|
12th January 1929, Page: 202, Column: 1 Points From The Inspectors' ReportsUnderground Haulage AccidentsUnderground haulage accidents in 1927 were responsible for 22 per cent. of the total number of fatalities from all causes underground, 232 persons being killed, whilst 40,864 persons were disabled for more than three days. Some of the comments of the Chief Inspector of Mines on this class of accident were reproduced on page 17, in No. 2, Vol. 39, and readers are referred to what is there said. The Widdas Block. In Mr. Masterton's report for Scotland the deaths due to this cause are shown to number 24, with 102 cases reported to the Inspector, and 3,993 disabled for more than three days. He says that many of the accidents from runaway tubs, both fatal and non-fatal, could be avoided if appliances which automatically block the way and have to be held open positively at or near the tops of self-acting inclines or dook roads were provided instead of ordinary stop blocks, which fail because somebody has forgotten to do what he ought. Reference is made to the Widdas block, which is a patent-free appliance so that there is no hindrance in the way of any colliery company making it. The appliance consists of a hinged stop block connected by toggle mechanism to an operating lever at the side of the road. At a distance down the incline of (say) twice the length of the set of tubs to be lowered there are runaway points, and these are connected to the same operating lever by rods. The arrangement is such that when the stop block allows the set to pass, the runaway points will put the tubs off the rails. When a set is ready the stop block is opened and immediately it gets over the incline top, and all the couplings and the tubs are taut, it is then closed, the same act placing the runaway points in position to allow the set to pass safely. The "Speed Monkey." A simple device called the "Speed Monkey" is in use on a steep part of a hand drawing road at Craigrigg Colliery in Linlithgowshire; it is very suitable for application a short distance down from the top of a self-acting incline or dook road. Mr. Masterton says it consists of an ordinary "monkey" or balance block of iron hinged between the rails in the usual manner so that the up-coming tub axles depress it, then allow it to swing back to the normal position, but that down-going tubs will always be caught. A light chain or rope is attached to the balance block and lies between the rails loosely with its upper end fixed to a sleeper at the incline top as a matter of convenience. An ordinary stop block is used to hold the tubs in the siding, and after the attendant has opened this and allowed the set to move over the top of the incline with all the couplings tight, he pulls the rope or chain which depresses the monkey till the set is beyond it. The Inspector says the appliance deserves to be widely used on account of the security it gives from the danger of tubs getting away owing to uncoupling or omission to couple. Provision of Devices. Referring to the provision of runaway points or other contrivances on haulage roads, there is a point in Section 46 (4) (a) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, which appears to Mr. Masterton to need to be emphasised. The sub-section seems to be qualified by the words "where the use thereof is practicable." He has yet to see the place where a contrivance of some kind is not practicable, and there can be no excuse for failure to provide what is required. He adds that the purpose of "runaway switches or other suitable contrivances" is to prevent accident in the event of tubs running away, and there ought to be such devices (a) near the top of every inclined haulage road to prevent uncoupled tubs getting away, and (b) at as many places on the road as is practicable, and certainly above the entrance to every siding off the road. Boys' Accident Rates. The deaths from underground haulage accidents in the Northern Division in 1927 numbered 47, the persons reported to the inspector as injured 255, and those disabled for more than three days 12,153. Next to falls of ground this class of accident continues to prove the most productive. As Mr. Davies, the Divisional Inspector, is convinced that the accident rate from this source ought to be reduced he discusses more fully than usual the causes and means of prevention of haulage accidents. In a three-year survey of 632 accidents he attributes 7 to defective plant; 80 to breach of rules ; 242 to accidents avoidable by the exercise of ordinary caution ; 303 to accidents that are unavoidable, bearing established practice in mind. Thus only 48 per cent. of the haulage accidents were unavoidable, but Mr. Davies holds the view that many of these could be prevented by improvements in established methods or the adoption of more modern methods of transport. The personal factor and the importance of the maintenance of proper discipline are commented upon by Mr. Davies, and he then directs attention to the fact that nearly all boys who start work underground are employed on some form of haulage work, and gives figures to emphasise the vital need for a real organised attempt at systematic training. According to the statistics 37 per cent. of the fatal accidents and 35 per cent. of all the accidents occurred to boys 16 years of age and under. As it would appear that only about 10 per cent. of the persons engaged in underground haulages are boys of these ages, the disparity between the percentages of employed and killed or injured is very marked indeed, and should provide food for much thought. It suggests to the Inspector either inadequate training, supervision and discipline, or unsatisfactory methods of haulage, or that the boys are put to work on improperly selected jobs or under unsuitable conditions. The Training of Boys. Mr. Davies supplies particulars of a scheme of training boys which he thinks is worth the serious consideration of all colliery companies and officials as follows:— "With regard to the systematic training of boys it may be of some interest to give particulars concerning the practice and progress made in this connection in the Westphalian Coalfield of Germany. Persons under 16 are prohibited by statute from working underground in mines, whilst between the ages of 14 and 16 those boys at work on the surface must attend school for 4 hours technical training per week. In addition to this training several of the larger colliery companies have recently instituted a system of mine apprenticeship training for boys between 14 and 16 who are intended for work underground. Fully a year ago at one large colliery visited recently by one of my Senior Inspectors, Mr. A. M. Bryan, the colliery company set aside a special training shop for this purpose, in which all such boys receive a certain amount of theoretical and practical training, under a skilled and specially selected supervisor with experienced assistants, in electrical, mechanical, carpentry, and smithy work, and in other matters relating to underground methods. "In the training shop, which was well fitted out for the purpose, all kinds of colliery equipment are repaired and spare parts made by experienced workmen with the assistance of the boys, who, in addition to the knowledge and training thus gained, also learn the proper use and handling of the various tools and become familiar with the stopping, starting, and maintenance of machinery. "As an illustration of the kind of instruction given with a very direct practical bearing on underground work, on the day of Mr. Bryan's visit, some of the boys had been engaged in laying and fitting together a rail track, crossings and points which had been made for a junction underground. Further, a completely fitted experimental staple pit lift was erected in the shop which enabled the boys to become familiar in many ways with the operation of such lifts ; an experience which was eminently suitable because the inclination and proximity of the various coal seams necessitated the use of a considerable number of staple pits in the underground workings. "Although provided at some mines, no instructional gallery was available at this particular colliery wherein to practice the setting of supports, but this was under consideration as was also the setting aside of a special district in the mine, where, after the completion of their surface training, the boys would spend the first few weeks of the employment underground under special supervision to enable them to become familiar with actual underground conditions and develop a certain amount of pit sense before being drafted into the larger working districts where close supervision is difficult. "Although the whole scheme is only in its infancy everyone in authority seemed very enthusiastic and felt confident that it would prove an economic success by producing a more skilled and superior class of workman and a success from the safety standpoint by preventing many of the accidents attributed to lack of experience, training and pit sense." Haulage Accidents Classified. Mr. Davies has ascertained the causes of the haulage accidents covered by this three-year review, the classification being :— 16% were due to persons being crushed between tubs and obstructions. 16% were due to derailment of tubs. 10% were due to tubs colliding in landings, sidings or flats. 9% were due to persons coming into contact with or being caught by moving ropes or chains. 9% were due to uncertainty of ponies. 8% were due to persons stumbling and being caught by moving tubs. 7% were due to persons being caught by runaways. 4% were due to persons not taking refuge and being caught by moving tubs when travelling. 3% were due to persons illegally riding. 2% were due to failure of ropes, chains or sockets. 16% were due to other unclassified causes. Suggestions to Eliminate Accidents. Suggestions for the elimination of haulage accidents are made by Mr. Davies, who points out that in about 25 per cent. of the foregoing accidents the injured person was riding on pony limbers at the time. He feels sure that if this practice was prohibited, as it is in a few mines, the number of persons injured would be considerably reduced. His suggestions are as under : "Crushed between Tubs and Obstructions. — The nature of the obstruction varies, but is mainly due either to the small or irregular cross-sectional area of the roadways. The obvious remedy is the provision of ample clearance between the tubs and the roof and sides of the roadway. This could frequently be attained by uniformity in the setting of supports and without any additional cost whatever, but in the main I am convinced that the problem of the size of roadway and uniformity of support depends very largely upon the adoption of a method of working the coal which reduces the number of loading points to a minimum, especially in longwall workings, and the use of some standardised method of support for the roof and sides, such as arched steel girders, for the haulage roads. In any event, special care should be taken, especially on horse haulage roads where persons are permitted to ride on the limbers and in all cases where tubs are spragged, coupled or uncoupled ; or where the driver or putter must pass the set, to maintain a safe clearance and to avoid as far as possible those sudden diminutions below the safe clearance. "Derailment. — The chief causes of derailment are bad permanent ways, mainly due to the common use of short length light section rails, irregularly driven and badly maintained roadways. Heavier section rails with fish-plated joints should be adopted to a much greater extent than they are at present. They have proved their worth in those mines which have been forced to use them in order to facilitate the flitting of heavy coal-cutting machines. More attention should be paid to the cleanliness of roadways, the making of larger radius and properly laid curves, the grading of roadways and elimination of spragging, and the more frequent examination to reveal defective tubs. "Tubs colliding in landings, sidings and flats. — The number of accidents from this cause is surprisingly large. The control of tubs in such places appears to receive very little consideration. Better grading, the provision of more automatic or interlocking stop-blocks and of efficient retarders, should receive more attention. An appreciable number of the accidents under this heading occurred to young boys in shaft sidings when coupling or uncoupling tubs. With proper supervision and instruction most of these accidents would be prevented. "Contact with moving ropes. — The nature of the accidents varied greatly in character, but the large number shows how important it is to prevent, as far as possible, persons from coming near moving ropes. A great improvement would result if separate travelling roads were provided, or where such is not practicable, if all travelling on haulage roads were prohibited while ropes are in motion, whilst the danger from contact with moving ropes would be considerably lessened by the maintenance of straight roadways, elimination of slack rope as far as possible, and the reduction of junctions to a minimum by more intensive mining. "Uncertainty of ponies. — Accidents due to ponies stumbling, bolting or kicking and to ponies starting, stopping or crossing out when not expected, are comprised under this heading. Many accidents are due to ponies being spoiled by badly trained drivers and to the uneven condition of the floor of the roadways. Ponies should be replaced wherever practicable by carefully planned mechanical haulage or improved method of working. One colliery company has progressively reduced their studs since 1901, when 256 horses were employed, and now the whole annual output of half a million tons is transported without the use of horses. This achievement is remarkable as the three mines concerned opened in 1840, 1853, and 1866 respectively, working seams 2 feet 2 inches to 3 feet in thickness, with gradients from 1½ inches to 8 inches per yard and with haulage up to a maximum distance of four miles inbye. "Stumbling. — The floors of all roads in which persons have to work should be maintained as free as possible from obstructions such as loose stones, uneven floors and the almost buried flanges of a pipe range. It should not be necessary for workmen to be continually on the lookout for obstacles under foot. "Runaways. — Protection against accidents under this heading does not receive the attention it merits, with the result that these accidents are much too common. Where tubs run on gradients the danger of runaways is ever present and steps ought to be taken to guard against this danger before accidents occur. It should be remembered that the danger is present on short and light gradients as well as on long and steep gradients." Mr. Davies proceeds to say regarding runaways that protection is easily afforded in the case of ascending tubs by the use of back-stays, or in the case of ways used for ascending tubs only by the use of the common spring-actuated runaway switches or stop blocks, which allow the free passage of ascending tubs but derail or stop descending tubs. The problem has received very little attention in the case of tubs running amain in the normal direction of travel. If protection is needed in one case surely it is logical to provide it in the other. The Inspector adds that there are several devices in use for this purpose in the Division, and he describes the Runaway Tub Switch, designed by Mr. E. Graham, which is in use at Bedlington Colliery ; the Automatic Runaway Tub Stop which is in use at Isabella Pit, Cowpen Collieries ; the "Samid" Safety Catch, which is in use at Horden Colliery ; the Safety Chock and Runaway Switch, and the Runaway Switch, invented by Mr. P. Widdas and in use at Gordon House Colliery, together with the arrangement of the brake wheel at this colliery on the endless rope self-acting inclines. Persons caught by moving tubs when travelling. — Many of these accidents were due either to persons failing to make use of available refuge holes or travelling along haulage roads while sets were in motion, when such travelling was prohibited. The provision of separate and comfortable travelling roads clear of all haulage operations would reduce the number of accidents from this cause. Illegal riding. — The remedy for this class of accident lies mainly with the workmen, but illegal riding connotes poor discipline. Here again separate travelling roads would prevent such accidents, and it should be carefully borne in mind that bad travelling roads are conducive to illegal riding. Failure of ropes, chains or sockets. — Considering the large output hauled, the number of accidents from this source is small, but there is no doubt that several might have been avoided with careful examination and maintenance of haulage gear. The safeguards against such accidents lies in the right choice of material and careful installation, inspection and maintenance. In inclined roadways the consequences of such accidents need not be so serious if proper safeguards against runaways are installed and if travelling on haulage planes is reduced to a minimum. Miscellaneous. — Of these accidents at least five were due to boys being caught by the winch handle at the offtakes on main and tail rope haulage. Accidents of this type would be almost entirely eliminated by the use of a more fool-proof type of winch which would prevent the operator from tightening up the rope without having the pawl in position. An appreciable number of lives were lost solely because some persons who sustained very minor injuries in the first instance failed to have adequate antiseptic treatment at once. It is a regrettable fact that the failure in nearly every case lay with the injured person himself. The importance of such early treatment for small injuries cannot be over-emphasised. Prompt first aid treatment prevents many insidious minor injuries from becoming serious or even fatal through septic poisoning. (To be continued.)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||