4th May 1929, Page: 324, Column: 2
Endless Rope Haulage
By J. D. Stewart.
From paper read at the annual meeting of the Mining Society of Nova Scotia. The
Author is Assistant Chief Engineer of the Dominion Coal Company Ltd.
We have read how a hundred years or more ago, in some parts of Scotland, coal
was transported along the mine roadways and up the shaft in corves or baskets
carried on the back of the miner or on that of his wife. And again, in mines
where the seam was thin, this basket or box was drawn along the pavement by a
rope passing between the knees and looped about the neck of the miner, who
crawled along a none too smooth roadway on his hands and knees in the dark,
dragging his couple of bushels of coal behind him. Underground hauling methods
have gradually improved until to-day, instead of hauling a cwt. of coal at a
snail-like pace, we have the electric locomotive hauling two hundred tons at
twenty or more miles per hour along well illuminated passages and on heavily
ballasted and smooth roadways, or the low speed endless-haulage system, with
which this paper is concerned, reaching out for three miles or more and hauling
300 tons per hour with a rope strain of 70,0001b. or so.
Low Speed Haulage.
The low speed endless-rope system of haulage — that is, the system using
a rope speed of 2½ miles per hour or so — is favoured on account of
its comparative low cost of installation, the ease with which it may be
extended, and because of the fact that the mine-cars are delivered singly and
at regular intervals, thus necessitating but short landings and bankheads.
Also, due to its low speed, the same careful track laying as is necessary with
the higher speed haulages is not essential, though much to be desired. And
again, in case of derailment of cars, the resulting damage is not so serious as
that due to the derailment of cars running at high speed.
To offset these advantages, however, the cost of maintenance of ropes and
pulleys, and the power and the labour cost at the landings, will be
considerably higher than that for the trip or the locomotive haulage systems.
There is also the necessity for maintaining a double track for the entire
hauling distance. The greatest disadvantage, however, is that as the mine
workings are extended the number of mine cars required by this system becomes
excessive and the large number of cars on the rope greatly increases the rope
strain and the power requirements. As a general rule, to handle a given output
with the same capacity mine car, the mine equipped with the endless-rope
haulage system will require 20 per cent. more cars than the mine with the trip
haulage system. On a long haulage, even where the gradient is but moderate, the
weight of the rope forms a considerable proportion of the load, reaching
probably as high as 20 per cent. of the weight of the coal in transit, while
the power required to overcome the rope friction will exceed that required to
overcome the frictional resistance of the net coal load.
There is probably no limit within reason to the distance coal may be hauled by
the endless-rope system, providing that the output required is small, the
gradient favourable, and the pit tubs light. Under these conditions the system
may be indefinitely extended and may be so developed to operate on curves, on
undulating roadways, and with branch lines for subsidiary haulage on the mine
levels. But where these conditions are reversed, the system, to operate
successfully, must consist of but a single line without branches and the
roadway must be straight and without sudden variations in the gradient.
Ideal conditions are seldom met with in the mine. Money expended in obtaining
well and evenly graded haulage-ways, in the elimination of curves, and in
preparing properly graded landings, will quickly be returned in the shape of
decreased power requirements, in freedom from breakdowns, and in the decreased
wear and tear on the equipment. The importance of properly designed roadways
cannot be too strongly stressed, and, as the hauling distance increases, the
greater becomes the necessity of obtaining and maintaining good roadways. As on
the surface, the mine roadways are the arteries through which flows the
commerce of the mine, and it is essential to the prosperity of the mine that
the flow of underground commerce be maintained with rapidity, regularity, and
economy.
The distance coal may be drawn with the endless-rope system depends upon the
gradient of the haulage-way, and, conversely, if the same rope strain is to be
kept, the gradient on which the system can be operated depends upon the length
of the hauling distance. When the load on the rope through either of these
factors — distance or grade — or a combination of the two, produces
a rope strain which necessitates a rope of such size and weight as to form an
abnormal proportion of the load and to produce excessive friction in itself at
the pulleys and hauling wheel, and in the haulage machine itself, it becomes
more economical to install a second or a relay unit than to continue the use of
the single system, since the extra cost of power absorbed in hauling the
excessive rope weight, in the higher cost of maintaining the haulage gear and
the more frequent rope renewals, will more than offset the cost of operating a
second hauling unit.
Large Capacity Mine Cars.
During the last few years the tendency has been towards the use of larger and
still larger capacity mine-cars. This is made possible by the wider use of
mechanical haulage and the adoption of the roller or the ball-bearing car
wheel. The benefit of the ball bearing wheels is felt more at the landings and
in the rooms, where the cars have often to be moved by hand. On the main
haulage-way, however, especially if the gradient is heavy, the benefit of the
ball-bearing wheel is not so apparent and the saving in power due to their use
is but small. The great advantage of the roller or ball-bearing wheel over the
plain bearing is in the saving of labour and oil in their lubrication. With the
plain bearing lubricated With oil, there is an enormous waste of oil, which
constantly drips off and tends to make the roadway dirty and at the same time
increase the fire hazard by depositing this highly inflammable material on the
road.
The weight of the tub is an important factor in determining the gradient on
which the endless-rope system may be successfully operated, especially when the
weight of the loaded tub is in the vicinity of, say, 6,000 pounds or more, and
where the haulage-way is double tracked and with landings on either side of the
roadway on which the tubs have to be man-handled. Where such conditions as the
above obtain, and if the gradient is more than 10 per cent., it would be
advisable to install the trip-haulage system in preference to the endless-rope
system.
Dominion Coal Company's System.
A notable example of the low-speed endless-rope haulage system, and one which
has now reached the economical distance from which coal may be hauled by a
single system, is now in use in the No. 4 mine of the Dominion Coal Company.
The original haulage installation was put in operation in this mine in the year
1897, when the greatest hauling distance was about 3,000 feet. At that time
there were three separate endless-rope haulage systems in use serving the East
and West deeps and the West level.
These machines were installed on the surface near the shaft, with the ropes
leading through vertical bore-holes, 175 feet deep, to the mine. The three
machines were set up side by side and were driven by a 22in. by 42in.
non-condensing, slide valve, steam engine, running at 60 r.p.m. through
friction clutches and single reduction spur gearing giving a speed reduction
ratio of 5.5 to 1. The rope wheels were 6ft. 10in. diameter, and the rope speed
235 feet per minute. The steam engine was built in 1872. This engine is still
in use and giving excellent service, notwithstanding that it has been well over
half a century in constant use, the only major repairs that have been made
during this time being the replacement of the piston rod. The steam cylinder
has been once re-bored.
To-day the East deep only is producing coal in No. 4 mine — the sections
tributary to the West deep and to the West level having been worked out some 12
years ago. The East deep was gradually extended until in 1922 the hauling
distance was 12,200 feet. The grade of the haulage-way for its entire length is
fairly constant at about 7.33 per cent. The large number of cars on the rope
entailed by this long hauling distance overtaxed the power; of the steam engine
and the strength of the haulage machine.
The question of replacing the existing haulage machine with heavier equipment
to further extend the hauling distance, and the alternative suggestion to
instali a second or a relay hauling unit in the lower part of the deep, was
then considered. The former scheme was adopted and it was decided to replace
the existing haulage gear by a stronger and heavier one, to install an
auxiliary steam engine to give the additional power required, and to use, later
on, a 1¼in. diameter rope in place of the 1 1/3-in. diameter rope then in
use. While making these changes it was required that the operation of the
colliery be not impeded. This was accomplished by making a temporary
re-arrangement in the lead of the rope and by installing the new machine on the
site of the disused machine extreme from the haulage engine. The auxiliary
steam engine was coupled to the extended end of the existing crank or first
motion shaft. The new haulage machine is of the conventional type, differing
only in weight and strength from the ordinary haulage gears. The machine is
driven through a friction clutch and single reduction gearing, giving a speed
reduction ratio of 6 to 1.
The rope wheel is of cast-steel with chilled cast-iron lagging segments bolted
to its periphery, about which the rope makes six coils on a pitch diameter of
8ft. 3in. On either side of the rope wheel is cast a brake path 7ft. 2in.
diameter and 6¼in. wide. The gear wheel is of cast-steel with 96 cast
teeth, 3¼in. c.p. and 15in. face. The gear and the rope wheel are keyed to
a 14-in. diameter shaft which is nicked down to 10in. diameter in the bearings.
The pinion is also of cast-steel with 16 fully shrouded cast teeth. The
friction clutch is of the band type. The friction wheel is 5ft. 6in. diameter
and is keyed to the extended hub of the pinion. The rope speed is 258 feet per
minute. At the present time the distance from the pit bottom to the end of the
East deep is about 17,000 feet.
A new level, the 19th, at 16,000ft., is now being driven, and from this coal is
being hauled by the main haulage. Above the 19th level there are four producing
levels at intervals of 1,070, 1,050, 1,000, 900 feet. Below the 13th level,
9,100 feet from the pit bottom, the mine is single sided, that is, all the mine
workings are to one side, the south side, of the haulage-way. The haulage-way
has double tracks of 23½in. gauge, the inner track being the full one. The
average grade from the pit bottom to the 19th level is 7.33 per cent. The total
vertical lift is 1,120 feet.
The cars used in this mine are of the end-dump type, are of 1.4 long tons
capacity, and have a gross weight of 4,550 pounds. Hadfield's cast-steel
wheels, 12in. diameter, with plain bearings are used. The total capacity of the
mine cars is 780 tons, or 71 per cent. of the average output of the mine per
shift.
Breaking Strain of Rope.
The haulage rope is 1¼in. diameter, best plough steel, Lang's lay, with
six strands of seven wires over a hemp core. The specifications require the
wires to have a minimum tensile strength of 224,000 pounds per square inch, and
the rope to have an actual breaking strain of 67 tons. The wires must also
stand 30 complete torsions in 100 diameters. The weight of the rope is 2.45lb.
per foot. The total length of the rope in use is 33,000 feet, and it weighs
over 40 tons. Three 1¼in. ropes have been worn out since this size rope
was first used in 1924. A 1¼in. rope is capable of hauling about 400,000
tons and lasts about 12 months.
When the haulage system is running up to capacity — about 175 cars per
hour — and with rope fully loaded to the 17th level, the number of cars
on the rope is 156. The tension an the rope due to this load and to the weight
of the rope is 74,400 pounds. The weight of the rope and its friction is
responsible for nearly 20 per cent. of the total rope tension.
In this short paper the writer has not attempted to offer anything new, but to
describe in a very general way one of the large installations of the
endless-rope system, and to draw attention to the factors which tend to limit
the application of this type of haulage, in hope that a full discussion of this
important branch of the industry may be provoked.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Stewart, J. D. | | Assistant Chief Engineer | |