Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th March 1929

Cleator Moor

Some Collections And Recollections

VII. The Orange Riot

If it be true that the state of the weather influences our frame of mind, the inhabitants of West Cumberland ought to have been in a most amicable mood on that long-remembered Saturday, the 12th of July, 1884, for old Sol beamed upon everything. The demonstration was organised on the usual large scale, a special train bringing in the whole of the outlying forces at about eleven o'clock, the visiting brethren being met at the station by the Cleator Moor Lodge.

As it may be of interest to older readers I will give the names of some of the divisional "brass hats," or some "masters," as they are termed by the craft. The Workington district was strongly represented, the three town lodges being officered by W. J. Park, John McKeeg, and James McVay, while that of Seaton had William Howson; Great Clifton, William Hetherington; and Harrington, Robert Quayle, John Mitchell headed the Cockermouth contingent, as did Daniel Wear and John Wylie for Whitehaven; the Parton partisans followed James Runnet; the Distington denomination followed George Elliot; a posse from St. Bees and another from Gosforth answered to James Edmonds and Joseph Little respectively; the neighbourhood Frizington phalanx being commanded by Samuel Forsyth. Rather significantly, perhaps the Cleator Moor "Unexpected" Lodge did not muster many members- the absentees possibly adopting "expected" as their cognomen for that day — but their skipper, John Bawden, was present along with the Rev. G. B. Armes, who lived many years and died Rector of Cleator. Another ominous factor was added by the arrival of a force of sixteen constables by the ordinary train, who were armed with swords, so that, together with previous arrivals of men in blue, similarly armed, there were in all about forty men in attendance.

It was a stirring sight, I have been told, and a rather awe-inspiring one, too, when the Orangemen, some 800 in number, formed themselves into procession, the route being over the Moor to Cleator, through Ehen Hall grounds, and back to a field at Wath Brow top. Each Lodge was accompanied by a band - there were brass bands, drum and fife bands, and in one instance the personnel consisted of two pipers, followed by two big drummers, who belaboured their drums with a couple of drum sticks each. Then each detachment had its distinctive large silk banner, all the members were clad in full regalia, and as a portion of the Insignia of the Order, probably, quite every second man carried a pike of a more or less ornamental character. These, however, were not of the theatrical description - not wooden imitations, but solid and substantial, with metal pikes, and capable of making an ugly hole in a man if directed with sufficient violence.

On the outward journey everything, with the exception of the bands, was irreproachably quiet and peaceable, but as all the musicians played all the time the din must have been deafening and discordant. Some played pleasant Scotch airs and quick-steps but other pugnacious pipers kept up an incessant rattle at insulting, irritating party tunes, such as "Boyne Water," "Come out if you dare," "To Hell with the Pope" &c., with the loud pedal on as they passed the Roman Catholic Church. Orange lilies were defiantly waved in the faces of girls, but strangely enough the streets were not crowded, the men of Cleator Moor being conspicuous by their absence, though here and there were ancient dames standing at their doors.

"Gathering their brows like gathering storm.
Nursing their wrath to keep it warm."

But never a word did they speak.

Unmolested, then, the demonstrators trooped into the field at Wath Brow, where they had tea in a marquee. Then came speeches by several strangers and Mr. Armes, the latter congratulating the Orangmen on the excellent order they had maintained and expressing his great astonishment at seeing such a large number of police men present. As none of these orators were of the inflammatory type and the heating influence of John Barleycorn being a negligible factor - it being generally agreed at the time that only one drunken man was seen all day - it is fairly obvious that what followed was done by design.

In spite of the previously spread lurid threats of widespread slaughter, their peaceful reception in the town lulled the suspicions of the demonstrators, for the character of the return march was straggling, big gaps being between the lodges and spaces between the files. Shrewd observers, however, noticed with grave misgivings a general motion of the spectators to the centre of town, and that the pockets of many of the men bulged as if filled with stones. Converging from the side streets into the Market Square the crowd awaited the approach, of the procession, and as it drew near, the younger men and girls began to pelt both the processionists and the police Supt. Thornburrow, of Whitehaven, and Superintendent Taylor, of Cockermouth, being at once singled out for special attention. Then there was a general rush on the part of the crowd, an attempt being made with varying degrees of success to tear down and destroy the obnoxious banners. Now Orangemen - and most other mortals possessing any grit - when smitten on one cheek are not the sort of men to passively present the other for a like compliment, consequently, as they by no means entertained friendly feelings towards their aggressors, they retaliated very vigorously.

As is usual in disturbances like this, where firearms are used, the important question arises as to which side fired the first shot. Stone-throwing and fisticuffs are one thing, but the whiz of death-dealing bullets is another matter altogether.

When the van of the procession was attacked, Grand Master Bawden, the leader, who was without defensive weapon of any kind, at once said to his followers: "Whatever you do, don't fire," for he knew that most of them had revolvers in their pockets charged with blank cartridge. Immediately after a pistol was discharged from the midst of the mob, the bullet whizzing past his head, but still he implored his men not to fire.

Six or seven Orangemen were now lying on the road as a result of the flying stones, and unable to restrain themselves any longer, their companions opened a rapid fire with their revolvers and vigorously laid about them with swords, pikes, and broken banner poles. Showers of stones assailed them from all sides, pistols were freely discharged at them from behind walls, and desperate hand-to-hand fighting was common, the opponents in this case, locked in deadly embrace, rolled over and over on the ground, struggling like the proverbial Kilkenny's cats. The fat was now literally in the fire, and fiercely did it burn.

There is, I think, little doubt that many of the shots fired by the disciples of the "great and good King William" were blank cartridge, but more deadly ammunition was used, and, as is frequently the case, the innocent suffered. One of the earliest shots that were fired, from Fletcher Street, killed a young Post Office official named Henry Tumelty. This unfortunate youth was a Roman Catholic, consequently as the news of a fatality spread like wildfire, the rage of the mob knew no bounds, and a first-class riot raged.

The police on this occasion were in an extremely trying position, for they were placed between two contending parties, without having the power to arrest anyone, however great might be the insult or offence, and without being able to protect themselves in any way. Some of the local magistrates, including Mr. J. S. Ainsworth, Mr. Jefferson, and Mr. J. F. Kirkconel, tried to stem the boiling tide of infuriated townsfolk at the Conservative Rooms, and the Rev. Robert Walker, curate of St. John's, and now the esteemed Silloth Canon, was injured in the face and leg while attempting to quell hostilities.

At Crossfield Road corner there was a hot encounter, many of the rioters having come from Montreal Street through the gardens at the rear; consequently a large crowd awaited the procession at the Leconfield Street junction. Joe Fisher, who then was landlord of the Ironworks Hotel, was wounded by a bullet through he took no part in the affray, and many others were "laid out" - a good old Cleator Moor term, that - at this spot. The local Orangemen thinking no doubt that discretion was the better part of valour, here gained shelter in their Lodge room, the old hematite building. Fighting all the way, the visiting celebrants at last reached the railway station, where they entrained. Considerable damaged was done to the Company's buildings and carriages before the train moved off, shots being freely exchanged all the time. Chief Constable, Dunn arrived at this juncture and remained until the crowd dispersed shortly afterwards.

Much excitement prevailed in the town all night, fights occurred in nearly every street, but gradually peace was restored. For many days, however no Protestant household retired to rest without having someone on guard, many sleeping with a revolver under their pillows; and for a number of years, when the 12th of July drew near, it was simply courting trouble for anyone to go abroad sporting an orange lily, or indeed any flower of similar hue.

An "official" list of casualties was one killed and fourteen wounded, nearly all of the latter suffering from severe gunshot, sabre, and spear wounds. There were, of course, many others of a minor nature and many a cracked pate, cut, and bruised did the druggists treat that night. This enumeration does not include the Orangemen's losses, which, though undoubtedly pretty numerous, were not of such a serious nature.

Inaccurate Official Report.

Shortly afterwards the Home Secretary, Sir William Harcourt, read Chief Constable Dunne's rather inaccurate report of the lamentable occurrence in the House of Commons, and some discussion arose. Mr. T. P. O'Connor asked questions regarding the action of the Government in respect of the Orange possessions. In a lengthy reply, Sir William stated that the Home Office had no authority over the Justices or the police, and that the very difficult question of meetings likely to lead to a breach of the peace rested entirely on the authorities on the spot - the Magistrates. Unfortunately, however, at that time the Magistrates had not the power, to prohibit a lawful meeting merely because it was likely to lead to a breach of the peace. Previously, from 1867 to 1871, they had, but on a case arising out of the Salvation Army - which suffered much persecution in its early history - the Queen's Bench Division decided that the Magistrates had no right to stop a lawful assembly simply because trouble might ensue by others. The Home Secretary also said - and this is a point I promised a word of explanation about - that the letter written to him by Father Burchall did not reach him until two days after the riot, but this was of no importance, for he could only have forwarded it to the Cleator Moor Justices, who had all the information.

R.H.L

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ainsworth, J. S.      
Armes, G. B., Rev.      
Bawden, John      
Edmonds, James      
Elliot, George      
Fisher, Joe      
Forsyth, Samuel      
Harcourt, William, Sir      
Hetherington, William      
Howson, William      
Kirkconel, J. F.      
Little, Joseph      
McKeeg, John      
McVay, James      
Mitchell, John      
O'Connor, T. P.      
Park, W. J.      
Quayle, Robert      
Runnet, James      
Taylor, —      
Thornburrow, —      
Turnelty, Henry      
Walker, Robert, Rev.      
Wear, Daniel      
Wylie, John      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print