|
20th March 1930 Miners' Phthisis?Strange Death At PitA Doctor's OpinionA Cleator Moor Inquest The inquest was resumed by Dr. G. A. L. Skerry at Cleator Moor on Tuesday, on Ben Hardisty (58), iron ore miner, 9, Trumpet Road, Cleator, who died on Wednesday week at Crowgarth Mine, Cleator Moor. Mr. W. Butler, H.M Inspector of Mines; Mr. F. Higher, manager at Crowgarth; Mr. Lightfoot, solicitor, representing Lord Leconfield; and Mr. C. Edmonds, representing the relatives of the deceased, were also present. The Coroner said that at the previous hearing John Fisher Hardisty, son of the deceased, said his father had worked for a time in South Africa and suffered from miners' phthisis. In answer to the Coroner on Tuesday, Mr. Hardisty said his father had never had an allowance from the Miners' Phthisis Board, as he could not get his papers through. Thomas Nixon, underground manager at Crowgarth, said that Mr. Hardisty had been given light work as a wagon picker on the surface. At 10.30 a.m., last Wednesday witness saw Mr. Hardisty having his lunch in the cabin. There was an eight ton wagon on the weighbridge and witness offered to help him to "bar" it down. He did so. Mr. Hardisty just pushed the wagon and coupled it up to the other wagons. It was not a heavy job. Immediately afterwards Mr. Hardisty came out on the line and started to cough. Witness paid little attention to it as he had had three bad coughing bouts previously that morning. Witness had just been in the warehouse a short time when Mr. Hardisty came in and fell against the partition. Witness caught him and found him bleeding freely from the nose and mouth. He died five minutes later. Dr. Eaton arrived in fifteen minutes. In answer to Mr. Edmonds, witness said Mr. Hardisty made no complaint about having strained himself. Dr. A. Reid, Egremont, said he had been attending Mr. Hardisty during the last 12 months, first for acute bronchitis and then for chronic bronchitis. He advised him not to go underground, but to obtain lighter work on the surface. Witness could not say whether he had miners' phthisis or not without an X-ray examination and this Mr. Hardisty would not undergo. It was difficult to prove miners' phthisis because the symptoms were so similar to chronic bronchitis symptoms. Death, in his opinion, was due to haemorrhage of the lungs, which could be brought on from coughing or from no apparent cause. It was quite a natural termination for chronic bronchitis. Mr. Edmonds asked whether a post-mortem would have cleared up the miners' phthisis question, and witness said he was not consulted. Very likely it would. A verdict of "Death from haemorrhage of the lungs" was returned. Mr. Hardisty was one of the ten men who were entombed for 28 hours and escaped unhurt when an extensive fall of the roof occurred in Lord Leconfield's Croft Pit, Bigrigg in November 1924.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||