Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

10th August 1929, Page: 20, Column: 1

Mines Report For 1928

The eighth annual report of the Secretary for Mines for the year 1928 has been issued as a Blue-book together with the report of the Chief Inspector of Mines for the same period (5s. 6d. net, H.M. Stationery Office). This report, although issued after the appointment of the present Secretary for Mines, is, of course, the report of his predecessor in office, who states that although some improvement in the coal trade was discernible towards the end of the year the results for 1928 taken as a whole were as disappointing as those for 1927. "The record of the earlier months of 1929," the report adds, "holds out a promise that the worst stages of the depression have passed, and that the efforts to increase the efficiency of the industry are already bearing some fruit. The total output in 1928 was 237,500,000 tons. This was about 13,750,000 tons less than in 1927, and about 5,750,000 tons less than in 1925." Output was less ; shipments of coal abroad were slightly less : there was a substantial reduction in the number of men employed, in spite of which, until the latter part of the year, there was greater irregularity of working, and the excess of costs of production over proceeds was twice as great as in 1927. On the other hand, the average price of all coal showed a better tendency.

During 1927 and the early part of 1928 prices had shown a consistent and marked downward movement, but in 1928 the fluctuations were within much narrower limits, and during the second half of the year an upward movement was begun. A most important feature of the year was the inauguration of various schemes devised to secure greater co-operation within the industry. After describing their schemes as applied in Scotland, in the Midlands, in South Wales, and in Northumberland and Durham, the report observes that "in each of these schemes the unit is a defined area considerable in size. This in itself constitutes a notable development in the policy of British colliery owners, but the indications are that it may be only a step toward some scheme of co-operation on a still wider basis. It has already been agreed in principle that the various districts should consult together as to ways and means of bringing about co-operation, not only between individual collieries in the same district, but also between the districts themselves, and the examination of this subject was still proceeding at the end of the year."

It is mentioned that progress has also been made in the amalgamation of colliery undertakings. Up to the end of 1928 amalgamation schemes affecting 172 pits normally employing about 120,000 workpeople, had been completed.

The report of H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines is largely statistical. Some notes from the text by Sir Henry Walker are appended :—

The Lighting Problem.

Though, as must be admitted, the Report says, naked lights are very convenient, it must be recognised that so long as such lights are used accidents from explosions which might have been avoided if safety-lamps had been used will continue to occur. Having regard to the important place which firemen fill in the working of a mine, the following paragraph, taken from the report of Mr. J. Masterton (Scotland Division) is very disquieting : "Three firemen illegally using naked lights when inspecting for firedamp got what they deserved — a warm reception. Two more firemen were burned with other men when firedamp, of which they knew, was ignited by naked lights they had allowed to be taken in. Another fireman, having made what he called an inspection of a heading, borrowed a naked light and was burned by igniting gas his alleged inspection had missed."

The objection taken, to replacing naked lights by safety-lamps is that, were that course adopted, more accidents, from other causes, e.g., falls of roof and during haulage operations, would result. This view and that to the contrary were given in evidence before the Royal Commission, on Mines which issued its Report nearly 20 years ago. Since that date (1909) and notwithstanding the enactments contained in the Coal Mines Act, 1911, based upon the recommendations of that Royal Commission, no less than 197 persons have been killed and 1,862 have been injured by explosions caused by the use of naked lights.

It is necessary to state that when the Royal Commission reported, there was not a handy substitute for naked lights. This position has since been met by the evolution of the electric cap lamp, and there can be no doubt that by the use of such lamps in place of naked lights a great number of explosions of firedamp could be prevented. So far from the use of these electric cap lamps tending to a greater number of accidents from falls and during haulage operations, the reverse would be the case. The freedom of movement to be derived from the use of these lamps, compared with that of a person encumbered with a hand lamp, is so great that their use by all haulage hands would tend to eliminate many accidents which now occur to those persons. In addition, the danger of setting fire by naked lights to brattice screens, through which these haulage hands must pass and repass many times during their shift, would be eliminated.

Shot-firing. — Eight explosions of firedamp followed the firing of shots during the year, 5 persons being killed and 21 injured ; in two cases no person was killed or injured. Sir Henry Walker says : "In view of the weight of permitted explosives used during the year, namely, 15,581,398 pounds, seven explosions said to be due to their use is not a large number. I say 'said to be due to their use' because it is debatable whether the fault lies not with the explosives but with the conditions — proximity of breaks containing firedamp for example — in which they are used. This is not to say that they may be used with impunity as I fear some persons think."

Explosions caused by Electricity. — During the year eight persons were killed and nine injured by three explosions caused by electricity. These accidents, with one possible exception, were due to neglect in not maintaining the electrical equipment in a safe condition.

Coal Dust.

In reference to the results of the analyses of the samples taken in mines in the Scotland Division, Mr. Masterton in his report states : "Dust samples have mainly been taken by the Staff from parts where the amount of stone dust applied did not appear to be adequate ; results, therefore, cannot be considered to be a measure of the average conditions in roadways, but rather of the worst that can be found."

This may be so, comments the Chief Inspector of Mines, but it must not be forgotten that the legal requirements are based upon the Reports of the Explosions in Mines Committee, who, in their Fifth Report, gave a warning in these words: "It should be clearly understood that in recommending a limit of 50 per cent. of ash we are putting it forward provisionally and as a minimum."

Falls of Ground.

During 1928, 196 persons were killed by falls of ground, and 1,789 persons were reported to the Inspectors as having been injured from the same cause. Compared with the year 1927, these figures show a decrease of 69 in the number killed and of 129 in the number reported injured. The total number of persons disabled for more than three days, including cases of injury reported to the Inspectors, was 56,130, a decrease of 3,462 compared with the year 1927, The total death-rate per thousand persons employed underground from falls of roof and sides, viz.: 0.66, compares with a rate of 0.68 for the year 1927.

The use of steel in the shape of arched girders for the support of roads continues to make headway ; progress in the use of steel props for supporting the roof in the working faces, however, is not so marked. This may be due, as Mr. Masterton implies in his Report, to a lack of appreciation of what is required when a change from timber to steel is being tried. Mr. Masterton states : "It should, however, be better appreciated that steel props cannot replace timber at the coal face without some re-organisation of the method of working; in some cases only a slight alteration, in others a change amounting to a complete difference in methods."

Mr. Hudspeth on the same point writes in his Report: "It may well be that conditions which are suitable for the use of wood props need variation if steel props, particularly those of a rigid type, are introduced. Generally, steel props show to best advantage where faces are moving rapidly and systematically. A rigid steel prop is not wanted at the face where it has to remain for a considerable time ; it is good neither for the roof nor for the prop and the latter is rendered the more difficult to withdraw."

The Chief Inspector says : "I think there can be no doubt that in the future, in the great majority of cases, steel arches will be used for the support of roads. How many years will elapse before this desirable position is reached it is difficult to say ; steel arches have been in use in some mines for twenty-five to thirty years, but only in isolated cases. Some awakening has recently taken place and information has been circulated ; the awakening should be hastened. Steel props too will, in time, be used in very much greater numbers than at present. It is curious how deep is the conservatism of everyone connected with mines. There are instances where steel props have proved themselves to be safer and more economical than timber and yet no steps appear to be taken to introduce them into other collieries owned by the same firms. There must be some reason for this but what it is I have, as yet, been unable to discover."

Shaft Accidents.

Twenty-eight deaths in and about mines under the Coal Mines Act were caused by twenty-seven accidents in connection with the sinking and working of shafts and staple pits. Seven accidents were due to overwinding. No persons were killed in these accidents but 66 were injured. Having regard to the number of persons lowered and raised in shafts each day the number of accidents is relatively few. For this state of matters great credit is due to those who design, handle and maintain the winding gear in use at collieries. The fatal and other injuries sustained by persons in cages occur as a rule to those persons who happen to be in the descending cage when an overwind takes place. Mr. Hudspeth reports two occurrences of this kind which resulted in injury to 13 persons ; Mr. Felton one in which six men were injured, and Mr. Nicholson details the circumstances of two accidents due to overwinding in the Lancashire and North Wales Division. He states that he does so because the possibility of an appalling loss of life was apparent.

The Chief Inspector considers that efforts should be made at shafts where persons are raised or lowered to install subsidiary keps in the headgear and to make provision for taking the shock of an overwound descending cage in the shaft bottom.

Underground Haulage Accidents.

The number of deaths (231) was 26 per cent. of the total number from all causes underground. There is no doubt that many of these accidents are preventable. Mr. Felton states that of the total number which occurred in the North Midland Division during the year, no less than 69 per cent. come into the category of "preventable." Mr. Charlton, on the same point, says that four-fifths of the accidents which were investigated in the Swansea Division could have been prevented, "While the 16 accidents not investigated, because they were not of a serious nature, were mostly due to slight lapses on the part of the persons injured." In the conditions in which haulage operations are carried on underground there is no room for the "slight lapses" to which Mr. Charlton refers. For example, Mr. Hudspeth in reference to four fatal accidents in connection with horse haulage in the Yorkshire Division remarks that "a greater width of road would have given the drivers a better chance." He adds : "Another essential is to provide a driver with a good even walking road. His job is at times hazardous and his walking path should not be obstructed either by timber or other materials or holes in the floor."

Mr. Abbott in his Report makes the following remarks : "In the haulage of coal, managers seem to be wedded throughout the length and breadth of all mines to the stereotyped system of conveying coal in tubs drawn either by horses or a mechanically operated wire rope. This system, the latter especially, has been abundantly proved to be a most fruitful source of accident. I should like to see it largely superseded by a much more extended use of belt conveyors ; haulage accidents would thereby be very largely eliminated." Referring to a belt conveyor in use underground at one of the Cannock Chase Colliery Company's mines conveying coal a distance of 500 yards and forming part of a system of conveyors by which coal is carried from the coal face for a distance, of 900 yards before being delivered into tubs (a length of 270 yards is down a gradient of 1 in 2) he states : "There is no physical reason why such means of conveyance should not be extended to the shaft bottom. This system does not contain in itself, to anything like the same degree as does haulage in tubs, features which might cause accident. The mortality and incapacity from accidents in mines are very largely due to the haulage of coal in tubs ; it will, therefore, be realised that a system of conveyance by belts is of tremendous import in the reduction of such incidents and should be encouraged and extended to the utmost extent. Steep gradients are no bar to its use and it requires much less supervision and power." It may well be, adds Sir Henry Walker, that this death-rate will eventually be reduced by employing conveyors to the extent Mr. Abbott advocates. In the meantime strict discipline, improvement in the condition of the roads and safety propaganda are needed.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Abbott, Henry Arnold    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Charlton, William John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Felton, John Robinson    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hudspeth, Henry Moore    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Masterton, John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Walker, Henry, Sir    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
10 Aug 1929  Mines Report For 1928 (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print