|
27th December 1930, Page: 188, Column: 1 Report On Wath Main ExplosionsSeven men lost their lives and three others were injured in the explosions which occurred in the Billingley Drift District of the Barnsley Seam, Wath Main Colliery, Wath-on-Dearne, Yorkshire, on the 24th February, 1930. The Report by Sir Henry Walker, C.B.E., LL,D., H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, on the causes and circumstances attending the explosions, has been issued by the Mines Department. In the course of his general remarks Sir Henry says :— "Having regard to the conditions existing when the first explosion occurred and to the occurrence of that explosion, it might well be asked, Why was not the left bank of 30's ventilated by leading brattice from the right side of the gateway right across the left bank to near the fast side? . . . This suggestion was considered by the management but not adopted; instead, a wood door was erected in 62's, a yard or so further from the face than the brattice sheet already hanging across that road. So far as can be judged from the evidence of the deputies, the erection of this wood door had little effect on the ventilation in 30's left bank, and they continued to report the presence of firedamp just as they had done prior to the erection of the door. I am at a loss to understand how by the erection of the wood door in 62's the ventilation in 30's left bank would be improved." . . . "The necessity for the efficient ventilation of fast ends has been stressed again and again in official reports. There is nothing In the evidence to suggest that, so far as legal requirements are concerned, the ventilation in 30's left bank was not in order, but legal requirements cannot cover every point of detail. Something is of necessity left to the judgment of those in charge of, and those engaged in, mining operations, but to have fast ends in a mine where safety-lamps are required unprovided with means for causing a current of air to sweep through is not in accordance with good mining practice. In addition to the provision of a brattice in 30's left bank, I consider that the goaf between 30's gate road and the Billingley Fault should have been packed tight. It was stated in evidence that this had been tried some ten or twelve years ago and had failed. . . Had the goaf been packed tight there would have been no cavities in which firedamp could accumulate and be forced out by falls. Moreover, from the evidence given by Mr. H. J. Humphrys, it is the general custom in mines in South Yorkshire to pack solid the goaf on rib sides or on gob sides; and 30's left bank, bounded as it was by the Billingley Fault, thus was similar to such a place." With reference to the manner in which the deputies made their reports Sir Henry says : "They each made a report of the inspections made by them prior to a shift of workmen coming into the district to work. They wrote these reports at the meeting station fixed under Section 63 in what was referred to during the Inquiry as a "memorandum book," and later, after their arrival at the surface, Wrote out what was intended to be an exactly similar report in the book prescribed (Mines and Quarries Form No. 42) for the entry of deputies' reports. According to the manager, the memorandum books, which consist of some 36 pages of octavo size with printed matter on each side exactly as is to be found in the prescribed form of report for deputies, were used because of the inconvenience of carrying the prescribed book into and out of the district each shift. This may be, but the weakness of the system in use, which was illegal, was that there was no guarantee that the report entered in the prescribed form was precisely the same as that entered in the memorandum book. There was evidence that one deputy had added to his report in the prescribed book several hours after he had entered the report. I do not consider that the contraventions of the Act in regard to the inspections made by the deputies nor. in the use of these memorandum books had any bearing on the occurrence of the explosions, but I do think that a much too complacent attitude was adopted by the higher officials in regard to the long continued reports of the presence of firedamp in or about 30's left bank."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||