|
9th February 1929, Page: 228, Column: 1 Organisation Of Mining IndustryBy Professor George Knox, F.G.S., M.I.M.E. [Professor George Knox is an Ayrshire man by birth, was Head of the Mining Department of the Wigan Mining and Technical College for eight years, and for two terms lectured at Manchester University, whilst during the last sixteen years he has been the Principal of the South Wales School of Mines at Treforest. Elected President of the South Wales Institute of Engineers for the current year, he delivered his Presidential Address on Thursday, the 24th of January. Pointers from his address are given below.] Seven Decades Ago. It is exactly seventy years since Mr. Menelaus gave his inaugural Presidential Address to this Institute, and despite the many changes which have taken place during that period his excellent address, with but slight alterations, as to sizes and quantities, is as pertinent to-day as the day on which it was given. We can fully realise the great advance that has been made in the standard of living, health, education, social welfare and leisure of the great mass of the people in this country, and yet many of the problems which faced the founders of the Institute are still with us. Mr. Menelaus stated that "cheap production is one of the most important questions of our time" ; that "we must make up by mechanical invention for the want of those natural advantages we are gradually losing from the exhaustion of our cheaply worked minerals" ; that "the price of labour is steadily and surely advancing and machinery must of necessity be largely substituted for manual labour" ; that "power with us is cheaply produced, but we want some means of conveying it through the ramification of a mine and over the surface of our works." After alluding to the enormous waste of material, he showed that their engineering establishments had not kept pace with the growth of the industry because their engineers had to expend the whole of their energies to keep the machine moving and had little time for reflection. Problems Intensified. Despite the fact that during the intervening seventy years we have had the most marvellous scientific discoveries the world has ever known, with an enormous increase in our educational facilities, we are to-day faced with similar problems intensified to an extent unparalleled in the history of the mining industry. It is not that there is any lack of money to finance industry, as is shown by the amount of money forthcoming for the promotion of every available type of luxury-supplying company. It is a sad commentary on our ability to organise ourselves as a nation that the staple industries, like agriculture, coal, iron and steel — upon which the very existence of the nation depends — should be bankrupt, while enormous profits can be made in every luxury trade, whether it be chewing gum, gramophones, tobacco, silk stockings or petrol. That there is something radically wrong with the mining industry every one is agreed, and it is not for lack of advice and criticism that those responsible for its management are unable to effect an improvement. If, however, half the suggested remedies for reviving the industry had been put into operation there would not be a working colliery in existence to-day. As history frequently shows, it takes a period of adversity to provide the driving force required to apply inventive ideas. It is quite probable that, as a result of our present experiences in adversity, there will arise a new organisation of the mining industry, the beginnings of which are already being attempted. Continental Plans. It is unfortunate that, having the knowledge of the somewhat similar experience of other coal-producing nations to guide us, we should have hesitated so long before attempting to apply the necessary drastic remedies. In 1893 Germany, faced with depression and chaos in the mining industry, formed the Rhenish Westphalian Syndicate, of which all collieries were forced to become members. This Syndicate took over the control of all sales and marketing of the coal produced, and arranged the quota of output from each district. It is an entirely separate organisation, with its own offices and technical experts. In 1923-24 when the industries were again in a desperate state and on the verge of ruin, with the experience already gained by the working of the Syndicate they were able to apply a scheme of centralisation and rationalisation together with the scientific marketing of their products, which has enabled them not only to provide the necessary reparation coal but to flood the Western European market with cheap coal. All uneconomic collieries were closed down and the output from the remainder was increased by a process of concentration, centralisation and mechanisation, whereby, despite the loss of 40 per cent. of her coal reserves (the Saar Coalfield), the output in 1927 was 94 per cent. above that for 1913. Penalties Pioneers Suffer. While we undoubtedly have some of the finest collieries in the world we are burdened with a large number of small uneconomic units, and after all it is the average that counts. We still suffer the penalties of all pioneers — conservatism and prejudice against change — as compared with the more recently developed continental coalfields. In the early days of coal mining in this country the colliery manager was the only technical man required, and the tendency to-day in spite of the enormous development of machinery employed, is to continue this system. In the newer continental coalfields the mining industry is organised in departments, each with its own staff and responsibilities. This probably accounts for the fact that in Germany 83 per cent. of the total output is machine cut, while Belgium has 67 per cent., France 53 per cent., and Great Britain only 23 per cent. Another reason has been put forward to account for our lagging behind continental competitors in the mechanisation of our collieries, namely, the age at which we appoint the bulk of our under officials. In the early days of mining by hand labour, the experienced workman was unquestionably the best type from which competent firemen and overmen could be obtained, but to-day when coal-getting and transportation are becoming highly mechanised the men required for these posts should be technically trained and young enough to adapt themselves to the rapidly changing conditions. These posts should also provide the training and experience required for later successful management. It is difficult to understand how people can support the claim of a colliery manager to act at 25 years of age and yet hesitate about the appointment of a fireman until he had reached the age of about 50. There are others who tell us that it is our lack of a proper system of marketing which is the chief cause of our troubles. Mr. R. Addy, M.A., stated recently that "with the exception of agriculture no great industry had more to learn on the subject of marketing than the coal industry." He attributed this defect to our excessive individualism ; to the number of different coalfields in the country, and to the large number of sizes and qualities of coal produced, together with our easily gained prosperity in the past. Another managing director of a colliery (Mr. A. W. Archer) a few weeks, ago stated that "no country, I regret to say, sells its coal less scientifically or expertly than Great Britain, and our sales organisation, if such there be, is, perhaps, the worst in Europe," and "until effective marketing schemes are set up in this country it will be difficult to avoid passing from one misfortune to another." Difficulties Not Insurmountable. The problem confronting the coalowners in this country in devising a national scheme for the co-operative marketing of coal, is a more formidable one than that facing the German coalowners in 1893. The difficulties, however, are not insurmountable, and it is to be hoped that the outcome of the present negotiations will result in a satisfactory solution of at least the co-operative phase of the problem. When the coal trade is in the position of the great oil, tobacco, and other syndicates of being able to determine the price at which its commodities can be bought, we shall be much nearer the solution of our difficulties. Before this can be accomplished some system of international co-operation will have to be established, which would compel us in this country to adopt a more scientific method of preparing our coal for marketing abroad, with a sales organisation capable of supplying a product on a certificate guarantee, within one per cent. either way. Great hopes have been raised in some quarters regarding the advantages to be obtained through amalgamation. Its chief objects are to secure greater economy in production, management and salesmanship and at the same time provide greater financial stability and regulate competition. Only large organisations can afford the financial outlay required to provide new developments on a large scale, and carry out the necessary research work to overcome technical and organisation problems. It is only under such conditions that uneconomic collieries can be closed down without great hardship to the employees, because most — if not all — of the workmen can be transferred to the more economic units under the same company. The most hopeful and beneficial result that is likely to be derived from amalgamations is the possibility of the application of what is now known as "Rationalisation." Stated in plain English, as defined by the Geneva Economic Conference, rationalisation simply means "the methods of technique and of organisation designed to secure the minimum of waste of either effort or material. It includes the scientific organisation of labour, the standardisation both of material and of products, the simplification of processes and improvements in the system of transport and marketing." Education and Industry. In matters of technique we are still far from perfection in the average colliery undertaking, and one of the chief causes for this lag in the application of proved technical methods is the absence of co-operation between industry and technical institutions. While we may deplore the lack of co-operation which has existed between industry and technical education in the past, it is satisfactory to know that such an important industrial organisation as the Federation of British Industries has realised the seriousness of the position, which is always a preliminary step to finding a solution of the problem. Technical education — like the mining industry — in this country suffers from its pioneering defects. It has always been voluntary in character, and from the early days of the Mechanics Institutes until the present day most of the work has been carried out in the evenings after the students had completed their day's work. In this country we usually think of secondary education merely as a preparatory course of training for professional life, and any effort to apply it as a source of industrial training — as in the case of Junior Technical Schools — has met with the most strenuous opposition. Given a proper system of combined technical education and practical training as provided by the "Sandwich" system, the application of technique and organisation to secure a minimum of waste of either effort or material would be brought appreciably nearer. It was estimated that the application of the Rhenish Westphalian Syndicate system of marketing in 1893 saved waste in labour, transport and middlemen's profits to the extent of 30 per cent. Enormous sums have also been saved by the substitution of pneumatic drills and picks for hand labour in the Ruhr, where 80 per cent. of the coal is obtained by the use of 150,000 of these tools. In the same area through the standardisation of equipment, costs have been materially reduced and fewer spare parts have to be kept in stock. Perhaps the greatest advantage to be obtained from any scheme of rationalisation will be the reduction of costs as a result of centralisation and concentration. In 1923 the United States of America National Coal Commission in their report on Underground Management, referring to the efficient application of mechanical cutting, loading and conveying of coal, stated that "the importance of the use of loading machinery may be appreciated, when in many cases the total cost, as shown by operating results, was reduced by 30 per cent. Mechanical coal-getting also enabled a system of concentration of work in small areas with a reduction of costs (other than coal-getting) by doing away with excessive roadways — reducing tram lines and timber — with a reduction in the cost of supervision and losses in ventilation. The area of working face to be kept open and the number of men employed were almost halved, while the output per man employed was increased by 80 to 90 per cent." In reference to the scheme of rationalisation, there is the question of waste of products and improved marketing. In regard to the former, the greatest waste is the direct use of raw coal as a fuel for heating and power production, with the consequent pollution of the atmosphere. Great progress has been made in the last few years towards a solution of this form of waste, and during the next few years we are likely to see enormous developments in the carbonising and liquefying of small coal. Causes of Slump. Among the important causes which are said to have contributed to the present difficulty to dispose of our coal at economic prices, the following may be cited: (a) World over-production. (b) Loss of markets as a result of the war, labour troubles, and the supply of reparation coal, (c) The depressed state of the large coal-using industries, (d) The increased expenditure on rates, taxes and transport, (e) Greater economy in the use of fuel. (f) Increase in hydro-electric installations, (g) The substitution of oil as a fuel particularly for road transport and shipping. The continued restriction of our export trade has made it impossible to supply the large coal-using industries at home with cheap fuel, with the result that they also have experienced a trade depression almost as great as the coal industry itself. Until our export trade can be revived it is difficult to see how the iron and steel industries, for example, can be provided with the necessary cheap fuel that would enable them to successfully compete with similar subsidised industries on the continent. The more economical methods of using fuel which have resulted in a reduction in the quantity of coal used per horse-power of energy generated and the increase in hydro-electric installations, while affecting to some extent the coal market, are in both cases laudable improvements which may be expected to continue to develop in the future. A more serious menace, however, is the substitution of oil as a fuel, particularly for road and ocean transport, although its extension to other phases of industrial life is projected. Mobility of Fuel Needed. If coal in the future is to compete successfully with oil fuel it must be made a more mobile product and capable of being used either in the solid, liquid or gaseous form as required. The increasing development in the use of oil-fired boilers and the development of large unit Diesel engines, together with the advantages in transport and bunkering, will make this mobility compulsory, if we are to retain a share of the trade in the Mercantile or Naval Services. The increasing use of gas and oil fuel for industrial installations render this change all the more necessary, and there are signs that the movement to accomplish this is now well on the way, as evidenced by the number and variety of carbonisation and hydrogenation schemes that are being projected, together with the development of the use of pulverised fuel. Given the necessary amalgamations into economic units with all the advantages to be derived from rationalisation and the scientific treatment and marketing of coal, there is still another essential ingredient, viz., Goodwill, required before progress can be assured. Peace in industry is just as essential as peace between nations, and there are signs of improvement in this direction, which it is hoped will meet with success.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||