|
6th April 1929, Page: 295, Column: 2 Life-Saving DoorsDiscussion on the paper by Mr. T. A. Southern, M.I.M.E., of Cardiff, on "Life-saving in Colliery Explosions and Fires" took place on Wednesday, 20th March, at the meeting of the Midland Counties Institution of Mining Engineers. Although unable to be present to open the discussion Mr. Southern in a communication urged the necessity of life-saving doors. To short-circuit the smoke by opening separation doors, is not always possible ; when it is possible it is not always thought of ; it is a very uncertain protection, for smoke may still invade the workings ; it does not check the fire, it increases it; if it is thought of by the men inbye, they are likely to reject it, for it requires them to adopt the hazardous and desperate step (which is against their natural instincts) of cutting off their way of escape by the return airway and imprisoning themselves in the workings to wait helplessly, hoping for rescue. If, for any reason, the men are not able to escape by the return, the life-saving door will provide them with a reservoir of respirable air in the workings and will greatly aid the Rescue Brigade to rescue them. The following are the principal points which he (Mr. Southern) endeavoured to establish convincingly in his replies to the three previous discussions, though, he fears, without the visible signs of general agreement that he would wish : (1) That the men inbye will make use of the life-saving door when the need arises. (2) That when the fife-saving door has been shut, and even if the fan is not stopped or "slowed," the air in the return will not become irrespirable by leakage of smoke into it, before the men at the face have had time to come out. (3) That facilities for reversal of the ventilation are not an effective safeguard. (4) That providing materials for erecting a barricade is likewise not an effective safeguard. (5) That the specified position — in the intake, just outbye of the first branch road to the face — will rarely be in unsettled ground. (6) That it will be practicable to keep the door — in that position — reasonably air-tight, and that, even a very leaky door will be far bettor than no door. (7) That the door would have been an effective safeguard to avert each of the ten worst disasters in Great Britain in recent years which have been described in the paper and discussions, and in which 990 men and boys were in grave peril, of whom 481 were killed by smoke from a fire in the intake. (In the case of two of those disasters — Mauricewood and Whitehaven — and possibly Whitwick also — this assertion presumes the aid of present-day rescue equipment.) Agreement on these various points is not as yet at all evident. He hopes, therefore, that members, whether they are in favour of the proposed life-saving door, or against it, will freely and frankly express their views. Especially he appeals to those who have experienced the grave danger of a fire in the intake, whether fatal or not, to describe the case and give a sketch of the airways and workings, and tell whether the life-saving door would or would not have been an effective safeguard in that particular case ; and if it would not he urges them to tell the community why. Several members took part in the discussion which followed. Col. Lewis agreed with Mr. Southern that the life-saving door would be the means of saving many lives in colliery accidents with which he had been personally acquainted. Mr. Frank G. Summons (Mansfield) expressed the view that the scheme might be carried a step further, and the life-saving doors made to close automatically in case of fire by means of electrical resistance. Other members supported the proposal, and it was decided to bring the matter before the next meeting of the Institution for further discussion.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||