6th April 1929, Page: 292, Column: 1
Mine Air
By F. L. G. Simpson.
[At the Asansol meeting of the Mining and Geological Institute of India Mr.
Simpson read a paper on "Further Note on the Ventilation of Indian
Mines as compared with the Ventilation of British Mines." The Author deals
with the results from twenty-four Indian mines and twelve English mines, and
submits a great deal of information in tabular form. An important point is
raised in connection with the interchange of heat between the air and strata
and the air passing through the workings. Mr. Simpson's remarks on this
are reproduced from the Transactions of the Institute.]
It is important to note the circumstances which govern the relations between
the temperature and degree of humidity at which the air enters the mine, and
the temperature and degree of humidity which it acquires in its passage through
the shafts and main airways to the workings and through the workings to the
upcast shaft. First of all, the rock temperatures below, say, 65 feet from the
surface, are not affected by climate, but rise, say, 1 degree Fahr. for every
65 feet of depth below the first 65 feet. The general temperature of the rocks
may be taken to be, at this fixed depth of 65 feet, the same as the mean annual
dry bulb temperature of the surface in the shade, at the place of observation.
But it is generally true that in cold climates or cold seasons the outside air
is generally colder than the rocks at or about this level, and in hot climates
or hot seasons the outside air is generally hotter than the rocks at or about
this level. Secondly, all the rocks contain more or less moisture from the
surface downwards, but there appears to be no line of uniform moisture as there
is for uniform temperature. Nor does there seem to be any uniform rate of
increase ot decrease of moisture with depth. It is a general rule, however,
that the moisture increases with the depth, although there are some exceptions
to this rule. The amount of moisture, however, at all depths depends very much
upon the kind of strata and the relative position with regard to other kinds,
also upon a number of other circumstances. The changes in the temperature and
humidity of the air after it enters the mine depend upon the depth and distance
and extent of the workings, and upon the reactions between the air and the
strata, and the rate at which these changes take place is much more rapid where
the differences are greater than where they are small.
As the differences between the air and the strata, both in temperature and in
moisture are generally greatest when the air first enters the mine, the
greatest amount of change generally takes place before the air gets very far
upon its course. After a certain distance the change in one direction ceases,
and under certain conditions the state here arrived at may continue for some
time, but generally a change in the opposite direction commences at once.
Supposing we call the point at which the change in the first direction ceases
the point of first equilibrium, then unless the workings rise to a smaller
depth, there will be a gradual increase in the temperature of the air because
of the increase in the depth and distance travelled, and in some cases there
will be an increase in the temperature in spite of the decrease in depth in
rise workings, due to the air having been heated in the lower levels. The
increase in temperature due to depth is partly owing to the extra heat of the
strata, but chiefly owing to the extra heat which the air acquires by
compression due to its own weight. Besides the increase in temperature and
humidity due to depth there is an increase in both temperature and humidity due
to the larger amount of rock surface exposed by the increased number of
galleries driven, and to the oxidation of coal shale, timber, etc. Then again
the increased number of drivings leads to a smaller quantity of air being
available for each driving, and this decrease in the quantity of air means a
decrease in the velocity of the air-current, which means a less rapid carrying
away of the heat of the strata and other sources of heat, and greater heating
of the air owing to its smaller volume and longer contact with the strata, etc.
The smaller quantity of the air also leads to greater humidity, and the less
rapid cooling of the bodies of the workmen, leading to the greatest discomfort
and loss of work. There is of course also an increase in both temperature and
humidity due to the presence of the workmen, and perhaps horse and to the
burning of lamps, use of explosives and oxidation of the freshly cut coal,
timber, etc. In many cases in India there are steam pumps in the workings as
well as at the upcast shafts, and in some cases in England steam pumps are
still in use in spite of the increase in the use of electricity.
We now come to the all-important question of how far it is possible to control
the temperature and humidity of the air in mines, and by what means. The only
means at our disposal that are generally practicable on a large scale, are the
circulation of proper quantities of fresh air, and its proper distribution to
all parts of the mine. There is no doubt that refrigeration, spraying with
water, dehumidifying, etc., are possible, and some of these means have been
adopted in certain cases, but the cast would be so great as to be prohibitive
in most cases, or would exceed the cost of such an increase in the quantity of
air as would give the same results, and we may therefore leave these measures
out of the question for the present. In some cases local cooling by water
sprays and by compressed air at various points have been found useful on a
limited scale but could not be economically applied on a large scale. There is
a general objection to the use of water sprays on account of the increase in
humidity which they bring about.
We have thus got to depend chiefly upon the circulation of proper quantities of
fresh air, and its proper distribution to all parts of the mine, and upon the
cooling effect of the strata down to that depth from surface at which the
natural temperature of the strata remains lower than the temperature of the air
entering the mine or passing that point. It has sometimes been said, and at
first sight perhaps with some show of reason, that where the outside air is
hotter than the strata, the quantity of air sent into the mine should be kept
as low as possible, consistently with the quantity needed to support life and
to dilute and render harmless noxious gases, etc. But it is only true to a
limited extent that the more hot air we send through the mine the hotter the
mine must necessarily become, because the more air we send into the mine the
greater its velocity ; and the more rapidly both the air and the strata are
cooled by evaporation, and the sooner the air comes down to the natural
temperature of the strata. The evaporation of moisture from the strata will
also bring down the temperature of the strata for a certain thickness from the
sides of the airways, and the effect of this is to keep the temperature of the
strata a few degrees below the temperature of the air for a considerable
distance, until ultimately the point of first equilibrium is reached.
There is no case on record of the temperature of the strata being raised by the
absorption of heat from the air to a temperature above that due to the natural
temperature due to depth, because whatever quantity of air is circulated, all
the heat that is absorbed by the strata is carried away by the conductive power
of the strata; or in other words, there is no limit to the quantity of air
which will be cooled in its passage through the mine, until the point of first
equilibrium is reached. This is better understood when it is remembered that
the strata have an absorbing power for heat of from 50 to 100 times the
absorbing power of air, and a conducting power for heat of about 100 times that
of air. The specific heat of the strata is from about 1½ to 3 times that
of air, or in other words it requires from 1½ to 3 times the amount of
heat to raise one pound of strata one degree Fahrenheit that would be
sufficient to raise one pound of air one degree Fahrenheit. From the above
considerations it is clear that it is exceedingly difficult for the air to
raise the temperature of the strata, and we may accept the conclusion that this
seldom or never happens. On the other hand the air, on account of its much
lower specific heat, is much more easily heated than the strata, and it is
generally known to be the case that where the air enters a mine at a
temperature below that of the strata it gradually acquires heat from the
strata, but it seldom or never reaches the same temperature as the strata, on
account of the cooling effect of evaporation, etc. The air also seldom or never
reaches a temperature higher than that of the strata, and where this does
happen it is not due to the heat of the strata, but to the accumulation of
heat, in a stagnant atmosphere, from the oxidation of coal, burning of lamps,
presence of men, and use of explosives, etc., and to proximity to steam pumps,
etc.
Taking now the cases in which the air, having entered the mine at a temperature
either above or below that of the strata, has at last reached the point at
which the change in temperature in one direction ceases, or "the point of
first equilibrium," we find that in the one case there is a change in the
opposite direction, and in the other case a continuation in the same direction.
But in both cases the action from that point is in the direction of an increase
in the temperature and humidity of the air. This increase in the temperature
and humidity of the air will be due to the following causes : (a) To the
increase in the temperature of the strata due to depth. (b) To the heating of
the air by its compression by its own weight, (c) To the larger amount of rock
surface exposed by the increased number of galleries into which the air will
branch off. (d) To the smaller quantity of air passing in each gallery owing to
the splitting up of the main current, (e) To the lower velocity of these
smaller currents. (f) To the less rapid carrying away of the heat of the strata
and of the heat from other causes, and of the moisture, (g) To the longer
contact of the air with the strata and with other sources of heat and moisture,
(h) To the oxidation of the coal and other substances, (i) To the burning of
lamps, and the use of explosives, (j) To the proximity of steam pumps, etc. (g)
To the presence of men and horses, etc.
Now the total amount of heat available from all the above causes is limited,
and it therefore follows that the more fresh air we send into the mine the
better, since the heat will thus be distributed amongst a greater quantity of
air and from this cause alone the air will become cooler. But besides this
increase in quantity, we find that the increase in velocity has a great effect
in keeping the air cooler, (a) by giving it less time in contact with the
strata and other sources of heat, (b) by the more rapid carrying away of the
heat, and (c) by producing more rapid evaporation. But whilst the amount of
heat with which we have to deal is limited, the quantity of air which we can
send into the mine is practically unlimited, except by the cost of overcoming
the resistances of the mine and shafts, etc. ; and the limit in this direction
has seldom or never been reached, the cost of producing the ventilation being
at most collieries a very small part of the total cost of equipment and
working. It should also be particularly remembered that it is not so much the
dry bulb temperature that affects the worker as the wet bulb temperature, and a
man will work mon comfortably in a dry atmosphere of, say, 90° Fahr. than
in a most atmosphere of, say, 75° Fahr. It is only by circulating large
quantities of fresh air that we can keep down both temperature and humidity.
I would invite attention to the very interesting and instructive points brought
out by the comparison of the figures in the various tables, particularly the
following :—
(a) The much greater depths, distances, and areas of the workings in English
mines than in Indian mines. About 3 times the depths, 12 times the distances,
and 16 times the areas.
(b) The much greater cost of the ventilation in English mines than in Indian
mines. Over 3 times.
(c) The much greater average thickness of the seams in Indian mines than in
English mines. About 4 times.
(d) The much greater output per head in English mines than in Indian mines.
About twice.
(e) The much larger number of men employed underground at one time in English
than in Indian mines. About twice.
(f) The much flatter lie of the seams in English mines than in Indian mines.
About twice as flat.
(g) The much heavier water-gauges required in English mines than in Indian
mines. About 5 times.
(h) The much smaller equivalent orifice of the mine in English than in Indian
mines. About 7/12ths of the Indian.
(i) The much larger orifice of passage of the fan in English than Indian mines
— about twice ; and the much larger fans — about 2½ times the
content.
(j) The much larger total quantity of air produced in English mines than in
Indian mines. About twice, although the quantity per head is slightly smaller
than in the Indian mines.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Simpson, F. L. G. | | | |