Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th July 1929, Page: 6, Column: 1

Underground Conveying

In the last issue of The Science and Art of Mining reference was made to the report on "Underground Conveying and Loading of Coal by Mechanical Means." The Committee reporting consisted of Messrs. Walter Hargreaves, John Brass, W. Benton Jones, Hugh F. Smithson, and W. D. Lloyd, with Mr. Robert Clive as chairman. It is submitted that the investigations as a whole may be taken as representing a fair average of present-day results obtained by the use of underground mechanical conveyors, no attempt having been made to pick out either the best or the worst cases. Readers of this journal who may desire to make a careful study of the individual cases discussed by the investigators have an opportunity of doing so, the report being on sale at the Office of the South Yorkshire Coal Trade Association, Royal Victoria Station Hotel, Sheffield (5s. 6d. post free in linen paper cover, and 6s. 6d. post free bound in cloth).

Saving by Using Conveyors.

From the store of general information it is gathered that a conveyor is essentially a device for collecting coal from the face and discharging it at a single loading point, and some of the savings that may thus be effected are : (1) Increase in the output per man at the coal face ; (2) saving in the number of roadways required to be made and maintained ; (3) the elimination of rail-laying on the face ; (4) a quicker advance of the face, causing a reduction in the life of the roads, with a consequent reduction in the repairing and back-ripping necessary ; (5) concentration of loading ; owing to the multiplicity of loading points on an ordinary longwall face, it is not always possible to keep the men supplied with tubs ; in the case of a double-unit conveyor face 150 yards long, tub-loading is concentrated at one point, whereas when the tubs are hand-filled at the face, there will be seven loading points in a similar length of longwall, with stalls 25 yards apart, and, by reason of the more slowly-advancing face, the output will be reduced to above one-third ; (6) a more systematic method of work, which reduces : (a) delays, and (b) amount of work to be performed ; (7) rapid advance of the face, which allows the collier to work under fresh roof and reduces the chance of accidents ; and (8) the elimination of "casting," which is often necessary in thin seams.

Additional expense may be incurred in consequence of:— (1) Capital cost and maintenance of the machinery ; (2) cost of power ; (3) wider and better roadways in certain cases ; (4) labour to move conveyor forward ; and (5) possible use of heavier section rails. From a general analysis of the information which the Committee has been able to collect, there appears to be no doubt that there are many conditions of present-day mining where the use of underground conveyors can be thoroughly justified on account of both saving in cost and safer working conditions.

Gate Conveyors and Gate-end Loaders.

Considering gate conveyors and gate-end loaders together, the following advantages are common to both types :— (1) The provision of advance headings and the dinting of the roadways is rendered unnecessary, either or both of which must generally be adopted where face conveyors load direct into tubs ; only in very exceptional circumstances is dinting advisable. When the dinting is hard it is expensive and difficult to do within the time available, and when the dinting is soft it tends to undermine the roadside packs. (2) Gate-end loaders or conveyors enable tubs to be loaded continuously without having to stop the face conveyors each time in the case of double units, and in the case of single units when not of a double discharge type. (3) They allow the tubs to be topped on account of the clearance above the top of the tub providing the rate of loading and the size of the coal permit of this being done. (4) They reduce the labour required at the loading point owing to their simplicity of operation. (5) They provide a means of loading a tub end-on instead of broadside-on, and this (the Committee are told) tends to give as much as a 10 per cent. increase in the carrying capacity of the tub. (6) They provide suitable conditions for the use of large capacity tubs.

The conditions most suitable for the use of either gate conveyors or gate-end loaders depend upon the method of working, the nature of the roof as regards hardness of ripping, position of ripping partings and the necessity for adequate packing along the face, as well as the area of coal to be won. Gate-end loaders are used in seams in which the road stands well when once ripped, and where the face has to travel some distance. In some cases comparatively short gate conveyors are used, in which the loading point is moved forward periodically-say, every 100 to 150 yards. Colliery managements are now giving more attention to the problem of gate conveying, and the troughed belt, which is capable of dealing with over 200 tons per shift, is a noteworthy example of modern enterprise. Gate conveyors are particularly applicable for working panels of coal up to 500 yards in length with either an advancing or retreating face. A permanent and substantial job can be made of the loading point, which is well back from the working face and remains in a fixed position for some considerable time. When large quantities of coal are dealt with on a long road, a gate conveyor is generally better than a gate-end loader as it enables a whole journey of empty tubs to be run under the conveyor, eliminating the constant pushing of empties necessary when a gate-end loader is used.

Points for Special Study.

To ensure success with underground conveyors it is necessary to fill a given quantity of coal with a considerably reduced number of fillers' shifts compared to the fillers' shifts necessary when filling coal by hand into tubs. In order to secure the most efficient results, the following points require special study :— (a) The continuous running of the conveyor throughout the shift. (b) The completion by the commencement of the coal-filling shift of any preparatory or other work which may interfere with the running of the conveyor and the continuous filling of coal, (c) The most systematic method of working to ensure freedom from falls, etc. (d) The most suitable angle to work the face, (e) The method of timbering. (f) Shot-firing, distance apart, and amount of charge. (g) Special supervision to ensure the minimum number of stoppages and speedy recommencement after a stoppage, (h) The will of the fillers to perform the maximum amount of work.

The best results are obtained where there is an official whose whole time is occupied in looking after the running of the conveyor system within a reasonably limited area. It is very essential that the whole underground official staff should be carefully trained in and possess a thorough knowledge of the altered organisation which becomes necessary when machine mining and conveying is adopted.

Conveying in Thick Seams.

At one time conveyors were only considered suitable for thin seams where it was not possible to take the tub along the face without additional ripping or dinting. This view is not generally held to-day, and in at least ten of the twenty-five cases investigated it would be possible so far as height is concerned to take the tubs ordinarily in use along the working face without additional ripping. Where conveyors are installed in a thick seam, more men are able to work in a given length of face and a large quantity of coal is easily dealt with at a single loading point. The capital and maintenance charges of conveyors are inversely proportional to the output produced and vary approximately according to the thickness of the seam for seams up to 4 feet, but above this thickness the output produced does not appear to increase proportionately. It is now fairly common practice to use conveyors in seams of over 5 feet in thickness. Conveyors have been used for opening out headings in the shaft pillar in a 5-ft. seam at one colliery. Incidentally, conveying provides a means of obtaining a rapidly expanding output when opening out faces from the shaft pillars owing to the shorter length of face required.

The Tub and Transport Problem.

The whole question of transport is one which merits most careful study. A continuous circulation of tubs from the tippler at the top of the shaft to the collier's working place underground is necessary to show good results in the case of hand-got coal, but it is absolutely essential in the case of machine-got and conveyor-filled coal. The principal factors to be considered are:— (1) Capacity of the pit bank and screens to keep the shaft or shafts winding at maximum speed. (2) Capacity of the shafts to deal with the output. (3) Capacity of full and empty pit bottom roadways to hold the necessary standage. (4) Capacity of the main haulage to take away as it comes all coal brought to it. (5) Auxiliary haulage capacity and easy and economic feed on to main haulage. (6) Layout at loading end of conveyors of sufficient capacity to load all coal that comes. (7) A sufficient number of tubs in circulation and not too many.

The type and arrangement of haulage used depends to a large extent upon local conditions. One colliery visited uses electric locomotives, each locomotive being of the 8-ton battery type, actuated by two twin 20 h.p. motors acting on the axles through single reduction oil-immersed gearing. The motors are capable of developing a tractive effort of 2,350 lb. continually for one hour without overheating. The haulage road is about a mile long and is laid with 56 lb. rails, and dips at 1 in 67 towards the pit bottom. The locomotive is capable of dealing with 40 to 70 tubs at a time (14 cwt. capacity), the aggregate speeds being 10 miles per hour with the full journey (gradient in favour of the load) and 7½ miles per hour with the empty journey, and deals with an output of 600 tons per shift from two gate-end loaders.

Roof Support and Packing.

Packing. — Collieries visited may be divided into three groups, according to the different methods of packing the face.

(1) Collieries where Gob Packs are Built at Right Angles to the Face at Regular Intervals, with Wastes in between the Packs. — When packs are spaced at regular intervals, the packing material is usually obtained from dirt bands in the coal or from the waste. Three cases are recorded where packing dirt is brought in from other parts of the pit to the top end of the face, carried on the conveyor, and discharged into the gob.

(2) Collieries where Dumb Gates are made for the Special Purpose of Providing Material to Pack the Face. — In most cases dumb gates are only ripped once, as their function is merely to provide packing material for the face, although they may serve as an additional escape road in case of emergency.

(3) Collieries where there are no Gob Packs. — In a few of these cases the roof is supported by steel props of large breaking strain, which when withdrawn systematically induce regular roof breaks in the gob. It would appear from the investigation that this method is particularly applicable in certain cases where the seam has either a coal roof, or a roof consisting mainly of sandy bind or sandstone; this method is successfully applied in Scotland, possibly owing to the fact that the roof usually consists of such material.

Intensive Mining.

For the purpose of definition it is assumed that "Intensive Mining" is where the operation of cutting, shot-firing, filling, ripping, packing, timbering and moving forward the conveyor are performed in a definite sequence of co-ordinated operations, the whole cycle being completed in 24 hours and a constant output being obtained from a definite length of face.

A table is given which shows that the rate of advance of the face is practically three times as great in intensive as compared with non-intensive methods. Intensive mining makes the maximum use of the plant available. Conveying systems have failed in the past owing to the small output obtained per lineal yard of face, thus making the output per conveyor low, with a consequential high overhead conveying cost per ton. Intensive mining can be seen to bring mining into line with modern factory practice, where each man has a special job to perform, at which in the process of time he becomes more adept. During the investigation several instances were found in which the men were allowed to go up the; pit as soon as their job was performed, and alternatively they had to stay until it was completed, only receiving overtime payment when the cause of incompletion was due to circumstances outside their control. The Committee say it may be pointed out that when collieries institute intensive methods there is a tendency to attempt to do too much in the allotted time, with the result that the system breaks down.

It is frequently argued that where intensive mining is applied (there is no possibility of making up lost time due to failure of the plant, falls, etc., which result in serious loss of output. Although this argument may be sound theoretically it has been demonstrated many times over in practice, providing every care is taken to, as far as possible, prevent the possibility of falls of roof, breakdown, etc., that considerable economy is bound to result from the introduction of intensive mining methods. Intensive mining necessitates the rigid adherence to a predetermined time table, and unless any specific work to be performed is completed in the time allotted to it, the work following it is held up, and the system breaks down. This can only be overcome by most careful supervision, and by arranging that the work to be done is well within the capability of the men chosen to perform it, otherwise the loss entailed by not having the work completed in time is far greater than the cost ot any extra labour that may be required to complete it.

While the results obtained during this investigation show that intensive mining gives better results than non-intensive methods, collieries have been visited where owing to the quantity of dirt to be dealt with from the seam and the extremely bad nature of the roof, intensive methods appear impracticable. On the other hand, investigators have reported that some of the collieries working non-intensive methods could easily introduce intensive workings. The rapid advance of the face by intensive methods is an important advantage both as regards (1) safety, because the collier is daily working under fresh roof, (2) freedom from falls, and (3) reduced life and maintenance of the roads.

Supervision.

Efficient supervision is the most important factor in the success of a conveying installation. Before conveyors are put in it is essential that the underground officials should be fully convinced that machine mining is essential and that with their co-operation its success can be assured. It is suggested that officials should be given an opportunity to visit other collieries and see for themselves in every detail conveyors in operation. At many of the collieries visited where conveying was completely successful the whole-hearted enthusiasm of the underground staff was one of the most striking features.

Speaking generally, up to a year or two ago mechanical conveying was in a more advanced state of development in Scotland and South Wales than in the other coalfields of the country, but during the last two or three years great activity has been displayed by the North of England and the Midlands. In some cases, particularly in Scotland, the underground machine mining policy is arranged by a central technical staff which is responsible for all underground development; the projected work is drawn out by them in considerable detail and has to be rigidly adhered to by the colliery staff. This policy sometimes results in minor difficulties, such as when small faults are encountered of which there is no previous knowledge, etc., but in the main the results fully justify the method. It is perhaps true to say the system is mainly adopted where the group consists of a large number of small collieries. The drawing up of a theoretical scheme of operations before installing conveyors is very useful, as copies can be distributed amongst the workmen and staff. It not only impresses on each man his own particular job, but also gives him some idea of the other man's job and is conducive to good team work.

Accidents.

Particulars of accidents on conveyor faces have been obtained from some collieries, and the Committee say that although conveyors tend to bring about a reduction in the more serious accidents in the working face, it is probable that there is no reduction in the number of minor accidents such as pinched fingers when coupling up the conveyor, smashed hands at the loading end, etc. On the other hand, the number of gate-ends, where it has been found that a larger proportion of accidents take place, is reduced. Owing to the importance of the loading gate it is more carefully made of larger area and better maintained than the ordinary gate road, each of which tends to reduce the possibility of accidents due to falls of roof, and haulage accidents due to tubs off the road.

At a large group of collieries where over 100 conveyors are in use, special "safety inspector" is appointed whose duty it is to visit the scene of all accidents, and keep detailed records and graphs of days lost through accidents, accidents per million tons, etc. If any type of accident is specially prevalent, the officials in charge are circularised, and warning notices are put up at the pithead to attract the attention of the workmen. In conclusion, it is clearly evident that the reduction of falls at the face due to more rapid and systematic working, and the reduction of falls on roadways due to larger and better roads, must lead to a reduction in the number and severity of accidents. It would not be possible, however, to provide any reliable statistical information on the subject unless a very careful record was kept at a number of collieries in fairly elaborate detail over a long period of time, and an investigation of this nature is obviously beyond the scope of the Committee.

Readers who desire to study the "details" under the various headings are referred to the Report, which is on sale as already indicated.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brass, John    Committee Member  Whos Who Page
Clive, Robert    Committee Member  Whos Who Page
Hargreaves, Walter    Committee Member  Whos Who Page
Jones, Walter Benton    Committee Member  Whos Who Page
Lloyd, W. D.    Committee Member  
Smithson, Hugh Fentiman    Committee Member  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
13 Jul 1929  Underground Conveying (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Jul 1929  Underground Conveying (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Aug 1929  Types Of Conveyor (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print