Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

6th September 1930, Page: 56, Column: 2

Qualifications Of Colliery Officials

Report of Committee of Inquiry

Appointed in July, 1928, by the Secretary for Mines, the Committee of Inquiry into the Qualifications of Colliery Officials has now issued its Report. With Sir Thomas Holland, K.C.S.I., K.C.I.E., F.R.S., in the capacity of chairman, the members of the committee included originally Mr. W. R. Davies, C.B., Mr. (now Sir) Alfred E. Faulkner, C.B., C.B.E., Mr. Douglas Hay, Mr. Joseph Jones, Mr. Mungo Mackay, Sir Richard A. S. Redmayne, K.C.B., Mr. H. J. Stone, the Rt. Hon. Stephen Walsh, M.P., and Mr. W. D. Woolley. In August, 1929, Mr. John McGurk, J.P., was appointed a member of the Committee vice the Rt. Hon. Stephen Walsh, deceased. The Report (H.M. Stationery Office, 2s. net) reviews, in detail, the history and working of the present system of training, examination and recruitment of the managerial and supervisory staffs in coal mines and makes numerous recommendations for improving that system to meet the needs of the industry and the progress of education.

As regards the statutory examination for first and second class certificates of competency (managers' and under-managers' certificates), the Committee's recommendations include proposals for a preliminary test of the candidate's general education, for a more comprehensive oral examination and for the raising of the written examination standard in certain subjects.

As regards surveyors, changes of a more fundamental character are proposed, involving the creation of a higher grade of mine surveyor's certificate, and the introduction of a statutory requirement that the accuracy of mine plans shall be checked, at certain stages, by or under the effective personal supervision of a person possessing the higher grade certificate.

For "firemen, examiners and deputies," the Committee recommend, for the present, alternative means of qualification the first by way of an oral examination of a practical character on matters falling within the scope of the fireman's statutory duties, including shot-firing; and the second by way of a written and oral examination of a distinctly higher technical standard. Persons qualifying by the first method would be eligible for appointment at the age of 25, and by the second at the age of 23, upon the completion in each case of a term of approved practical experience.

The Committee further recommend that shot-firers should qualify under precisely the same conditions as firemen, and that the examinations should be conducted by local examination authorities whose work should be co-ordinated by a Central Authority.

The Committee advocate three alternative qualifications for overmen, the minimum age of appointment to be governed by the standard of the technical examination passed by the candidate. Thus holders of 1st or 2nd class certificates of competency would be eligible for appointment at the age of 23, while persons holding a fireman's certificate granted on a purely oral examination would be required to serve at least two years as a fireman before appointment as overman at the minimum age of 27. Between the two, provision is made for the appointment, at the age of 24, of persons without previous service as firemen, who have obtained a fireman's certificate by passing the more difficult written and oral examination referred to above.

The Committee express the opinion that the time has come for the duties of mechanical and electrical staffs to be defined by statute or regulations and that subsequently the question of requiring appropriate statutory qualifications should receive consideration.

The Committee are impressed with the need for closer cooperation between the teachers of mining subjects on the one hand, and the Board for Mining Examinations on the other, and make certain proposals to that end.

In view of the importance of the question it may be assumed that the Report will command wide attention. In their Introduction the Committee say that at the outset of their inquiry it was necessary for them to determine the interpretation to be placed upon the term "officials of mines." They explain that there are two main classes of officials those who may be described as "general officials" whose main business is the management of the mine or the conduct of its routine operations, and those who are specifically engaged on more strictly technical services associated with the mine. Comprised in the former category are the manager and the under-manager, the official variously designated the fireman, deputy or examiner, and the official who is nowhere specifically referred to in the Coal Mines Act, but who is customarily termed overman. On the technical side are the electricians who supervise the electrical apparatus and carry out certain other duties specified in the regulations, the mechanical engineer and mechanics, who exercise somewhat similar duties with regard to the machinery, and the surveyor, who must, by law, prepare, or supervise the preparation of, the working plan of the mine. Finally there is the shot-firer, whose duties are in part general and in part technical. It is to these officials to whom specifically the Committee decided to devote their attention.

In the historical review of the introduction and development of the system of examinations it is recalled that the introduction into the code of mining legislation of the requirement that mine managers should attain a prescribed standard of competency occurred in 1872. The starting point of this important innovation was the Darley Main Colliery explosion in 1849. The first Government Inspector, reporting upon the disaster, emphasised the lack of qualifications of persons entrusted with the management of collieries in the Barnsley district, and stated that both owners and workmen were in favour of appointing a Commission to examine candidates for underground management and to grant certificates of competency. Nothing tangible resulted however, but a series of colliery disasters which followed deeply impressed the public mind and inspired the Miners' National Association (the predecessor of the Miners' Association, of Great Britain) to present to Parliament, in 1864, a petition urging among other things :—

That all agents, overmen, or chief managers of mines be subjected to a scientific examination, and that a certificate of competency be given by some qualified person, or Board of Examiners, as your Honourable House may be pleased to direct, previous to any mine being placed in their charge.

In response to the petition the House appointed a Select Committee which, whilst not denying the advantage of some elementary scientific knowledge required of officials, deemed it inexpedient to accede to the miners' suggestion, and they dismissed the subject. However, the public conscience had been stirred and Bills embodying the miners' proposals were successively introduced in 1869, 1870 and 1871, Finally, a Bill was introduced in 1872, and was referred to a conference at which the Government, the Mining Association and the Miners' National Association were represented. Some measure of agreement was reached and the Bill which eventually stabilised mining laws for a period of fifteen years was passed without any great alteration.

The Act provided that mines of coal, stratified ironstone, shale and fireclay should be under the control and daily supervision of a manager who should for the time being be registered as the holder of a certificate under the Act.

Normally small mines were excepted and the interests of existing managers were preserved by the power to issue certificates of service. The administrative duties in connection with the examination of candidates and the award of certificates were assigned to district boards. Twelve (later eleven) examination boards were established by the Home Office, and one examination was held by each board annually, though not concurrently. The system was open to criticism on the ground that it failed to secure uniformity either in the practical qualifications of the candidate or in the standard of examination, the not unnatural result of examination machinery conducted by different boards having wide discretion, on more or less independent lines. It was, indeed, not an infrequent practice for a candidate who had failed to satisfy the examiners at one centre to proceed forthwith to another which was supposed to favour a lower standard. Nevertheless, the system persisted for fifteen years undisturbed and with some modifications in detail for another twenty-five years.

The Act of 1887 introduced the distinction between first and second class certificates for managers and under-managers respectively, the effect of which was undoubtedly to raise the qualifications of managers both in practical experience and scientific knowledge.

An important modification was introduced by the Coal Mines Amendment Act of .1903, under which three years' experience and a diploma or degree in mining from an Institution approved by the Secretary of State were to be accepted in lieu of five years' practical experience as a qualification of candidature. Thus for the first time tangible recognition was given to university training.

The history of modern legislation on the subject began with the appointment on the 7th of June, 1906, of a Royal Commission "to enquire into and report on certain questions relating to the health and safety of miners, and the administration of the Mines Acts." The majority of the proposals of the Commission were incorporated in a Coal Mines Bill which was presented to Parliament on the 15th of March, 1911. Provision was made for the replacement of the district boards by a Central Board consisting of not more than fifteen persons and constituted much on the same lines as the old boards, with the addition of one or more persons possessing special qualifications. The constitution of the Board was subsequently confirmed in the Act, and since 1911 has consisted of seventeen persons, of whom six are representative of owners or agents of mines or managers of mines or mining engineers, six are representative of workmen employed in mines, with the addition of the chief inspector and two divisional inspectors of mines, and two persons eminent in mining and scientific knowledge.

The development of the examination system since the passing of the Act of 1911 has been promoted by a series of Statutory Rules made by, or with the consent of, the Secretary of State, and after the passing of the Mining Industry Act, 1920, by, or with the consent of, the Board of Trade. Under these rules the examination scheme has been extended to embrace another class of colliery official, namely, the Surveyor. Similarly, the Board for Mining Examinations, with the approval of the Board of Trade, has laid down, and from time to time modified and amplified, its requirements as to the qualifications of applicants for certificates and as to the manner in which the examinations are to be conducted.

The Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1850, first made it compulsory for owners to keep accurate plans of their workings, but it was not until 1912 that any statutory provision was made for ensuring that the preparation and maintenance of the plans should be in competent hands.

Prescribed qualifications were issued in an order made by the Secretary of State on the 27th of February, 1912, under which the examinations for surveyors' certificates were entrusted to the Board for Mining Examinations and to a number of "approved institutions" whose certificates were equally valid.

In 1921 the standard was raised, a minimum age limit of twenty-one years was fixed, and four years' practical experience was required of candidates not holding an approved degree or diploma, or not having passed satisfactorily the full surveying course of an approved institution.

The system of multiple qualifying authorities was not entirely satisfactory, and two years later it was abolished. Thereafter the Board for Mining Examinations was constituted the sole examining body, and the written part of the examinations for Mine Surveyors' Certificates has since been held concurrently with the examinations for Certificates of Competency. The Board, however, continues to accept the possession of a degree or diploma issued by an approved institution or the satisfactory completion of a full course of instruction in mine surveying as equivalent to two of the four years' practical experience required.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Davies, W. R.      
Faulkner, Alfred E.      
Hay, Douglas      Whos Who Page
Holland, Thomas, Sir      
Jones, Joseph      
Mackay, Mungo      
McGurk, John      Whos Who Page
Redmayne, Richard Augustine Studdart, Sir      Whos Who Page
Stone, H. J.      
Walsh, Stephen, Rt. Hon.      
Woolley, William Downing      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print