|
31st May 1930, Page: 360, Column: 2 Steel Pit PropsDiscussion of Types. Paper No. 58* of the Safety in Mines Research Board on Steel Pit Props provides a discussion of individual props that have been tested, but the testing of other types is proceeding and in due course another Paper may be the outcome of the additional inquiries. The rigid props tested and discussed are the steel tube (with timber filling), the "Chatham," and the steel joist ; the yielding props being the "Butterley," "S.F.," "Tait," "Berrisford," steel tube (with tapered wood plug), "Sarre," "S.A.M.," "Mureaux," "Schwarz," and "Ruhr." In a recent issue (p.p. 330-331) the general comments of the Authors of Paper 58, showing the advantages of steel props, were given in some detail. In view of the importance of the question under discussion further references to the Paper may be of service, as below. The yield load and the amount of shortening before the prop becomes rigid, are the most important characteristics of a yielding prop and are the data used when comparing different kinds of yielding props. Speaking generally, the load-shortening curve for most yielding props consists of a sloping initial portion up to the yield load followed by a more or less horizontal portion, during which shortening proceeds under a nearly constant load. In taking the yield load as a characteristic of the props it must be remembered that in many cases the load borne by the prop increases considerably as the shortening progresses, so that the yield load values may be considerably below the resistance of the prop at later stages in its shortening. It may be questioned whether the value of the yield load and of the resistance of the prop at subsequent stages in the test may not be influenced by the speed of the testing machine, or the rate at which the prop is strained. Some experiments made on a Schwarz prop showed that the resistance of the prop was not appreciably altered by increasing the rate of straining from 0.109 to 0.61 inch per minute. The effect of sudden violent increases in load, such as may be caused by "cramps" at the face, on the resistance of yielding props has not been investigated. The "Butterley" prop has a low margin between yield load and buckling load, hence prop failures might be expected to be relatively frequent. But, in practice, the wastage is only 3½ per cent. per annum (including props lost) because of the high value of the yield load, and the special attention paid to yearly withdrawal. The low yield load values shown by the Continental props are very striking in view of the fact that they have been and are being used with great success abroad. The smallness of the yield loads and the large amounts of shortening under these small loads have given rise to the impression that the Continental props tested would be of little use for maintaining the necessary height of the face in British mines under present conditions. The Authors have had an opportunity of discussing this point with several mining engineers in the Westphalian coalfield and have been informed that success in the use of yielding steel props ("Schwarz") depends on the rate of advance of the face and upon the thoroughness of the packing. At one large colliery (Westfalian) the use of steel props has had to be discontinued because the rate of advance of the faces fell below 5 ft. in two days. At the other three pits which the investigators visited the faces with steel props advance one cut every day in thin seams, and every two days in seams of medium thickness. Some German mining engineers are convinced that the best face support for Westphalian conditions is one which begins to yield under a load of about 5 tons, thus allowing the roof to bend down and to develop its pressure on the coal face. Regular and solid packing carried up close to the face is an essential condition for the use of yielding props, as without it the props would either be shut up, or the roof would break off behind the last row of props. In Germany special care is taken to avoid any breakage of this nature, since it is considered that the break would relieve the coal face of a great deal of the pressure, and render the coal much harder to work. The Authors' observations, admittedly limited, in certain British collieries where small areas of workings are solidly packed, showed that in these areas the roof settlement took place more regularly and gradually than in adjoining areas where the goaf was only partially packed. The roof conditions generally were better, because the roof developed fewer breaks, and in some cases was quite free of them, whilst the coal was easier to work. It has been stated that a fair amount of experience has already been gained in the use of steel props. Those who have adopted them, however, are still but a small minority, and it is not unreasonable to anticipate further improvements in design and method of employment as the use of steel props extends. Steel offers scope for variations of form which it is not possible to obtain with timber. Effect on Accident Rate. — Where steel props have been used in Great Britain there has been a marked freedom from reportable accidents from falls of roof. In Scotland the introduction of the steel tube prop at Newbattle Colliery as part of a systematic method of intensive mining, together with the use of steel straps at the face and steel arches on the roads, has effected a great reduction in the number of accidents from falls of ground. Only three reportable accidents occurred during the five years since the completion of the system in 1919 until the end of 1924, during which time 1,700,000 man-shifts were worked — less than two accidents per million man-shifts, the comparable rate for the whole of Scotland being about ten. On the quick-moving machine-cut and conveyor faces, supported by steel tube props and steel straps, at Watergate Colliery, Durham, and Broomhill Colliery, Northumberland, there have been very few reportable accidents from falls of roof. At Ashington Colliery, Northumberland, very few reportable accidents have occurred where steel props are in use. At Bentley Colliery, South Yorkshire, where only steel joist props are used, the number of reportable accidents from falls of roof at the face is small. It is fair to add in this case that mines using wood props in the same neighbourhood have low accident rates also. The mines in Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire using the "Butterley" steel props show a remarkable freedom from accident. In working places where this prop has been in use only one reportable accident due to a fall of roof (a non-fatal accident) occurred during the nine years from the adoption of the prop until the date of the inquiry, during which time 979,138 man-shifts were worked. In the working places using timber props 87 reportable accidents due to falls of ground occurred during the same period, when 7,093,678 man-shifts were worked, or one reportable accident per 81,536 man-shifts. The use of the "S.F." prop at Cannock Chase Colliery shows equally good results. During the fourteen months ending November, 1928, 100,000 tons of coal were won without any accident from falls. Cost of Steel Props. — The price of a steel prop is, of course, a good deal higher than the price of a wood prop, but the steel prop can be used over and over again almost indefinitely, whereas the wood prop only lasts for one or two settings. The subsequent expenditure where steel props are employed consists of the cost of repairing damaged props, replacing props lost or damaged beyond repair, and to a small extent the cost of extra supervision and extra lids. Bent props can be straightened at the colliery; when damaged beyond repair they have a value as scrap. If the type of steel prop selected be one which is suitable to the working conditions, and if proper attention be paid to the Betting and withdrawing of the props, the expenditure on repairs and replacements will be low, and the introduction of the steel prop will show an appreciable reduction in costs even in the first year, the reduction becoming much greater in the second and subsequent years. The saving will normally be greater with the longer props because steel props do not increase in price so much as wood props for a given increase in length. One of the factors having a bearing on the local success of steel props economically is the absence of debris at the working face. A dirty floor increases the difficulty of withdrawing the props and the risk of losing them. Replacements in several instances amount to 50 per cent. per annum, but even when this figure rises to 300 per cent. per annum a saving in cost of material is effected. When it is remembered that timber props often are only set once at the face, the loss of 50 per cent. of the steel props per annum becomes relatively a small matter. For example, in the case of a face on which 100 props are set every day for 245 days a year, 24,500 timber props would be used in a year assuming that all of them were lost or broken at the first setting, whereas only 50 steel props would be consumed, that is, 490 timber props to every steel prop. At Newbattle Colliery, the cost of the steel tube props, including the cost of the steel straps, is only 1.75d. per ton of coal produced. At Watergate Colliery the estimated saving due to the use of steel tube props and steel straps amounts to over 2d. a ton. At the Bolsover Colliery Company's two mines the cost per ton for steel joist props is very much below that for timber props. At Bentley Colliery the cost of the steel joist props is 0.58d. per ton; this includes flanging one end of the props, extra wood lids, straightening damaged props and the cost of extra supervision; the estimated saving is nearly 3d. a ton. Recent information shows that at the Butterley Company's collieries the saving by the use of the "Butterley" prop amounts to about 1.5d. per ton. At Cannock Chase Colliery the cost of the "S.F." prop is 1.2d. per ton ; this includes interest on capital outlay, the cost of straightening and replacements, but excludes the cost of wood plugs and lids; there is a saving of 9d. a ton as compared to the cost of timber. At Penallta Colliery the "Tait" prop has reduced the cost two-thirds as compared with timber props. * Steel Pit Props, by T. Ashley, S. M. Dixon and M. A. Hogan (Price 1s, net, H.M. Stationery Office)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||