underground, was "knocked off his
crutches" by six or seven of the defendants
because he did not comply with
their requirements.
"Mushroom" Organisation
His Lordship asked if there was a
trade dispute in progress at the time of
the show of cards.
Mr. Upjohn: There is a dispute
whether non-unionists ought to work at
the colliery. That has been going
on all along. There are other unions, one
of which the Federation looks upon as
a mushroom.
His Lordship: A mushroom is an agreeable
thing.
Mr. Upjohn: It may be a poisonous
fungus. (Laughter.)
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bennett, —, Justice | | Judge | |
| Blackwell, John | | Miners' Rep. | |
| Bowen, Idris | | Miners' Rep. | |
| Britton, William | | Miners' Rep. | |
| Connick, — | | Colliery Manager | |
| Hurst, Gerald, Sir | | Q.C. | |
| Milson, William John | | Miners' Rep. | |
| Rowles, — | | Miner | |
| Upjohn, — | | Q.C. | |