|
9th March 1929, Page: 262, Column: 1 Steel SupportsThe attention of readers of this journal has from time to time been directed to the results of experiments with steel supports in the various inspection divisions, and as briefly noted on page 248 in our last issue the British Colliery Owners' Research Association has published Report No. 1 (East Scotland District) on "Use of Iron and Steel for Underground Supports." The report has been prepared by Mr. James S. Carson, who was appointed by the council of the Association to make investigations on their behalf regarding the use of iron and steel under varying conditions at different collieries in the different coalfields. The first results of the series of investigations, covering the East of Scotland, are embodied in the report, three groups of collieries ("A," "B," and "C") having been selected for the purpose of the inquiry. The Report, the price of which is 2s. 6d., by post 2s. 9d., is illustrated by 29 diagrams, and managers and other colliery officials will find in its pages much valuable information. In a foreword it is explained that "the council of the British Colliery Owners' Research Association have had before them for some time the possibility of an increased use of iron and steel for underground supports in mines. There is reason to think that there is considerable scope for the increased use of iron and steel in place of timber with greater efficiency and better economy in working. A substantial increase in the use of iron and steel in place of timber would also be of material benefit to the heavy British industries in increasing the demand for iron and steel and thus also for coal." Experience at Collieries. In his general remarks under "A" Collieries Mr. Carson says : For several years a large amount of experimental work has been done at the collieries in this group, with a view to the introduction of iron and steel supports underground. The result of these experiments has been a general adoption of steel arch girders for road supports. These are now being used close to the face — i.e., they are set immediately the road is brushed. The problem of face supports has not, however, been definitely solved. The management have now arrived at the conclusion that face props must be as near as possible rigid. This creates an extreme difficulty since the seams vary considerably in height, sometimes in quite short distances. Again, in some cases using a more or less rigid prop, it is very costly and difficult to get all the props withdrawn. It would appear that the desired prop while remaining rigid under the load should be capable of adjustment in length — (1) To suit variations in height at the face, and (2) to facilitate the withdrawal. Certain lessons have been learned during this experimental period, the chief among them being enumerated below: (1) Prejudice on the parts of both officials and workmen directly concerned, can only be overcome by gaining their confidence in the safety of the method. (2) The systems must be perfectly understood by those concerned, and must be rigidly enforced. (3) Intimate personal supervision is absolutely essential: (a) To ensure adequate number of props of the requisite length ; (b) To see that timber and steel props are not mixed on the same face — any mixed system allows uneven settling of the roof and causes breaks to take place over the face ; (c) To ensure that all props are withdrawn regularly from the waste ; (d) To maintain the system rigidly ; (e) To keep account of props in use and of numbers damaged or lost; (f) To organise and supervise variations in methods of packing, etc. (4) The introduction of steel props must be done under a definite system, otherwise the transition period will be very long and very costly. During this period intensive supervision is essential. Control of Superimposed Strata. Mr. Carson discusses the theory of roof control and then proceeds to say :— Having decided our method for face support we have yet to tackle the control of the superimposed strata. It has been stated that nothing of a practical nature can be done that will permanently prevent subsidence in this strata. The solid coal is now replaced by a system of roadside packs and waste packs interspaced by areas of waste filled with broken rock. These packs must be strong enough to control the settling of the main body of overlying rocks, that is they must allow a regular subsidence to take place. The support given by the packs will depend on: (a) The number of packs, (b) width of packs, (c) the material of which built and the manner in which built. The number of packs is more or less already fixed from the spacing required to allow our wastes to fill themselves behind the last row of props. There can be no argument, other than building the packs as strong as possible with the available material. Given good workmanship the strength of the packs in any given case will depend on their width. Packs should be built continuously at right angles to the face line. Packs should not zig-zag across the face as this disturbs the regularity of the roof movements. Stepping the packs has less effect but should also be avoided if possible. The size of packs required can only be ascertained by experience at the face, as no correct forecast can possibly be made, without actual tests at the face. The roadside packs must be wide enough to form one support under the main roof. That is the packs should act as one support and be sufficiently strong to prevent extensive breaks taking place over the road. As subsidence of the superimposed strata causes the packs to squeeze down, it is essential that the road supports should accommodate themselves to this settling. Timber supports break and have to be renewed, whereas when arch girders are used they accommodate themselves by bending and twisting, but continue to maintain a fairly safe road and to prevent falls of stone, long after being badly distorted. Replacement of twisted girders is not essential until it is necessary to enlarge the road, whereas in many cases it is necessary to replace timber supports several times within the live area of (say) 60 yards from the face. By these methods the subsidence of the main body of superimposed strata follows at a more or less definite distance behind the face ; beyond this distance, although subsidence still continues, it is very gradual and very regular. These conditions seem to be best met by the use of steel props as: (1) Steel props are more economical when once a definite system has been established. (2) By using steel props we are able to guarantee the strength of every, prop will be sufficient to carry the required load, without exceeding the elastic limit strength of the prop. (3) Wood props do not have the requisite rigidity nor uniformity in strength to control the roof at the face. (4) Where steel props are used, regularity of withdrawing can be more easily maintained, and definite propping systems more rigidly enforced. (5) With steel supports there are fewer minor falls at the face, and consequently fewer interruptions of coal getting and less oncost labour. (6) With fewer falls at the face the number of accidents due to falls of stone is reduced. (7) Steel props can be produced at home and in many cases steel tubes which otherwise would only have a scrap value can be utilised. Advantages of Steel Arches. (1) By bending and twisting under pressure, the girders accommodate themselves to the subsidence, while continuing to provide sufficient support to prevent falls of stone, which, where timber supports are used, are a constant source of worry and expense, causing serious interruptions of output and continuous cost for clearing the falls and replacing the props. (2) By reducing the number of falls on roads the number of accidents is reduced. (3) Arch girders give a greater resistance against side pressure. (4) Where floor is liable to "heave" in roadways this can in many cases be cut through without interfering with the girders. Using props these must be replaced when pavement is brushed. (5) Derailed tubs do not displace girders so easily as they do props. (6) Bent and twisted girders can be re-shaped and used again. (7) Steel arch girders can be produced at home. This would materially benefit the steel industry, and ultimately the coal industry. (8) By using steel arches a considerable saving in maintenance is effected. (9) When using steel arches the air friction is greatly reduced. (10) Means whereby steel arches can conform to subsidence without being damaged have been successfully applied. While it is realised that any figures so calculated can only be a very rough approximation, the following estimate is of interest as showing the effect on the demand for coal if steel could be utilised to completely replace foreign timber. It seems reasonable to assume that for every ton of coal produced there would be in use four steel props, at an average weight of about 70 lb. Taking a daily output for Great Britain of 1,000,000 tons, this would require 125,000 tons of steel props. Allowing a rate of consumption of 1 per cent. per week, the yearly consumption of steel for props would be 65,000 tons. Allowing for the use of corrugated steel straps to replace wood planks and bars, etc., the consumption of steel for face support would probably be in the nature of 100,000 tons. The estimation for steel arches cannot be made, except very roughly, as the quantity used will vary within much wider limits, but it would seem to be quite safe to estimate on the use of 1 ton of arch girders per 1,000 tons of output. At this rate the annual consumption would be in the region of 270,000 tons of steel. If these estimations be accepted then there is a possible market for 1½ million tons of coal annually to produce steel for colliery consumption. This figure would of course be greatly exceeded during the period of introduction and it would probably be more than doubled during the first two years. No account has been taken in these estimates of the use of steel sleepers and all-steel tubs for underground use, nor steel sleepers and all-steel wagons for surface use, and it is certain that their use could be greatly extended with very beneficial effects to the coal and iron trades, and incidentally to this country as a whole.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||