|
12th January 1929, Page: 204, Column: 1 Mine Signalling BellsA report has been issued by the Mines Department "On an Investigation at the Mines Department Testing Station, Sheffield, of the Safety of Certified Mine Signalling Bells when Connected in Parallel." The authors of the Report, Captain C. B. Platt, M.B.E., and R. A. Bailey, Ph.D., recall that as a result of the Formal Investigation into the cause of the explosion at Senghenydd Colliery in 1913, experimental investigations were carried out by Professor R. V. Wheeler and Professors R. V. Wheeler and W. M. Thornton jointly, into the safety of bare wire signalling systems in fiery mines. The reports of these investigations showed that, with the majority of types of bells then in use, the break-flash at bare signalling wires was capable of igniting firedamp, but that it could be made safe by incorporating in the bell one or other of a variety of "safety devices." They laid stress also on the desirability of limiting the amount of current in the circuit. Of the "safety devices" which they suggested the three now commonly employed are : (1) a non-inductive shunt across the magnet coils ; (2) a copper sleeve over the core of the magnet; and (3) a closed-circuit winding over the core of the magnet. Since 1917 numbers of mining type bells fitted with one or other of these "safety devices" have been officially tested and have been certified as safe for use with any source of current up to the maximum pressure permitted by the Regulations for signalling circuits, namely, 25 volts. The official test established the fact that with all these types of bells the break-flash at the bare signalling wires has been rendered incapable of igniting firedamp by incorporating a "safety device" in the bell, but the test was made with one bell only in circuit and the safety of the break-flash is only assured under those conditions. The certificate of safety was issued subject to that implied limitation, but as it recently became evident that there was some misapprehension on this point, a statement was issued by the Mines Department in July, 1927, in the course of which it was emphasised that the certificate of safety does not hold good if two or more bells are connected in parallel on a bare wire circuit; for in such conditions the break-flash at the bare signal wires might become dangerous. In any event the margin of safety would be greatly reduced. The object of the present report is to give an account of further experimental work by which it has been shown that, under certain limiting conditions, certified bells may safely be connected in parallel on a bare wire circuit. When two or more bells are connected in parallel, the total energy concentrated in the break-flash at the signal wires is the sum of the energy contributed by each bell. This break-flash, which is known to be safe with one certified bell, may, therefore, become dangerous when two or more certified bells are connected in parallel. The maintained spark at the trembler of the bell is not intensified under these conditions and need not, therefore, be considered further. The problem for solution is to diminish the energy of the break-flash at the signal wires to less than that which will cause ignition of the most readily ignitable firedamp-air mixture. There are three methods by which it would seem possible to do this : (i) By reducing the battery voltage, (ii) By increasing the safety factor of the individual bell, (iii) By limiting the current. When a "safety device" is incorporated in a bell, the safety of the bell is ensured at the expense of its signalling efficiency. With one bell only in circuit the reduction in efficiency need not be a serious matter. But it becomes a very serious matter if the effect of the "safety device" is increased to the degree necessary to ensure the safety of a circuit containing several bells in parallel. The simplest, and least costly, method of increasing the safety factor of a certified bell is to incorporate a non-inductive resistance in parallel with the magnet coils. The value was determined, for different makes of bells, of the resistance of the shunt required to ensure the safety of four and six bells, respectively, in parallel. Normally, the resistance of the non-inductive shunt that suffices to ensure safety with a single bell in circuit is from five to ten times that of the magnet coils. However, to ensure the safety of a circuit containing several bells in parallel it is necessary to reduce the resistance of the shunt to a figure comparable with the resistance of the magnet coils themselves. This means, of course, that about half the energy supplied to operate the bell would be wasted in the shunt — a serious matter when, as is usually the case, the energy is supplied by batteries of limited capacities. Other forms of safety device also reduce the signal strength as the safety factor is increased, and there is the added disadvantage that modification would involve reconstruction of the bell. Another practical objection to increasing the safety factor of the individual bell is that it would involve the withdrawal of all the bells from use for the necessary alterations. Experiments have shown that a type of battery of sufficiently high internal resistance to ensure the safety of nearly all types of certified bells when used in parallel is the porous-pot Leclanche battery, consisting of cells of three-pint size connected in simple series, and provided that not more than one battery of this type is connected in the system. It should be clearly understood that modifications of the ordinary Leclanche cell, having a relatively low internal resistance, such as the "Carsac" and the "Carporous," as well as so-called dry batteries, are not safe for use with certified bells in parallel when operated from bare wire signal circuits. Relays. — Although the discussion has been confined to certified bells, the characteristics of certified relays were also examined during the course of the investigation. In most instances it was found that certified relays have a safety factor considerably greater than that of certified bells, particularly in those instances where the relay has a high resistance. Nevertheless, it is advisable that the same precautions as those recommended for bells should be adopted when relays are connected in parallel on a bare wire circuit.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||