15th June 1929, Page: 372, Column: 1
Mine Costs
By H. S. Jackson.*
The costs of production have a special degree of importance in
the coal trade, as compared with other trades. They are much
more likely to vary, due to a number of causes, and hence it is
very important that figures showing the cause of variation should
be systematically kept. Good methods of recording the costs
greatly facilitate the efficient management of a coal mine. The
greatest item in the total cost of production is wages. This constitutes
about 70 per cent. of the total cost. The remaining 30
per cent. is made up of materials, salaries, interest on capital and
taxation. Capital plays a greater part than is generally realised
in the production of coal. A coal mine differs from other industrial
organisations in three important features, namely
(1) When capital is laid down to sink and develop a mine, a
long period, probably of several years, must elapse before there is
any return. Thus this capital is, in the meantime, lying idle from
the point of view of the investor, instead of earning compound
interest as is other investments.
(2) In the second place, there is a special degree of risk
associated with the laying down of capital in a colliery, due to the
uncertainty of the seams, their height, quality and horizon, the
effect of unknown faults, water and other difficulties.
(3) In the third place, a colliery represents a "wasting asset."
That is to say, that as soon as it begins to raise coal, the total
potential value of the colliery begins to fall.
In view of these facts, it is clear that there should be a greater
rate of remuneration on the capital invested in collieries than in
other industries. In addition, it must be remembered that the
difficulties due to smaller seams and greater depth, are increasing;
also the employment of modem methods of mining, involving the
increased use of machinery, demands an increased use of capital.
The money left from the proceeds when the wages and "costs
of production other than wages" have been paid is called the surplus.
This is not all profit, because it is also required for developments
and improvements. To make the industry self-supporting
there must be some return on capital, and also some expenditure
on development and expansion, therefore the surplus should be
regarded as an essential item in the costs. Any alteration in the
form of ownership, or administration, would not make it unnecessary
to provide out of the industry itself a continuous supply of money
for a reasonable return on capital, and a margin for development.
It may be stated as a maxim in keeping production costs down that
the highest possible rate of output per person employed must be
aimed at. The United States of America afford a good example,
as the production per person employed has been steadily raised for
many years, due to the employment of more and more machinery,
and the reduction of drudgery in loading of coal. Nearly the
whole of the coal in the bituminous mines in the United States of
America is machine cut, and, because of the suitable geological
conditions, the output per person employed is more than double
that in this country. The chief merits of machine mining lie in
the concentration of coal-getters into as small and rapidly advancing
districts as possible. This enables a regular rate of progress and
the maximum productive time per shift to be obtained. In this
way every man employed can be trained as a specialist in his own
job, and so devote his whole time to it. In addition other items
in the cost sheet may be considerably reduced, e.g., ventilation,
which is much simplified, and roof control which, if carefully
supervised, will considerably reduce timber costs, and even
damage due to surface subsidence. Haulage systems, and stone
work are also reduced by cutting out pony putting and gateway
cutting. Finally, haulage roads are much simplified, maintenance
is reduced, and official supervision is reduced. The percentage of
round coal which is worth nearly double that of small is also greatly
increased.
In connection with the recording of working costs for various
seams, it is important that the various items are arranged so that
comparisons may readily be made. The cost per ton, prices, or
rates of wages, and cost of materials for each kind of labour, and
for each district should be accurately recorded so that by careful
perusal the management may readily discover whether there is any
inefficiency, or whether development work is costing too much.
The pay sheets should keep a record of each man's, or set of men's
earnings, output, rate of pay, and tons per shift. These sheets
may conveniently be divided up into various classes for each
seam or district, including such groups as hewing or filling, putting
and driving, coal-cutting particulars and sundries.
The cost figures for each of these items may then be taken from
the various sheets, the materials and mechanics' costs added to
them, and the result shown on the abstract pay sheet for the
district. These results should also be shown in simplified tabular
form and recorded in a seam cost book for each weekly or fortnightly
pay. From the various seam costs books, another book should
be kept showing the total underground and surface costs for the
pit, the total amount of wages for each item, and items such as
rent allowances, screening, compensation, braking above and
below ground, onsetting, insurance, etc. On the same page there
should be shown various leading particulars such as number of
tons raised, the dirt laid out, the total timber costs, minimum wage
costs, the average wages for hewers, fillers, putters, conveyor
and cutter men, and the proportion of round coal to smalls. In
addition, it is usually necessary to show a monthly cost sheet
on the vendible tons. The vendible tons are the tons raised minus
the tons required for colliery consumption, workmen's coals,
and the loss in weight due to screening and transport from the pit.
It is customary under the terms of lease to calculate the royalties
payable on the vendible tons. Thus under certain leases no royalties
are paid on workmen's coals or fire-coals for colliery use.
Under other leases about 5 per cent. of the output is royalty free
for the same purpose. Other wayleaves are paid on surface railways.
The items which are added together to determine the costs on
vendible tons include the following (calculated on pit costs on
vendible tons) :—
| 60.50 | per cent. | Wages. |
| 17.50 | ,, ,, | Timber and stores. |
| 4.00 | ,, ,, | Power and coal bought. |
| 1.65 | ,, ,, | Compensation. |
| 2.88 | ,, ,, | Office expenses, Including salaries and welfare. |
| 1.76 | ,, ,, | National insurance. |
| .96 | ,, ,, | Damages (insurance and additional). |
| 3.36 | ,, ,, | Royalties. |
| 4.16 | ,, ,, | Rates. |
| 3.23 | ,, ,, | Rents (including leased houses). |
| 100.00 | | |
The costs may vary from week to week owing to a great number
of causes in a coal mine. If there is a diminution in output, it
is usual for the costs to rise owing to the increase of standing
charges such as screening, horsekeeping, compensation, pumping,
ventilation and supervision. Thus if a large percentage of men are
off work the costs usually go up, although the wages cost per ton
may not vary or may even go down.
It is very important that the supply of empty tubs be more than
sufficient. It has been stated that in the ordinary course of events
a filler only spends one-fifth of his shift in the actual process of
filling his tubs, the rest of the time being spent in travelling, getting
his bait, drilling, timbering, helping the putter, and waiting for
tubs. If an empty tub is always ready waiting for him he is urged
to get it filled.
In order to maintain the maximum output per yard of coal face
very efficient management is required. A modern colliery is a
very complicated and active organisation, depending nearly entirely
on the human element. All second-rate material either men or
machinery, must be rigorously excluded. The effect of one poor
worker may be felt throughout a district. There must be the
strictest discipline from top to bottom. All officials must have
a strong sense of loyalty and be strong themselves In personality.
An official who makes friends amongst the workmen is a very
dangerous man as he immediately causes jealousy amongst the
other men.
Regularity of output, though sometimes difficult to maintain,
is of great importance in keeping the costs within reasonable limits.
The factors which control this are chiefly good haulages and screening
facilities, ensuring a regular supply of empties, good ventilation,
ensuring freedom from interruption of work due to gas, and
giving comfortable working conditions, good control of roof in
machine and other faces, and standardisation of machinery in case
of breakdowns. The effect of regular working of the pit is
also very important, as it has a big effect on conditions below
but also affects standing charges such as compensation, insurance,
rents of surface properties and running expenses.
It is not an exaggeration to say that this country's production
of coal could be almost doubled in a very short time. Until
recently there has been a general loss per ton on coal mined, and
even now many collieries are producing at a loss. The capital
invested in collieries which are closed is lying fallow, and the
workers are unemployed, thereby increasing the burden to the
collieries and the country in taxation. However, the industry
has been through many previous stages of depression. It has
always been able to survive the deepest periods of gloom. We
still have the best coal in the world, well situated near to centres
of industry, and near the seaboards. The excessive charges of
production, namely, rail transport and taxation, are apparently
to be reduced, and if the selling of coal is conducted on better
lines we can give customers a greater degree of confidence both in
continuity of supply and in quality and variety of coal.
* From paper read at the May meeting of the Associates and Students'
section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical
Engineers.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jackson, H. S. | | | |