16th November 1929, Page: 136, Column: 2
"House" Discusses Mining Accidents
In the House of Commons on Wednesday, 6th November,
Mr. Gordon Macdonald (Lab.) called attention to accidents in mines,
and moved: "That this House deplores the heavy loss of life
and the large number of non-fatal accidents in coal mines, and is
of opinion that every possible step should be taken without delay
to secure the fullest protection possible to those engaged in this
dangerous industry. In the course of his remarks Mr. Macdonald
said that mining conditions had been revolutionised since the
Act of 1911 by the introduction of improved machinery for
different purposes. There should, therefore, be a committee of
inquiry on which all interests would be represented set up to
consolidate the statutory orders issued since that year and to frame
an up-to-date Mines Regulation Act.
Sir Herbert Samuel (L.) said that the total death-rate from
accidents below ground had for a number of years, unhappily,
remained very constant. This was also the case in regard to
deaths from falls of roof, which last year were responsible for about
500 deaths. The ratio of haulage accidents had remained unaltered
during the last fifty years, and last year 230 men were
killed from this cause. How vast the totals of accidents were
was proved by the fact that the mining industry paid in workmen's
compensation no less than £3,000,000 a year, an average
charge of 3d. on each ton of coal produced. It was clearly
the human duty on the part of the industry and of the State to
co-operate in reducing still further these statistics. Pointing out
that the longer hours worked must necessarily mean a larger
number of accidents owing to the longer exposure to risk,
Sir H. Samuel said the Royal Commission over which he presided came
to the conclusion that the only right basis for calculation of accidents
was the number of man-shifts — that was, to multiply the number
of shifts by the number of men. The increase of machinery and
of electricity certainly did introduce new dangers, to which he was
sure the Mines Department was alive, but it would be an extreme
course to exclude them on that account, and he doubted whether
the economic difficulties of the industry would permit of a measure
of that character. As a matter of fact, the number of accidents
due to electricity had up to the present been remarkably small.
Commodore King (C.) agreed as to the large number of accidents
caused by falls of ground and by haulage and he welcomed the
recent decision of the Miners' Welfare Committee to devote money
to research. A year ago he remarked how struck he had been
at the number of accidents which might have been avoided if the
miners themselves acted on safety-first principles. All he desired
was to impress on the mineworker the need for trying himself to
avoid danger. He would always give the Minister any support
he could in any effort to secure the safety of the mines.
Other members contributed to the discussion, and Mr. Ben Turner
(Secretary for Mines) regretted to say that the improvement
in the number of fatal accidents shown in 1928 had not so
far been maintained this year, and that the figures had gone back
to the old mark of over 1,000. It was impossible to be complacent
about such a position, and every effort must be made to effect a
reduction. As to the work of the inspectors, Mr. Turner said that
he and his colleagues had been accused of "joy-riding" during
the recess. There was no joy-riding in mines. It was dark,
disagreeable work for all concerned. It was the intention of the
Department to appoint additional electrical inspectors of mines
whose duty would be mainly to inspect electrical plant below
ground. He hoped four, including one at the head office. Dealing
with the causes of accidents, he said he did not like to see blame
cast upon workmen and deputies who could not tell the true story
because they were dead. He believed the fascination for the god
of output was largely responsible. Concluding, Mr. Turner said
that in his prayers every night he prayed for the welfare of miners.
"I wonder," he said, "why owners and men cannot work more
closely together. I cannot see why mine-owners and men should
not meet frequently together to consider important questions
affecting the industry and to work out changes which will make
coal-mining more free from accident than to-day."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| King, —, Commodore | | M.P. | |
| MacDonald, Gordon | | M.P. | |
| Samuel, Herbert, Sir | | M.P. | |
| Turner, Ben | | Secretary for Mines | |