8th March 1930, Page: 272, Column: 1
Economiser In Boiler Installations
In his paper on "The Value of the Economiser in Present-day
Boiler Installations" prepared for the meeting on the
22nd of February of the North of England Institute of Mining
and Mechanical Engineers, Mr. G. E. Tansley said the effect of
present-day boiler-house practice on the value of the economiser
as an investment has been discussed from many angles, but it
has not been discussed from every angle in any one particular
contribution. Much has been said regarding the preheating of
feed-water by other means and the consequent reduction in
efficiency of economiser heating-surface, but the arguments have
not been developed in order to introduce such factors as the
following: (a) Higher boiler pressures. (b) Higher boiler outlet-gas
temperatures. (c) Higher permissible economiser water-outlet
temperatures. (d) Longer economiser life due to higher
feed-inlet temperatures. (e) Increased gas velocities, which
mean (1) increased economiser efficiencies, (2) increased cleanliness,
(3) reduction in capital outlay for a given duty, and (4)
longer life of machine.
Apart altogether from the purely technical standpoint, it is
Mr. Tansley's opinion that a complete revision of methods of
arriving at the real monetary value of an investment in any economic
apparatus would be advantageous, as it would remove such
problems from the somewhat rule-of-thumb methods in use to-day
to more logical methods introducing essential factors. The usual
methods in arriving at this value is to charge 6 per cent. on the
capital to be laid out and 10 per cent. depreciation, adding these
charges to the usual running charges and debiting the apparatus
with the total, which is then deducted from the gross saving
in order to obtain the net saving and the probable number of
years in which the apparatus will have repaid its initial cost.
A much more logical method is to look at the problem from
the standpoint of a life of from one to fifteen or twenty years,
and to plot two columns of figures, the first giving the accrued
value for each year of the capital sum if it had been left to earn
interest, and the other the accrued value of the gross savings
(less running charges) on the basis that these savings themselves
would be earning interest on a compound basis during the whole
life of the economiser. In this manner, so to speak, a bird's-eye
view can be formed regarding the value of an investment at any
time during the life of such an apparatus.
Life of Economiser.
It is not generally understood, said Mr. Tansley, that the life of
an economiser is to a very large extent dependent upon the feed-inlet
temperature being sufficiently high to prevent condensation
on the tube surfaces. It is fairly well known that the temperature
of the metal is at practically the same temperature as the water
contents. If, therefore, the temperature of the feed-water is at
any time below the dew-point temperature of the gases at that
time, the moisture in the gases will condense on the external tube
surfaces, and this, in conjunction with sulphur, will accelerate
wastage. If the temperature of the feed-water is very low and
the gases are passing the surface at a low velocity, thus giving
a longer time of contact, condensation will be extensive. If, on
the other hand, the feed inlet temperature is high or the gases
are passing at a high velocity, condensation will be non-existent;
and if it were not for deterioration when the economiser is out
of commission there is hardly any reason why its useful life should
not be prolonged indefinitely. In connection with those plants
where the feed-water is heated by means of steam bled from the
turbine, the feed water is often not only above dew-point temperature,
but also at a higher temperature than atmospheric steam,
with the result that steam-blowers can be used without causing
extra condensation or wastage. Under these conditions a life
of twenty years for a cast-iron economiser might reasonably be
looked for, and this would mean depreciation losses of only 5 per
cent. Under the existing basis of calculation where a 10-per-cent.
depreciation is adopted, the economiser project would consequently
not receive fair consideration, especially if, in addition to charging
a depreciation loss of 10 per cent., one had omitted to calculate
what the real saving would have been on the basis that the annual
earnings of the economiser had been themselves invested at the
same rate of interest as was charged against the original outlay.
This method of calculation demonstrates to a remarkable degree
how the increase in feed-inlet temperature, while militating against
the economiser in the sense that it reduces temperature difference
between gas and water, on the other hand enhances its value,
as it tends to prolong its useful life.
Economiser and Boiler Pressure.
As compared with a few years ago, Mr. Tansley explained,
economisers are now working under very much safer conditions.
The cast-iron of which they are now constructed is 50 per cent.
stronger than that in use in the past, and for higher pressures
the old friction joint has made way for a positive joint capable
of withstanding any pressure likely to be met with in the near
future. The old reciprocating pump, with its sudden increase
in pressure at the end of every stroke, has been partly superseded
by the centrifugal pump, any increase in pressure from which is
gradual, and therefore of a static as opposed to a dynamic nature.
Hammer action at higher boiler pressure is practically eliminated,
as this in most cases in the past has been traced to overheating
and small steam-pockets, which naturally form much more readily
at a low pressure than at a high pressure. As an example, it may
be stated that the amount of sensible heat required to bring 1 pound
of water up to steam temperature at a pressure of 100 pounds
is only 298 B.Th.U's, as compared with 469 at a pressure of 600
pounds. When, in addition to this, it is realised that the
temperature of steam at a pressure of 000 pounds is 487° Fahr.,
which is very often approaching the temperature of the flue-gases
in contact with the economiser tubes, it will be at once recognised
that considerable time would have to elapse before trouble could
result from steam formation. Looking at the problem as it affects
the cast-iron economiser, provided the initial factor of safety
remains the same, the conditions are therefore really very much
better with high-pressure than with low-pressure boilers. This
may sound paradoxical, but it is nevertheless true.
Mr. Tansley said in conclusion that generally speaking, when
using cast-iron economisers it is, of course, inadvisable to
install more heating-surface than would be required under ordinary
working conditions to raise the temperature of the water to within
30° or 40° Fahr. of the steam-temperature corresponding to boiler
pressure but with the advent of the Foster economiser, with its
steel inner tube, it is now not only sound practice to raise the water
to at least steam-temperature before entering the boiler, but it
is practicable to actually generate steam in the hotter portions
of the economiser.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Tansley, G. E. | | | |