|
9th March 1929, Page: 266, Column: 1 Fuel DevelopmentsA lecture was delivered at Nottingham University College on Friday, 15th February, by Dr. J. W. Whitaker, of the Mining and Fuel Department of the College. His subject was "Fuel Developments and the Training of Fuel Technologists," and he had as chairman Dr. F. S. Sinnatt, assistant director of the Fuel Research Board. Movements in Fuel Technology. In the course of his introductory remarks Dr. Sinnatt said that in the past the coal mining industry had been satisfied to obtain the coal from the ground as efficiently and cheaply as possible. Rapid changes in the methods of utilising fuel, and in the balance of the grades of coal required, have made it necessary for industry in general to be increasingly interested in methods of utilisation. The department under Professor W. H. McMillan in the Nottingham University College was unique in the country, as far as he knew, as combining the study of mining and fuels. There are only six centres out of over twenty Universities where Fuel Technology is a full subject of the University curriculum. In thinking about the subject of the utilisation of coal we must remember that only some 35 millions of tons are carbonised in coke ovens or gas works, that 140-150 million tons are used in the raw state, while some 70 million tons are exported. Plants for the production of coke by low temperature carbonisation are being erected in the country, and the coke will be made from small sized coal. If this industry expands less high grade coal will be required for the domestic fire, and the collieries will have to face the new conditions and ensure new outlets for the valuable household coals. Low temperature carbonisation attracts a great deal of attention and is certainly making progress if the number of distinct processes is considered. Coke suitable for domestic purposes may be produced by high temperature carbonisation, and this subject is one requiring the closest attention. Another interesting movement in fuel technology is the use of pulverised coal; here again is a process which calls for small coal and depletes the market of this product. If the fuel is used for the production of electricity or gas or coke, power, light or heating is obtained for domestic purposes, part of which is normally obtained from lump coal. Still another movement which requires the closest attention is the idea of sending gas in pipes for long distances ; one gas main in Germany is over 140 miles long, whilst one in Belgium is about 40 miles long, the gas distributed being obtained from coke ovens. Then there is the hydrogenation of coal. This process in the present stage of its development is not a commercial one, but is of interest when it is remembered that 60 per cent. of the weight of coal can be transformed into oil. This means a yield of 110-130 gallons of oil per ton of coal. The oil broadly speaking resembles crude petroleum, The hydrogenation of coal is also interesting because at the Fuel Research Station it has been discovered that, when non-caking coal is treated with a small percentage of hydrogen, it is converted into a product possessing high caking properties. Difficult Problem. Dr. Whitaker in his lecture said that public interest in fuel is assured because fuel is always with us — in the home and the factory ; thus every man considers it quite within the reach of his knowledge and wisdom to pronounce on the advisability of this or that process of fuel treatment, or to define what should be the national policy in regard to fuel if we wish to avert disaster. Such widespread interest is all to the good provided that there is sound judgment controlling it, and what he (the lecturer) conceives to be the most valuable function of our Fuel Research Board is that they attempt to exercise this judgment. It is, of course, no easy matter to decide upon the merits of the various schemes of (say) coal utilisation which are before us at the present day — whether all domestic coal should be carbonised, and if so, what processes to adopt; whether coal should be cleaned more thoroughly at the collieries ; whether gas fires should be employed more widely ; whether the whole of the coal should be gasified at gas works ; whether powdered coal should be employed on smaller plants, and so forth. Still, these are some of the matters that have to be considered sooner or later by our collieries, our factories, our gas companies, our public power stations, and the like. We have well-known fuels of three kinds, namely, solid, liquid and gaseous. Practically all of these owe their origin to ancient vegetation. As solid fuels we have wood and charcoal, peat and peat charcoal, coal and coke. Our main liquid fuels are petroleum fractions and benzol and alcohol. Among the gaseous fuels we have coal gas, producer gas, blast furnace gas, etc. All the fuels have their special uses. Facts to be Faced. The lecturer mentioned the factors affecting the present depression in the coal industry, emphasising the oil competition, and then dealt with the three processes for the manufacture of oil from coal, more particularly low temperature carbonisation. Assuming all our bituminous coal to be carbonised, the yield of finished liquid fuel fractions would be approximately ten million tons, which is about 7 per cent. of the world's output of petroleum and more than our home consumption. Moreover, the semi-coke is a good smokeless fuel. This is an interesting situation, and it has raised the hopes of many engaged in the coal mining industry. The facts to be faced are : Petroleum oil is not mined, but simply bored for and then pumped, and by a comparatively simple distillation and treatment separated into petrols or gasolines, paraffin oils or kerosenes, heavy fuel oils or residuum ; the products also often including lubricating oils, gas oils, paraffin wax and vaseline. There is very little labour cost. There is no sinking of shafts ; no winding, ventilation and haulage ; no blasting ; no timbering of mine roadways, and all the other heavy items of cost inseparable from the mining of coal. Then again our coal, when it arrives at the surface, is more expensive to handle, being a solid. It has to be weighed, screened, the impurities removed (either by separation in water or by other methods), and the purified material then conveyed to a retort or oven for carbonisation. At the end of it all, when we have scrubbed out the naphthas with creosote oil and condensed all the tar, we have converted about 10 per cent. of our fuel into the liquid form. There remains 70 per cent. of the coal as coke or semi-coke in the retort or oven — 10 per cent. of the coal has gone to gas, and the other 10 per cent. has appeared as water along with the tar. Now the heat in the gas is nearly all required for the carbonisation process, so that we can practically rule it out of our balance sheet. Or, if a gas rich in methane and of high calorific value is in demand, we may sell the gas and heat the retorts by means of some of our semi-coke, burning it first to producer gas, as in the normal gas works practice. Economics of Problem. For simplicity we will consider the former alternative. From one ton of coal, then, we have 15 to 20 gallons of water-free tar, 2 gallons of motor spirit, and 13 cwt. of semi-coke, which may or may not require briquetting to give a suitable smokeless fuel. Assuming coal at £1 per ton, it is a fair estimate that the coke will not sell at any higher rate, since all the ash is still in the coke. We thus have for our semi-coke 13s. and the question arises can we obtain 7s. for 20 gallons of tar and naphthas. If so, i.e., if we can sell our tar and crude naphthas at about 5d. per gallon, the process at any rate is not faced with disaster, though it is difficult to see how it can be remunerative unless we get more nearly twice this price. We require expensive condensation and scrubbing plant for the work and in the recovery of the naphthas special plant for the distillation of the benzolised oil. While, therefore, we might make a profit on the tar if we can sell it at 6d. or 7d. per gallon, the recovery of the motor spirit from the gas would not be a profitable proposition unless we could obtain considerably more per gallon for it in the crude state. Dr. Whitaker added that "protection for these oils and spirits would of course help the low temperature carbonisation industry considerably." There is one further point of no little importance, namely, the transport of the semi-coke. This fuel is unfortunately twice as bulky as coal, and more friable. Its transport will therefore be more expensive, and its storage in modern coal cellars of small dimensions will also present difficulties. Many of the enthusiasts of low temperature carbonisation schemes put forward a programme of this kind. Take the colliery slacks containing 20 or 30 per cent. of ash, wash them, and carbonise the washed slack. Now, a colliery slack containing (say) 25 per cent. of ash can often easily be washed to give excellent coal with 5 per cent. of ash. But, the lecturer proceeded to say, for every ton of the old slack we shall have only about 15 cwt. of washed slack, so that if the price of the crude slack was 10s. per ton, the price of the 15 cwt. washed coal must be 10s. plus (say) 6d. for washing, i.e., 10s. 6d, or roughly 14s. per ton, and the question then becomes one of economics as above. Moreover, as soon as semi-coke made in this way begins to compete with house coals sold by the collieries, the collieries must of necessity put up the price of their slacks. Indeed, there is already a movement in this direction. The collieries cannot afford to rely on the (present) prices of slacks for their profits. There is, however, this much to be said for adopting the process at collieries : that if we can produce coal, washed or otherwise, with a low ash content of not more than 5 per cent. (and preferably not more than 3 per cent.) at a low price, say 10s. to 12s. per ton, then the revenue on our tar and motor spirit, though it is only some 7s. or 8s. per ton of coal, increases the margin of profit to workable dimensions, provided that the output is reasonably large, and that the price of low temperature tar does not fall as the quantity produced increases. Methods of Heating. Into all the various kinds of low temperature carbonisation plant which have been proposed there is no time to enter, said Dr. Whitaker. Suffice to say that the heating of the coal has been attempted in the following ways : (1) By external furnaces as at gas works and coke ovens, the charge being either stationary or in continual movement. (2) By hot flue gases. (3) By hot producer gases. (4) By superheated steam. (5) By means of a molten lead bath, (fi) By allowing powdered coal to fall through a hot tube. (Illustrations of some of these processes were shown.) The modern tendency is either to return to the first method of heating, or to adopt the pulverised coal treatment in conjunction with steam raising plant, i.e., distilling off the oils and gases from the powdered coal before feeding the hot powdered coke into the boiler furnace. The oils are condensed in suitable plant and the gases returned to the furnace or to the jacket of the hot tube to heat it. Dr. Whitaker expressed the view that if we can burn ordinary coal in our domestic grates and avoid the formation of smoke by means of a suitable grid coated with some catalytic substance to complete the combustion of the smoke, the grid to be placed some inches above the fire, many of the arguments for low temperature carbonisation are futile, and at the same time we are enabled to retain that most charming source of heat in a room, the ordinary coal fire. Indeed we should retain it and increase its efficiency ; it was not an extravagant and expensive method of heating our homes. The lecturer said he had rather elaborated the subject of low temperature carbonisation of coal in order to show what are the conditions necessary for the success of semi-coke as a domestic fuel. He repeated them : (1) "Small coal of very low ash content to be obtainable at a low price" ; (2) "Protection or safeguarding for the oils and spirit produced." If these two desiderata were granted, his view was that the industry would live, but that visions of using only coke or semi-coke in domestic and other fires were largely futile. The amount and quality of the coal which could be so carbonised with practical economic success was strictly limited. The carbonisation operations will be best conducted at the collieries if these are in populous districts, e.g., Lancashire, or near large towns. The cost of the transport of semi-coke must always be borne in mind. Training of Fuel Technologists. Coming to the final part of his lecture, viz., the training of fuel technologists, Dr. Whitaker said there were endless branches of the subject, such as the control of combustion in furnaces ; the quality and quantity of radiation from various fuels ; the design of furnaces ; the numerous aspects and problems of heat transference ; the relative advantages of gas of high and of low calorific value; the piping of gas from coke oven plant to distant towns ; the advisability of complete gasification of coal; the applications of powdered coal on board ships ; central heating, and numerous other problems. The type of man required for this kind of work is essentially a chemical engineer with special training in fuels. This is really what constitutes a Fuel Technologist. The training of such a man should be similar to that of an ordinary degree student in science or engineering for the first and second years of his University course, chemistry, physics, mechanics, heat engines and electro-technics being of the greatest importance. In his final year or years his time should be spent on the subjects of : (1) Raw fuels, their mining and production. (2) The purification and dressing of fuels. (3) Coal carbonisation and gasification. (4) Heat transference. (5) Domestic heating and the heating and ventilation of large buildings. (6) The control of combustion. (7) The flow of gases and liquids. (8) Mechanical draught. (9) The composition and testing of refractory materials for furnaces. (10) The testing of fuels, waters and gases. (11) The metering of solids, liquids and gases. (12) Economics. All collieries and all industrial firms consuming large quantities of fuel should have on their staff a trained fuel technologist.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||