20th April 1929, Page: 306, Column: 1
Natural And Mechanical Ventilation
By L. S. Buxton, B.Sc.
From paper presented at the March meeting of the Past and Present Mining
Students' Association in the Wigan Mining and Technical Collage Mr. Buxton is
Assistant Manager of the Parsonage Pits at West Leigh, Lancashire.
The various reports already published by the Committee on "The Control of
Atmospheric Conditions in Hot and Deep Mines" have brought into prominence
some of the problems connected with ventilation which will arise in mines
worked at great depths. One of the most important points raised is that of the
wet-bulb temperature and the various physiological phenomena related to it.
Investigations have also been made into the causes of high underground air
temperatures, and the effect of such high temperatures on the miner. As a
result of their investigations, the Committee have shown that the best way of
overcoming the difficulties presented by high strata temperatures, and the
presence of moisture, is by a brisk circulation of air.
Bearing in mind the fact that the workings at the Wigan Coal and Iron Company's
Parsonage Pits are approaching a depth of 4,000 feet, and that a strata
temperature of 105°F. has already been recorded, it was considered
desirable that an attempt should be made to determine, firstly, to what extent
the ventilation of the mine is due to natural causes, and secondly, to
investigate the effect on natural ventilation of mechanical aids. As the
experiments proceeded other points evolved relevant to the matter in hand,
which will be dealt with in the course of this paper.
Arrangement of the Ventilation.
It would perhaps be well at this point to give a brief description of the
general ventilation arrangement of the mines. Of the air descending the
downcast shaft approximately one-half enters an inset at a depth of 1,923 feet
and ventilates the Bickershaw Seven Feet and Crombouke Mines. The remainder
descends to the Arley Mine at a depth of 2,946 feet, where it is split. About
20,000 cubic feet per minute go to the East Side and about 80,000 to the West.
The air on the West Side travels a slightly rising course for 450 yards, where
a portion of it is diverted to the rise workings. Fifty yards further on
another split is made, some of the air going to the No. 1 West dip workings,
and the remainder to the No. 2 West dip workings. On the East Side of the
downcast shaft the air is split once. One portion ventilates the main level
heading, and the other the dip workings. There are only two regulators in the
mine; one on the East Side near the upcast shaft, and the other in the return
brow of the No. 1 West dip workings.
Two regulators are also required in the Seven Feet Mine. One is situated in the
main return near the upcast shaft, and restricts the quantity of ventilation
for the whole mine. There are three main splits in the mine, and it is in the
least of these, the Crombouke, that the second regulator is needed.
The ventilation plant consists of a Walker Indestructible double-inlet fan, 28
feet in diameter and 9 feet wide. At its maximum speed of 120 revolutions per
minute it is capable of dealing with 750,000 cubic feet per minute at a 6-inch
water-gauge. The fan is driven by a double tandem compound non-condensing
engine, through a cotton rope drive. At present the fan is found to create
sufficient ventilation at a little over half speed, i.e., 74 revolutions per
minute with a water-gauge of 3.2 inches. The total quantity of air entering the
downcast shaft at this speed is roughly 188,000 cubic feet per minute in
summer, and 210,000 in winter.
These figures alone demonstrate to what a great extent the flow of air is
affected by variations of surface temperature, and it was felt that in the
winter, at any rate, the greater part of the air flow would be maintained
without the aid of the fan. In view of the rather gassy nature of the Crombouke
and Seven Feet seams, there was naturally some apprehension as to what would
happen if the fan was stopped for several hours, and a preliminary experiment
was carried out to see exactly what would happen. The test was made on a
Saturday morning in December, 1927, between 6-0 a.m. and noon. The surface
temperature during the test averaged 34°F. In every district there were
stationed two men, a fireman and an observer, equipped with anemometer and
hygrometer. An inspection was made and a set of readings taken in each district
before 6-30 a.m., at which time the fan speed was reduced from normal to 50
B.P.M. At 6-45 a.m. another set of readings was taken and a report on the
condition of each district was made. At 7-0 o'clock the fan was stopped, and at
7-30 a.m., and every hour up to 11-30 a.m., each party reported to the manager
the general conditions in the district, together with the wet and dry bulb
temperatures and the quantity of ventilation at the pre-determined point. As
soon as the fan stopped the regulator in the Crombouke district was pulled
down. At the same time the areas of the main Seven Feet and the No. 1 West
downbrow regulators were slightly increased, and were further increased each
succeeding hour, a record being kept of the exact area of each opening.
In the Arley Mine the greatest diminution in quantity was naturally expected in
the rise workings, but, although there was a decrease in quantity, it was not
nearly so great as was anticipated. Measurements taken at the face at the
highest point of the workings showed 5,000 cubic feet per minute to be
circulating when the fan was running at its normal speed. A quarter of an hour
after the fan was slowed down to 50 B.P.M., the quantity was 4,500. At 7-30,
with the fan stopped, the quantity was 3,240 and gradually decreased to 2,630
at 8-30 a.m. An hour later the circulation had increased to 2,810, in spite of
the fact that both the No. 1 West downbrow and the Main Seven Feet regulators
had been further opened. From 9-30 onwards to the conclusion of the test the
quantity varied slightly between 2,800 and 3,000 cubic feet per minute, but
never fell lower. During the test the temperature increased irom 82° to
85°F., with a corresponding rise in the wet-bulb temperature from 66°
to 69°. No trace of gas was found at any point throughout the whole time of
the experiment, and conditions generally were such that work could have been
carried on in quite as great a degree of comfort as under normal conditions,
In the No. 1 West downbrow most interesting results were obtained. As a result
of slowing down the fan the quantity of ventilation at the point of measurement
(the main brow a few yards back from the face) increased from 6,000 to 7,000
cubic feet per minute. There was a loss of 250 cubic feet per minute when the
fan stopped, but as the regulator opening was increased, the quantity increased
until at 11-30 a.m. there was a circulation of slightly over 8,000 cubic feet
per minute. The temperature rose from 84°F. to 88°F., but working
conditions were actually better than with the fan running at normal speed.
In the two remaining districts the measurements were taken in the intake airway
near the point of splitting. In the West Tunnel district the quantity dropped
from 16,000 at normal speed to 13,000 cubic feet per minute when the fan
stopped. The East district showed a reduction from 28,000 to 18,000, and in
both districts there was a further slight drop, probably due to the opening of
the regulators. These readings, however, did not represent the true conditions
at the face, for both districts reported a sufficient ventilating current and
no trace of gas. It is probable that the greater part of the diminution of
quantity in both districts was compensated for by a decrease in short-circuit
losses.
In the Seven Feet main intake the total quantity was reduced from 108,000 cubic
feet per minute to 68,000 by the stopping of the fan, but the opening of the
regulator brought it up to 83,000 cubic feet per minute. In the Crombouke
district the quantity dropped from 24,000 to 17,000, but quickly recovered, and
at 11-30 a.m. there was rather more than the normal quantity of air
circulating. Reports from the other districts showed only a slight reduction of
ventilation at the face, with working conditions normal and a general reduction
in temperature of 1°F.
Were such results obtainable all the year round, the fan might very well be
dispensed with altogether, but, unfortunately, from the point of view of
natural ventilation, such conditions of surface temperature rarely occur for
more than a few days at a time.
It may perhaps be suggested that the test was of too short a duration to prove
conclusively that such a large volume of air could be circulated by natural
causes alone; but a further test, carried out under conditions that ensured the
elimination of all effects, such as momentum imparted by the fan, afforded
further proof of the permanent nature of the natural ventilating current. The
air measurements were made after the fan had been stopped for 24 hours, when
the surface temperature was 47°F. In the level headings and rise workings
in the Arley Mine about half the normal quantity was circulating, whilst in the
dip workings the stopping of the fan had not made the slightest difference at
the face. Had the downbrow regulator been opened as in the previous test there
is no doubt that an increased rate of circulation would have resulted.
The results obtained from these experiments required further tests for their
elucidation, and it was decided that two tests should be carried out at as near
the same surface temperature as possible ; one with the fan running at normal
speed, and the second with the fan stopped. The chief points to be determined
were : The extent to which the fan influenced the difference of atmospheric
pressure between intake and return in the dip and rise workings ; the variation
in temperature in the workings, and the comparative efficiency of ventilation,
this being defined as the ratio of the quantity of air reaching a given point
in the workings to the total quantity entering the district.
A difficulty then arose as to the means to be used to measure the underground
atmospheric pressure. A portable aneroid barometer was the instrument required,
but unfortunately none of those available was graduated higher than 32 inches.
The one chosen had its dial graduated continuously right round its
circumference, the 32-inch mark coinciding with the 26-inch mark. It was
thought that, by comparing the readings taken with the depth at the point of
measurement, it might be possible to calibrate the instrument as far as was
required. It will be obvious that the experiment should be carried out as
expeditiously as possible, in order to obviate the complications arising from
changes in the surface temperature and pressure. For this reason the number of
places at which readings were to be taken was cut down as much as possible, and
the following places were chosen : Surface and fan-drift, intake and return at
the Seven Feet insets, bottom of downcast and upcast shafts, and two points in
each of the intakes to the rise and dip workings respectively, and the
corresponding points in the return airways. Even with this limited programme it
was found impossible to complete the test under five hours, so that records had
to be kept of the surface temperature and pressure whilst the experiment was in
progress. In order to be able to compare and contrast conditions under extreme
variations of surface temperature, tests were carried out both in summer and
winter.
Calibration of Barometer.
The pressure readings obtained in both summer and winter natural ventilation
tests were plotted in graph form against depths from the surface. In each case
a straight line was obtained up to about 31.8 inches, but at greater depths the
readings gradually fell away from the straight line. By comparing the two
curves, which started at different surface pressures, it was found that, for
any given reading of the instrument, the difference between the reading and the
corresponding point on the straight line was the same in each case. It may
reasonably be assumed, therefore, that the true pressure at any point is that
given by the straight line. From the data obtained from the graph a further
curve was plotted, showing the true pressure for any reading of the barometer,
and from this curve the readings taken in the other tests were evaluated. The
following are the more important of the corrected pressure readings reduced to
normal pressure at the surface:—
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Buxton, L. S. | | | |