|
26th January 1929, Page: 216, Column: 1 Points From The Inspectors' ReportsUnderground Haulage AccidentsWhen Ropes and Chains Break. The underground haulage accidents in the Yorkshire Division in 1927 were responsible for 41 deaths, 161 persons were reported as injured, the number disabled for more than three days being 7,769. The Divisional Inspector, Mr. H. M. Hudspeth, says that compared in detail with the figures for 1925, accidents classed under ropes and chains breaking, and runaways, show increases. A relatively high percentage of these accidents prove fatal. Of 88 persons so killed and injured, 14 — or nearly 37 per cent. — were killed, whereas the relative percentage for all haulage accidents was 20. Those classed under the sub-headings mechanical haulage and runaway trams or tubs are the largest numerically, and obviously offer the greatest scope for reduction. Haulage accidents are in the main avoidable, says the Inspector, and improved supervision, together with care on the part of employees, would largely reduce their number. Of the 41 persons killed, 32 were engaged in connection with haulage operations, including seven "rope-runners." Nine other persons were travelling the haulage roads, including two who were illegally riding. Four of the accidents under the last two categories occurred where travelling was not forbidden. The possibility of reducing the number of "rope-runners" is a matter to which the Inspector says attention could be given with advantage. In some instances there was no need whatever for their presence, and in others there was no necessity for them to be in close proximity to the moving tubs ; in at least one case the conditions under which the man was working were very dangerous. Electric Lamps for Drivers. Regarding the accidents described by Mr. Hudspeth, two of them emphasise the importance and need for adopting such measures as will reasonably ensure the safety of persons working in places where, in the event of runaway tubs, men are exposed to grave danger. The Inspector is glad to report that the use of devices to arrest runaways is extending. He says that where persons are allowed to travel endless rope haulage roads and a clear space of at least 2 feet is not provided at one side of the road, the space between the tracks of rails must be kept clear. He further mentions that of the four accidents classed under horse haulage, two occurred to drivers using flame safety-lamps, which fact in one case certainly contributed to the accident. Drivers, he adds, should have electric lamps. Another driver died from blood poisoning, although there was no evidence of external wounding. Challenging Figures. In the North Midland Division haulage caused 17 deaths, the lowest number since 1923 ; more persons were reported seriously injured than in previous years, the number being 161, whilst 4,287 were disabled for more than three days. Mr. J. R. Felton, the Divisional Inspector, notes that whilst in the aggregate there was an improvement, this did not apply to Notts., where the fatalities were higher than in any of the last five years, a position, he says, calling for the serious reflection of managers in that county. Of the total accidents in the Division, it appears that 12 fatal and 106 non-fatal accidents might have been avoided by attention to regulations, and observance of reasonable care and thought. These are challenging figures, the Inspector says, and show what scope there is for effecting a reduction in this class of accident. Taking the 65 accidents coming under mechanical (including self-acting) haulage, 75 per cent. of them were avoidable ; of the 47 accidents under the head horse haulage, 62 per cent. were avoidable ; of the 65 accidents under hand haulage 62 per cent. were avoidable. Mr. Felton notes with pleasure a great reduction in 1927 in the number of boys under 16 years of age killed and seriously injured by haulage accidents. Apart from any legal obligation, he says a moral responsibility is laid upon all officials and experienced workmen to see that everything possible is done by training, supervision and example, as well as by improvement of conditions, to protect boys employed belowground against the inherent dangers of their occupation; and he believes this is being increasingly recognised. Particulars are given of a few typical accidents which might have been avoided, and from which lessons may be learned. Non-fatal Accidents Increase. The number of deaths in 1927 (20) due to haulage accidents in the Lancashire and North Wales Division compares favourably with the year 1925, there being a reduction of six, but Mr. A. D. Nicholson says that for some inexplicable reason the number of non-fatal accidents reported to the Inspector is considerably greater, 110 persons being injured as against 88 in 1925. The increase in non-fatal accidents is almost entirely confined to hand haulage. The persons disabled for more than three days numbered 4,089 (increase 73). Two fatalities in this Division are classed under the headings of breakage of ropes and chains. There were eight fatalities through being crushed by tubs in connection with mechanical haulage. Two of these occurred while riding outbye on sets at the end o£ the shift. In both cases the deceased persons raised themselves too high and were crushed between the top of the tub and the roof. One person was killed in connection with horse haulage. In spite of the large number of accidents where hand haulage was the method of transport — 26 as compared with 16 in 1925 — there were no fatalities. Mr. Nicholson is pleased to report a considerable improvement in the fencing of haulage wheels both large and small, and at many collieries the suggestion to provide an easily detachable and uniform type of fencing has been adopted. He is satisfied that such a system will result in a reduction in the number of accidents in the near future. Needless Loss of Life. The Cardiff and Newport Division showed a great improvement in 1927 compared with 1925, the haulage accidents causing 40 deaths (decrease 11), whilst 178 (decrease 15) were reported injured, the persons disabled for more than three days numbering 3,639 (decrease 1,057). The reduction in the deaths has been progressive in recent years, namely, 76 in 1923, 61 in 1924, 51 in 1925, and 40 in 1927. Under the heading ropes or chains breaking there is an increase of two, and under mechanical haulage an increase of five, over the 1925 figures ; under the heading horse haulage there is, however, a large reduction, from 19 to 4. Hand haulage shows no change, but there were three fewer deaths due to runaways. Under the heading walking inbye the five deaths represent an increase of two. It is noted by the Inspector, Mr. J. Macleod Carey, that in four cases there had been a contravention of rule or instructions on the part of the deceased persons. He adds that it is most unfortunate that the special regulations drawn up for the prevention of this class of accident had been ignored, and the result — the loss of four lives — is deplorable. Quotations from the reports show that none of these lives need have been lost if notices and instructions had been observed. The systematising of walking times, at Mr. Carey's suggestion, was carried out at the latter end of 1924, and it is interesting to note that the deaths under the heading walking inbye or outbye over a four-year period were — 9 in 1923 ; 13 in 1924 ; 3 in 1925 ; 5 in 1927. Avoidable Accidents Predominate. In 1927 the deaths from haulage accidents in the Swansea Division numbered 20 as compared with 28 in 1925 ; 108 persons were reported injured to the Inspector, or 14 more than in 1925, whilst persons disabled more than three days totalled 1,621, a reduction of 166. All the fatal as also the more serious of the non-fatal accidents (88 in all) were investigated, and the Divisional Inspector, Mr. W. J. Charlton, classifies them as follows : Defective plant, 4 ; breach of statutory obligations by officials, 1 ; breach of statutory obligations by workmen, 24 ; preventable by ordinary caution, 43 ; unavoidable 16, or 18 per cent. The Inspector says that stricter discipline would soon bring about a diminution of the accidents due to haulage operations. Illegal riding — a prolific source of accident — should be dealt with very severely, instead of which it is, he is convinced, very largely winked at. In haulage operations, regular practices make for safety, and any temptation to depart therefrom should be resisted. Some Safety Notes. There are roads on heavy gradients in this Division, and Mr. Charlton says careful attention is called for with respect to — The strength of ropes, chains and other material; the provision of safety switches and stop blocks ; the design of back stays ; the fixing of the maximum number of trams for each haulage engine ; the fixing of periods during which travelling may take place while the engine is at rest; and the design and maintenance of carriages to ride persons. The Inspector's observations read :— "Haulage ropes and shackles are very liable to abuse, through overloading ; a notice specifying the maximum number of trams per journey should therefore be posted at every double parting. The periods between the recapping of ropes and the annealing of shackles (which should depend on experience of the conditions of use) should be specified in every case. Safety switches and stop blocks at the tops of slants should be interlocked as in the Widdas safety block; back stays of very robust construction are necessary, even if of rather inconvenient weight; the times fixed during which travelling may take place on foot on haulage roads should be posted in suitable positions, and should be rigidly adhered to ; carriages when not in use should be protected from the weather. "The firemen when making their rounds should keep in mind the errors likely to be committed by haulage hands, and try to inculcate safe methods. Such errors are :—Riding for long or short distances on mechanically drawn trams (except where specifically allowed by the manager) ; riding on guns or horse drawn trams (except where specifically allowed by the manager) ; failing to use safety blocks, safety switches, or bar hooks ; using plate nails in guns instead of the proper pins ; standing in a double parting or on a haulage road when journeys are landing ; walking close to mechanically or horse drawn trams ; attempting to rerail a tram to which a horse is attached ; tumbling trams into the side of a road, and failing to see they give sufficient clearance to passing traffic ; failing to station themselves at doors which have to be opened for traffic in ample time to allow of the operation being done in safety; failing to stop the use of ropes, chains or other tackle when defects are observed. "Managers should eliminate the use of horses, so far as is possible, by the substitution of mechanical haulage. They should also try to avoid the use of doors on main haulage roads, as they are a constant source of danger. "Where, during repair work on an incline, a tram has to be used a 'bull' prop, or 'dumpling' block, should always be placed on the low side of the tram for the protection of workers below." The Inspector gives some notes on accidents which occurred, with occasional advice, and in his reference to illegal riding he says it is deplorable that one of the persons injured was a fireman, for if officials ride there is little hope of stamping out this dangerous practice. Useful Automatic Stop Block. The table showing haulage accidents in the Midland and Southern Division places the deaths at 23 ; persons injured reported to the Inspector at 144, and cases of disablement for more than three days 3,313. Some of the accidents, reports Mr. H. A. Abbott, were due to the provision of inadequate plant, inadequate maintenance, or lack of requisite appliances. He then says the provisions of Section 46 (4) (a) of the Act do not appear in some cases to be properly appreciated. On some inclined haulage roads it is not sufficient simply to provide stop blocks or similar contrivances at the top of an incline to prevent tubs running away ; in addition thereto, runaway switches or other suitable contrivances must be provided on the incline where the use thereof is practicable for the purpose of preventing accident from runaways after a tub has got past the stop blocks at the top. In the construction and equipment of haulage roads more attention might profitably be given to details ; these should not be left to the mentality and ingenuity of a fireman in charge of a district, says Mr. Abbott, but should be the subject of a specification and drawing provided by the manager to meet the conditions prevailing, indicating exactly how the work should be done, what appliances should be provided, and where they should be fixed. The Inspector illustrates and describes a useful and reliable form of automatic stop block designed and used at the Talk-o'th-Hill Colliery and other mines, which is designed to arrest descending tubs if accidentally detached from the rope or exceeding normal speed. The sprag is of the usual falling type hinged at the roof, and is normally held clear of passing tubs by the chain the other end of which is held by the slip ring. A pendulum which swings freely and the upper end of which is attached to the slip link by chain, is in two parts hinged together, the lower part swinging upwards to allow the passage of ascending tubs. By proper adjustment of the chain tubs descending at normal speed move the pendulum without disengaging the slip link, but when descending at excessive speed the pendulum is caused to swing with sufficient violence to snatch the chain and open the clip link, letting the sprag fall to arrest the tub. The stop block may be fixed about ten yards from the top or bottom of an incline or in any intermediate position, to arrest runaway tubs. Details of some haulage accidents which contain useful lessons and features of interest are given by Mr. Abbott. There is so much that is useful and informing in the Reports of the Mines Inspectors that all mining officials and students would be amply repaid if they invested the shilling which is charged per copy. Concluded from page 204.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||