4th May 1929, Page: 321, Column: 1
Concrete Mine Supports
In the last issue of this journal, page 309, a summary was given of a paper on
"Sand-filled Members as Supports for Mine Workings," read before the
South African Institution of Engineers, by Professor W. J. Walker and
Mr. S. F. Gimkey. These authors have also read a paper on "Strength
of Concrete Mine Supports" before the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining
Society of South Africa. Details of tests are presented in the Journal of the
Society, Professor Walker explaining that the experiments were
originally planned to determine the distribution of pressure along axially
loaded sand-filled steel pipes of different diameters, with the object of
determining their suitability as mine props. Experimental work of any kind, as
it goes on, gives results and yields information which generally leads to
another method of attack from that originally intended ; and that was exactly
what happened in the case of the experiments which he carried out with Mr.
Gimkey. Having shown some illustrations of the tests Professor
Walker said he wished briefly to consider some of the possible objections
to sand-filled columns, as follows: "The first point I want to discuss is
that of reinforced concrete telescopic pipes versus 'pancakes.' There is no
question about it that, taking it material for material, the telescopic pipes
can be made cheaper than the 'pancake.' The main difficulty which is always
introduced in argument is the handling of the sand in the use of these columns.
As far as I can see, that difficulty can be overcome by the provision of
suitable carriers, the collars being packed with sand with a load, say, of 10
to 20 tons, on the surface, placed in these suitable carriers and taken
underground in that way.
"Steel pipes, of course, from the cost point of view cannot compete with
the reinforced concrete pipe. Now, one can only compare, from the point of view
of strength, the telescopic pipe column of 30" diameter, with a 30"
diameter 'pancake.' The possible load that a non-pressure Hume pipe telescopic
column will take — that is, with the sharpened edges, of course —
30" diameter, based on the information of our tests, is 211 tons. Without
the sharp edges the possible load would be in the neighbourhood of 70 to 80
tons. A 'pancake' column of that diameter will only take a load of 150 tons. In
addition, the telescopic column has the possibility of giving as the
hanging-wall comes down on top and further, the danger of sudden collapse in
the case of a telescopic, column is very small indeed. In the case of a
'pancake' column, our tests indicate that the final collapse — the
maximum load taken — is the point of complete collapse, and, probably,
very sudden collapse.
"Taking the case of the ring column verses 'pancakes,' in that case the
question of taking the sand down the mine in the rings is much more difficult.
It might be possible to devise a device or gadget for taking these rings down
with sand already packed in them, but, as I say, the problem is much more
difficult than it is in the case of the collars — the rings are
undoubtedly the stronger and cheaper job.
"Then another point which may be brought up, and has been brought up, is
that from all the tests it is very evident that it is the wire reinforcement
which is the main factor in giving strength to the whole structure, whether
telescopic column or ring column ; and the conclusion that we have come to is
that the concrete mixture need only be one of minimum strength consistent with
holding this reinforcement together and strong enough to withstand the usual
treatment received when being transported.
"Now, 'pancakes' could be reinforced in the same way as the rings, and
it is perfectly obvious that if they were reinforced in the same way as the
rings they would withstand a very much greater load than they do with their
present reinforcement, which is usually just a piece of wire rope which is not
a homogeneous ring, but is simply lapped over at the ends.
"Now, in comparing, therefore, 'pancakes' with rings or pipes, the cost of
a pancake column will obviously be greater, since, in the 'pancake,' you have
concrete throughout the whole structure ; that is the best way, I think, of
looking at the matter from the cost point of view. You have much more material
in the 'pancake' with the reinforcement than you would have in the ring. In
addition, the 'pancake' column has no 'give.' With the homogeneous
reinforcement, of course, it would not have the sudden collapse which they have
now under the present method of manufacture.
"The last point I want to bring up — all with the idea of inducing
discussion — is the question of penetration of the column into th"
hanging.
"Now, as far as I can see, the question of penetration does not depend
mainly or even primarily on the load capacity of the support. I have no
experience of the actual work, but I am speaking from what I imagine must be
the case. You have a definite weight supported by a column. If the column
penetrates the hanging, euch penetration has nothing whatever to do with the
structure of the column. It is mainly a question of what 'give' the column has.
If it is a slab column, of course, it has no 'give' and the hanging will
penetrate ; if penetration does not proceed such columns must have a tendency
to collapse suddenly.
"In the case of the ring or collar structures you have 'give' and
penetration cannot take place until the whole structure has jammed so tightly
that further 'give' is impossible. That, of course, will only take place after
movement of the wall has taken place, say, 12" for a 5' stope ; and the
time taken for that movement, of course, will depend on the circumstances in
the mine concerned."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Gimkey, S. F. | | | |
| Walker, W. J., Prof. | | | |