18th May 1929, Page: 339, Column: 2
Treatment Of Miners' Nystagmus
At the April meeting of the Midland Institute of Mining Engineers Dr. W. J.
Wellwood Ferguson read a paper on "Some Observations on Miners'
Nystagmus and Its Treatment." He said that at present no "cure"
is known, that the aim of successful treatment is to find out and remove the
cause, that further experiments with lighting should be instigated and
observed, and that recently Mr. J. Jolly, late of Dinnngton Colliery,
had suggested to him that the administration of calcium and iron might be
beneficial in cases of nystagmus. Dr. Ferguson had suggested the
addition of vitamin D, this having a marked effect on the absorption of
calcium. Five men have been treated since September 1928 on the lines suggested
by Mr. Jolly. All were marked cases of miners' nystagmus of considerable
duration. All were at that time, and still are, working at the coal face, i.e.,
are not of the type to claim compensation if it can be avoided. All have
improved remarkably with regard to the acuity of vision, which has returned to
normal in all cases. Headache and giddiness have been absent since early in the
course of treatment, and the oscillations are in all cases less marked —
in one case, which was a particularly bad one, remarkably so. In none are the
oscillations as yet entirely absent. Dr. Ferguson feels it is rather
premature to ascribe any importance to the results in so few cases, and he has
started a further series of men on similar lines, but in the present state of
affairs anything is worth trying, and even negative results are of value.
Following the reading of the paper members of the Institute discussed the
problem from various angles and questions were asked having a bearing on the
incidence of nystagmus. In his reply Dr. Ferguson said he thought that
what they wanted to do with nystagmus was not to cure it, but to prevent it,
and experiments with regard to lighting and lamps had to do with prevention
entirely. The other aspect was the treatment which had grown up which might
help men who had already acquired the condition.
Miners' nystagmus is known in America but it is not the problem that it is here
in this country, probably due to some extent to three causes. First of all, the
American laws of compensation differ in all the different States, and nystagmus
is not, in the majority of cases, dealt with from the compensation point of
view as it is in this country ; only the very bad cases, possibly, are made a
note of at all. Secondly, he has gathered that the Americans go in very much
more for cap-lamps, with a very much greater candle-power. The benefit of the
cap-lamp, of course, is that it moves wherever the miner goes, so that he
always has the same relative illumination of the coal face. The lamp is not
left behind. Then the Doctor thinks the Americans take a greater interest in
their diet than the workers in this country. From what he can hear, they all
know exactly how many calories they are consuming, and so it is possible that
they might be living rather better, and so are able to resist nystagmus more
than our own men here.
Evidence is variable regarding the occurrence of nystagmus in some pits more
than in others, and with regard to the inefficiency of men on light work and
work on the screen, they would not see so well. Continental figures have been
published with regard to accidents to men with and without nystagmus, and there
is a greater proportion of accidents in the pit to men who have got nystagmus
than to men who have not got it. Dr. Ferguson thinks the same thing
would apply to their working capacity. Anything that would diminish the glare
of an electric lamp, quite apart from the illumination, would relieve the
symptoms to a certain extent. Actually one could not lay down any hard and fast
rule with regard to the improvement from better lighting over a period, because
the majority of the men have to work in the pit a long time before they develop
nystagmus.
With regard to cap-lamps in Scotland, Dr. Ferguson said he came to
Sheffield from Scotland, and he saw a great many cases of nystagmus. He had not
got actual figures, but he knew that all the cases he saw were in pits that
were not using the cap-lamp, but were using either oil or safety-lamps, and the
men there commonly said that they were unaffected while they were in a cap-lamp
pit, but developed nystagmus when they used the oil safety-lamp. In Lanarkshire
they called nystagmus "Glennie's blink," attributing it to the
change-over from the cap-lamp to the safety-lamp. He was told that in Scotland
the incidence of nystagmus was much less in pits where cap-lamps were used than
in those employing safety-lamps.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ferguson, W. J. Wellwood, Dr. | | | |
| Jolly, J. | | | |
| Jolly, J. | | | |