15th June 1929, Page: 374, Column: 1
Simultaneous Decking
By Thomas Forsyth.
From a paper on "A System of Simultaneous Decking," read before
members of East of Scotland Mining Students' Association at Herlot Watt
College, Edinburgh, reproduced in the "Colliery Guardian."
The modern mining engineer is confronted with many problems, not the least of
which is the hoisting of a large output from a single shaft in a comparatively
short time. There are a number of solutions to this problem, such as (a) the
adoption of skip hoists, (b) the increase in the capacity of tubs, and (c) the
increase in the number of decks per cage.
To the colliery engineer the two latter methods hold out more possibilities.
Throughout the country there has been a general increase in the size of tubs
used, and contemporaneous with this development, cage sizes, and the number of
decks per cage has also increased.
The increase in the number of decks, while solving the output problem in one
sense, brings in the difficulty of decking, with a resultant loss of time. To
eliminate this time loss, the next step taken will be to introduce a system of
simultaneous decking, in which the multi-decked cage is served in the same time
as a single-decked cage. Many such systems have been evolved, and it is with
one of these that I wish to deal, viz., the hydraulic decking system in use at
the Mary Colliery, Lochore, belonging to Messrs. The Fife Coal Co., Ltd.
At present this colliery is dealing with 850 tons from a depth of 300 fm. in
the No. 2 shaft, and due to the system of decking, which is extremely reliable,
robust and efficient, this output is easily dealt with.
The hydraulic system operates at a working pressure of 650 ft. per sq. in. This
pressure is produced by a horizontal three-throw pump having rams 5in. by 5in.
and driven through double-reduction gearing at a speed of 80 revs, per min. by
a 35 h.p. a.c. electric motor. This pump runs continuously, and in order to
store its energy during idle periods, between power demands, an ingenious
constant pressure storage tank is used.
Hydraulic Accumulator.
When the mains are supplied, a check valve operates, causing water to be passed
to the accumulator of the steel-cased ballast type. This consists of a steel
drum, filled with 36 tons of scrap iron, mounted on a ram cylinder, the ram
being inside the drum or tank and securely bolted to it. This great weight is
then raised by the water to a predetermined height. The ram cylinder, which
carries the weight, is fitted with guides to prevent rotation of the tank. When
the tank reaches the necessary height it immediately brings into operation a
by-pass valve, thereby allowing the water to pass to the supply tank, to which
also returns the ram cylinder discharge. We thus have a closed water circuit.
By this means, when work is required to be done at the pit bank, the
accumulator is capable of giving out its potential energy by descending the
column. The working rams are supplied through 2½in. steel pipes with screw
flanges, and the supply of water to the pump is maintained from a large tank of
150 cu. ft. capacity. The amount of water actually used is very small, the only
loss being during ram operations when a slight leak occurs, and this is
supplied by the overhead make-up tank. Since installation no trouble has been
experienced with the plant.
Decking Arrangements on the Surface.
The power so generated is utilised to operate a system of articulated ccrvice
cages, the rams of which are 8in. and 6in. diameter respectively. The empty
tubs arrive by means of creeper chain at the rear of the shaft, from whence
they gravitate to the service cages. Two Westinghouse tub retarders are
employed to control the approach and immediately following these are track axle
counter of the six-star type, which allow three tubs to pass to the service
cage at one time.
The service cages are of robust construction and are of practically the same
dimensions as the main cages, without, of course, a cover on the top deck.
The ram cylinder is situated centrally below each cage and each set is
connected by means of fin. chains passing over special 2ft. diameter pulleys in
the head frame. By this method, when one cage is ready to discharge its empties
to the main cage, the top deck of the other is loaded in preparation for the
next wind. The arrangement is similar for the full side.
Method of Operation.
When the main cage arrives at the pit bank the service cage is ready to
discharge its load of six empties ; while on the full side the service cage is
standing empty ready to receive the discharge of six full tubs, i.e., three to
each deck. The sequence of operations is as follows :—
(a) A small wheel, fixed to the side of the main cage, engages with a
horizontally stretched chain at the side of shaft, this chain being connected
to the shaft gate running bars at the back of the pit, on which are mounted the
gates. The bars of the top and bottom decks are connected at one end by a
tee-rod so that the gate-opening action is simultaneous at both decks.
(b) When the bars are raised, the gates, each mounted on roller bearings, fly
along their respective bars clear of the incoming empties.
(c) Simultaneous to this action, the gates at the front of pit are raised by
the main cage in the ordinary way.
(d) The attendant at the empties side then pulls a lever which causes the
interconnected track tub-stop to fall in the service cage and the empties run
on to the main cage.
(e) Meantime the axle counters in the main cage are tripped and the fulls are
discharged, as the last axle passes each, the stop is again set in the
"on" position ready to stop the incoming empties.
(f) The full tubs from the bottom deck run straight through the bottom deck of
the service cage, no stops being necessary. At the same time the top deck of
service cage gets its load, the tubs running in against a girder stop block.
(g) When the main cage leaves the bank, the wheel or pulley on its side
releases the chain, which operates the gates at the back of the pit, thus
lowering the bar and allowing the gates to close simultaneously. The gates at
the front of the pit descend along with the cage.
(h) During the wind the "loads" service cage is lowered and the tubs
run out as they clear the stop. In doing this, of course, the other load
service cage is raised to take the next discharge from the ascending cage.
Similarly, at the empties side the service cage containing the tubs is raised
while the now empty one is lowered.
This cycle of operations takes about 10 seconds.
The saving in time will be about 15 seconds per decking period compared with
the time occupied with ordinary decking methods. At a minimum of 30 winds per
hour, a saving of 1 hour per eight hour shift is thus effected, and an increase
of 12½ per cent. in output obtained without increase of winding speed and
peak loads. A saving is also effected in manual labour; fewer men are required
and the maximum efficiency from labour is obtained.
Underground Arrangements.
There are four water garlands in the shaft supplying water to the hydraulic
main 2½in. in diameter. At the pit bottom the pressure so obtained from
such an extremely simple source is about 670 lb. per sq. in. Should the supply
of water fail — an extremely unlikely occurrence — water can be
supplied direct from the surface which would give a pressure in the
neighbourhood of 720lb. per sq. in. This hydraulic supply is taken to rams
similar to those on the surface, but placed in rather different positions. The
pit bottom itself is designed on generous lines, 18 to 20 feet high, without
intermediate floor which only extends to the service cages. The width at the
shaft is 18ft. and is gradually reduced to 12 feet beyond the cages.
The top decking floor is approximately 6 feet above the main bottom rail level,
and is made of concrete and 8in. by 4in. H-girders. Here, as at the surface,
the flow of tubs is in one direction only, an essential in a scheme of this
kind.
It is obvious that half the total output must be raised to the top decking
level, and in order to do so the loads service cage is operated by means of a
horizontal ram. This ram is 6in. in diameter with a 6ft. stroke, and as it lies
in a horizontal plane it requires support when fully extended, the heavy
cross-head tending to drag it down. A 2in. diameter steel rod passing through a
sleeve extension of the cylinder is provided for this purpose. The cross-head
is fitted with ring bolts to which are attached the chains, two on each side,
which pass over 2ft. diameter chain pulleys to the top of the cage. This cage,
a single deck, is of robust construction and carries three tubs. Guides are
installed on either side. The distance between the top and bottom decks on the
main cage definitely fixes the distance through which the service cage must be
raised.
The operation of decking is very simple. When the service cage is loaded a
lever is pulled allowing the high pressure water to raise the load. When the
cage is almost at the top level a lever at the side is depressed by a stop,
which causes the floor of the cage to tilt and give a gradient of 1 in 20 when
the cage is at rest. The tubs immediately run forward on to the top decking
level where the number is divided between the two roads in readiness to supply
main cage.
On the bottom decking level the tubs pass the service cage and divide to each
cage. The latest type of C.A. tub retarder is employed here. The usual method
of stopping tubs by spragging the wheels is undesirable from many points of
view. Not oniy does it result in considerable wear on the treads of the wheels,
but it also entails the employment of a large amount of labour that could be
used more profitably elsewhere in the pit. Particularly is this the case when
marshalling the tubs in front of the main cages at either pit top or bottom, or
where several roads converge into one. In such positions a well-planned scheme
of tub control will very soon pay for itself, provided that the following
points are carefully considered :—
(1) The scheme shall employ a minimum of labour, and be capable of control from
a central position.
(2) The tubs shall be stopped with as little shock as possible.
(3) Any mechanical devices employed shall be as simple as possible, and very
robustly built to withstand the exacting conditions met with in collieries.
The Westinghouse tub stop is operated by a compressed air cylinder, the supply
of air to which is regulated by a control valve. The stop comprises a pair of
brake bars, rigidly connected to each other. The brake bars are arranged to
engage with the tub axles before the latter reach the upturned portion of the
bars.
In conclusion, I would like to express my thanks to Mr. Nelson, the
manager, for permission to go over in detail a more interesting system, and my
indebtedness to the engineer for many important items.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Forsyth, Thomas | | | |
| Nelson, — | | Colliery Manager | |