|
1st June 1929, Page: 362, Column: 2 Mining SubsidencePotential Forces LiberatedBy Prof. George Knox, M.I.E.E., F.G.S.* When an excavation is made underground by the removal of a seam of coal two potential forces are liberated. One of these, due to gravity — if free — is acting vertically downwards. The other is acting horizontally, and is projected against the former in a direction opposite to that of the advanced workings forming the excavation. As these two forces are acting towards the excavated area the former will be neutralised to an extent proportional to the amount of tangential compression exerted. If the vertical gravity stresses are greatest, the result is a maximum subsidence and a minimum draw, whereas the greater the tangential stresses the greater the draw and the less the subsidence. Halbaum's cantilever theory appears to offer a reasonable explanation for the planes of strains produced in the absolute roof of mines with horizontal or moderately inclined strata, but like most other subsidence theories it must not be pressed too far. In the case of highly-inclined strata each successive bed of rock above the mined area receives an increasing amount of natural support until the vertical position is reached, when each bed would be standing on "end." In this case the gravity stress is reduced to a minimum until a critical depth is reached, beyond the limit of shear stress for the particular rocks forming the walls. In the case of horizontal or slightly inclined strata the greater the speed at which the coal is worked out, the more completely it is extracted, and the higher the efficiency in packing the goaf, the greater is the draw over the solid strata. From this it would appear that the slower the rate of vertical subsidence, proportional to the rate of advancement of the face, the resultant stresses, instead of inducing fractures, allow the planes of strain to remain below the shearing limit, and the strata to bend gradually with a frictional drag on the strata beyond the line of solid face. It has been frequently noted that where the vertical force is inadequately controlled through inefficient packing, etc., and allowed to act rapidly, the strata forming the nether roof break in the form of small faults with a maximum of subsidence and a minimum of draw. If, on the other hand, the absolute roof subsides slowly and evenly, the nether roof may bend without breaking, resulting in a maximum draw and a minimum subsidence. Effects of Subsidence. — The writer had the opportunity for several years of studying the effects of subsidence in working comparatively fiat seams by the longwall system in Scotland and Lancashire. In neither case was the method of packing very efficient, and it was noted that the angle of pull varied from 8 to 12 degrees (from the vertical). Fractures through the absolute roof would appear at the surface at one of these varying angles in front of the working face, increasing in width as the workings advanced towards them, reaching a maximum (2 inches to 8 inches in some cases) when the working face was immediately below, and gradually closing up again as the workings advanced beyond them. The nearer to the vertical these fractures took place the wider they became, doing considerable damage to surface property in the vicinity. As the angle of draw increased, the fractures decreased in width and subsidence took place less rapidly, so slowly, in fact, that even though large buildings became slightly tilted on the approach of the workings, they righted themselves again without serious fracture when the workings had passed beyond them. Thickness of Seam Worked. — In thick seams, even where as efficiently packed as thin seams (which is seldom the case owing to the difficulty of providing sufficient packing material), the total subsidence is increased and the angle of pull is small. As the workings in thick seams usually advance slowly and irregularly (owing to the method of working adopted), the tendency to fracture the absolute roof is great. The fractures produced are usually wide, and the "prime" face being nearly vertical, this allows the motive zone to act rapidly and often in jerky fashion, suddenly breaking off pieces of the nether roof. This is probably why the accident rate in this country is usually two to three times as high in thick seams as compared with thin seams. Depth of Workings from the Surface. — In shallow workings subsidence usually takes place suddenly, the subsiding surface being very little (if anything) larger than the excavated area, owing to the small angle of pull. This accounts for the early theories ("vertical" and "normal") put forward. Even if the prime face remained at the same angle it is evident that as the depth increased, the subsiding area at the surface would increase for the same area of excavation; under similar conditions the angle of pull is likely to increase with increasing depth, owing to the draw of the littoral zone against the motive zone assisting to support the absolute roof and allowing it to sink gradually in a slightly curved form and with fewer fractures. Method of Working Adopted. — Unless under very exceptional circumstances (such as working under sea, etc.), the two chief methods of working coal are longwall and bord-and-pillar. In longwall workings, where the coal is completely extracted in one operation, subsidence (varying according to thickness, efficiency of packing, depth, etc.) usually takes place along planes parallel to the working faces, but some distance in advance of them. In bord-and-pillar workings, where the line of faces on the pillars being extracted may be very irregular, and where the nether roof is usually allowed to fall into the gob as the pillars are extracted, the subsidence is increased in amount and is irregular in form. If, however, subsidence does take place along planes parallel to the jointing of the rocks, a large amount of the coal in the pillars is badly crushed. Presence of Faults and Large Fissures. — In the presence of faults the subsiding strata tend to draw into the hade of the fault, which, if flat and hading away from the workings, increases the draw and reduces the subsidence. If, on the other hand, the fault hades towards the excavated area, the initial angle of pull will be reduced and subsidence increased, but in a short time the planes of strain will gradually extend lower, producing fractures running into the fault. This usually results in great pressure being produced on coal seams in the vicinity of faults, as shown by the number of cases of gob-fires which have taken place under such conditions in seams liable to spontaneous combustion. It has been stated that workings in the Yorkshire, Northumberland and Durham districts frequently have the angle of pull increased when approaching underneath the magnesian limestone, which contains many large fissures. On the other hand, as Dickinson pointed out, when working directly underneath such hard, well-jointed rocks the angle of pull may be fairly small. Surface Contour. — Where the surface contour is irregular, as in the South Wales coalfield, the subsidence resulting from mining operations is quite different from that of other areas with more or less flat surface contours. In the first place, there is frequently an added load to be considered in the mass of "unbridged" strata constituting the high ground forming the mountain ridges. The enormous weight of strata above the level of the valley floor is an added weight tending to force the absolute roof into the mine excavation. When workings are advancing from the valley toward and under the mountains, subsidence fractures do not close up so readily as in the case of "bridged" strata, hence the reason for the large fractures visible on the ridges between the valleys, particularly where the ridges coincide with estate boundaries. Dip of the Strata. — The angle of inclination of the strata plays an important part in determining the ratio between subsidence and draw, and in determining the relative positions of the worked and subsided area. Many writers have adopted the view that at all dips over 24 degrees the angle of pull is vertical, but it is hardly possible to imagine mined strata coming to rest on a vertical prime face. The direction in which inclined workings are being extended plays an important part in determining the ratio of draw and subsidence. At the Oakley Slate Quarries, Blaenau Festiniog, the writer observed that all the subsidence fractures were practically at right angles to the dip of the strata. In this case the workings were advancing to the dip. The same results have been noted in coal mines extending from the outcrop towards the dip, whereas when working from the dip upwards the angle of draw has increased considerably from the vertical. The effect of dip on draw is still a very debatable point, except that the draw is greater in the direction of dip and lower in the direction of rise as compared with horizontal strata. It is also suggested by various authors that once a certain dip is reached any increase of dip has no further effect on the draw. Dickinson suggested 18 degrees, O'Donahue 24 degrees, and the Dortmund report 35 degrees, as the limiting angle, although draws up to 45 degrees have been recorded. Various suggestions have been made to differentiate between the relative dip and rise draw in estimating pillars of support. Fletcher suggested making the draw 1 in 10 to the vertical for dip side of pillar, and 1 in 10 to the normal for rise side. Dickinson proposed 1 in 5 to vertical and normal instead. O'Donahue, taking 8 degrees as the normal draw for horizontal strata, adds to this two-thirds of the angle of dip to rise side, and subtracts one-third from the dip side of pillar. Lloyd raised the question as to whether the angle of draw would be extended after the workings had stopped. In the case of the observations made by Kirby, it is evident that the draw did continue to extend after the workings had stopped. The section shows that when working ceased the draw was 95 feet, but a year later it had extended to 119 feet. It was interesting to note that the draw over the outer coal pillar also gradually extended between December, 1914, and December, 1917. These final distances probably represent the maximum draw which would have been attained had the workings been extended to any greater distance. The amount of vertical subsidence is even more variable than the angle of draw, varying from 5 to 75 per cent. of the thickness of the seam worked. The rate of subsidence has been given at anything from 60 days (Morgan) to 15 years (McMurtrie). No one has yet put forward any rational explanation for these divergencies, or applied any empirical formula which will satisfy all possible combinations of factors which may enter into the problem. Conclusion. — From the analysis of all the available published statistics — from observations made on this subject — it would appear that under normal circumstances the "time factor" is the most important element in determining the maximum stresses induced in the absolute roof and their behaviour in the nether and upper regions of the subsiding strata. If it is possible by rapid advancement of the workings and efficient packing to prevent the actual fracturing of the absolute roof, this may be due, as Prof. Jones states, to the combined effect of vertical shear and horizontal thrust in the nether roof, and to vertical shear accompanied by tension in the upper roof. As the descending strata have an increasing area in ascending order, any slow bending movement must cause an enormous draw on the face of the solid strata, which could account for the increase in the angle of draw with the efficiency of packing and speed of working. If mining engineers in each of the coalfields would collect and furnish reliable data, similar to that supplied by Kirby, to some central institution in their respective areas, where it could be analysed and collated, there might be some hope that in the near future our knowledge of subsidence would not be only enlarged, but be of a more definite character. * Excerpts from paper on "Notes on Mining Subsidence Theories," read before the South Wales Institute of Engineers and published in the Proceedings of the Institute.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||