|
9th February 1929, Page: 232, Column: 2 Life-Saving DoorsFrom reply by Mr. T. A. Southern, M.I.M.E., to discussion on his paper on "Life-saving in Colliery Explosions and Fires." Part 3 of Vol. LXXVI. of the Transactions of the Institution of Mining Engineers. Should the Life-saving Door be Fireproof? This is certainly preferable, but it is not essential, nor is it very important. In ninety-nine cases out of a hundred, the wooden door will be equally effective. In a mine subject to gob-fires, however, especially if the intake was timbered, a gob-fire might break out close to the life-saving door, and a fireproof door would be the more necessary in such a mine. In the event of the door being itself involved in the conflagration, a wooden door, of course, would be of no avail, but the chances are so remote that they may be ignored. Moreover, of all fires in intakes a fire at the point specified for the door is likely to be the least dangerous, because the men in-bye will get the earliest warning of it and will have the best chance to put it out or to escape past it without danger to themselves. Will the Door be Reasonably Air-tight? In very many instances the door will be in almost completely settled ground. There is nothing to prevent the life-saving door from being kept quite as air-tight as the best ordinary air door, and, in any case, even if the life-saving door is very leaky, it will be a vastly better safeguard than no life-saving door. Leakage of Smoke into the Return through Doors and Stoppings. The author is of the opinion that proper maintenance of doors and stoppings, besides having a beneficial effect on the normal ventilation, will reduce leakage of smoke to such an extent that it will not foul the return before the men have had time to come out. Dangerous leakage is especially unlikely if the fan be stopped, as it should be, in all cases of fire in the intake, thus taking the pressure off all leakage paths, reducing the supply of air, to the fire, and preventing the rapid coursing of smoke and fumes through the airways. That the return may be foul, as suggested by the President (Major Currer Briggs), and that the men may walk out-bye from "an atmosphere, near the face, able to support life" into irrespirable air, so far from being an objection to the life-saving door, really emphasises its value, because the door is absolutely essential to procure the breathable atmosphere near the face. The men will rarely, if ever, be so bereft of reason, or so lacking in intelligence, as to fail to realise that, if they find the outer part of the return airway full of smoke (a very improbable eventuality, save in the case of an idle split open to the same return), they have a reservoir of breathable air behind them, and that they should retreat and remain in this good air till rescued, or till the conditions have improved so much that they can come out safely without needing to wait till rescuers come in. The author thinks the life-saving door will prevent panic and that miners will soon learn its purpose and its possible limitations and how to take full advantage of its protection. If a case occurs where miners perish through the rashness above indicated, their fate will impress on all miners what they must do for their own safety in such circumstances. Men in the Intake Out-bye of Life-saving Door. Major Currer Briggs suggests that the instinct of self-preservation will always impel these men to rush out-bye in the intake, and that it will be very difficult to persuade them to go in-bye and then travel out by the return. Much depends, the author thinks, on the age and type of these men and where they are when the smoke reaches them. If they are young and inexperienced and lacking in the "team spirit," and have not worked at the face, and are therefore not familiar with the life-saving door, and especially, if they are more than half-way out-bye at the time, they probably will make a dash to get out through the smoke and if they do give a thought to the men at the face, they may reasonably think that they can best help to save the men in-bye by rushing out-bye themselves to give the alarm. But if these assumptions be reversed, this very same instinct of self-preservation, plus a desire to warn and save their mates in-bye, plus their acquaintance with the life-saving door, will impel them to rush inbye to get to the life-saving door and shut it, and they will not "be shutting themselves in, further from safety," but will be holding back the smoke, and securing for themselves and their mates a safe way of escape by the return. Life-saving Doors and Complicated Ventilation System. In reply to Professor Douglas Hay, we all know that there are complicated systems in some mines — for example, where a section of working faces has more than one intake reaching the face at different points, or where the intake air for one district is the return air from another district, reinforced perhaps by a split of fresh air joining it; but whether the scheme of ventilation is simple or complex, whether the splits are separate and distinct or are tangled or interwoven, it is inevitable that every range, group, or district of working places must be served by one or more intakes, and the men can be protected from smoke from a "fire in the intake" by providing them with a life-saving door at the in-bye end of each intake. Life-saving Door v. Materials for a Barricade. The author has not advocated the idea that materials for the building of a barricade should be kept always ready for use at the positions specified for the life-saving doors. He has mentioned this as the next best and only substitute for the life-saving door, but immediately swept it aside and denounced it as a substitute, thoroughly unreliable as a real safeguard. Some essential item of equipment — or men able to erect the barricade quickly — might not be available at the critical emergency ; and, even in the most favourable circumstances, the provision of barricading materials bears absolutely no comparison with the completely erected and readily closed life-saving door. Another drawback is that a barricade would prevent anyone who was in the intake from escaping into whatever good air the barricade did retain. Life-saving Door in an Over-rope Haulage-road. Major Hudspeth has pointed out that if the door has to be placed in an over-rope haulage-road, it will have to be in four parts instead of two. Some difficult cases of that sort will doubtless occur, but these will be very few. Nearly always the position specified will be in-bye of the end of the main haulage ; in fact, at the in-bye end of the double parting which feeds the main haulage. Where the specified position is not a convenient one, it will usually be possible to circumvent the difficulty by choosing a position farther in-bye, even though that may necessitate two life-saving doors in two sub-intakes, instead of only one life-saving door in the intake. Cwm Colliery Explosion and Fouling of Return Airway. In the Cwm explosion, to which reference has been made by Major Hudspeth and Professor Douglas Hay, there were twenty-Seven men in the Old Coal District unaffected by the explosion, the seven who came out by the return got out alive, the other twenty perished. It was a narrow escape for these seven, for When they had travelled about 1,600 yards of their journey to the upcast, with the smoke and after-damp following them, they found the last 800 yards of the return fouled by afterdamp coming from the Black Vein District, which was devastated by the explosion. It is suggested that if a life-saving door had been shut by the men in the Old Coal District and all those twenty-seven men had come out by the return, they would (or might) have found this last 800 yards in a more poisonous state owing to the life-saving door in the Old Coal District turning all the ventilation of that side of the colliery on to the Black Vein District and so driving out the afterdamp into the return. Let us assume that this would have occurred, for it is a distinct possibility. It is certainly not an argument against the life-saving door. It shows that this part of the return might have been deadly either with or without this door. Without this door, the men would have had death behind as well as in front; with it, they would have had assurance of life and safety on one side. Miners will soon learn that if they rush out into foul air in the return they will defeat the whole object of the life-saving door, and it will not be attributable to any fault or failure of the door. But the author ventures to prophesy that when the life-saving door has become a familiar object in every intake, it will give the men such a sense of safety and confidence in the face of this danger that they will not rush out into foul air, but will go warily, and, finding the air bad, they will retreat and wait in the good air behind them. It is at least equally probable that the increased ventilation, short-circuited by the destruction of air-doors in the Black Vein District (unless even the short-circuit was blocked by air-tight falls), would have swept out the after-damp from this open thoroughfare and cleared this last 800 yards of return whilst those men were travelling the first 1,600 yards, and that they would thus have reached the upcast in good air all the way. Whitehaven Explosion and Fire. Regarding the Whitehaven disaster : It would not be reasonable to suggest that the life-saving door will, of a surety, save the lives of the men in every conceivable set of adverse circumstances that may occur. Whitehaven was not just a fire in the intake ; and it was a very adverse case, for the men's egress from Nos. 5 and 6 Districts via the return was barred by smoke which was passing from a fire in the intake through blown-out stoppings into the return, and by afterdamp which was flowing into the same return from No. 3 District. Smoke and afterdamp had also been driven at least 400 yards in-bye into their return by the prolonged blast of the explosion. Opinions may differ as to whether the sense of security that will be given by the life-saving door, and the lessons its presence will automatically convey to the officials and men, would have resulted in the eighty-five men, or many of them, effecting their escape in those first two hours. It is probable. For, of course, where men have shut the life-saving door to stop smoke that was coming in-bye, and have then found that they cannot escape by the return, it would be unreasonable to suppose that, being protected by the life-saving door, they will sit down aimlessly and helplessly behind it without making frequent cautious investigations to test the condition of things in the return, and also in the intake out-bye of the life-saving door, in the latter case making use of the trap-door for that purpose ; and, in some cases, they will find that conditions in the return or intake have improved to such an extent that they can come out safely by the return or intake, without needing to wait for rescuers coming in. In some cases, this improvement will be the result of what the rescue men have been doing.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||