12th January 1929, Page: 200, Column: 2
Roof Control On Longwall Faces
By J. F. C. Friend, B.Sc.
Extracts from paper read on 15th December before the members of the North of
England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.
In laying out an area in a seam for long-face working, particularly when
employing machinery and concentrated modern methods, the problem of
roof-control is as important as are those of haulage and ventilation. The
control of the enormous weight of rock thrown into a state of unstable
equilibrium by the rapid removal of the coal along a wide face, can no longer
be treated with indifference when the great expense in loss of output and wages
due to a serious or even minor fall of roof on a vital point is considered.
Coal strata contain rocks of extremely varied character. Massive
semi-crystalline rocks, laminated shaly sandstones, fireclays or water-rotted
shales may be associated with a coal seam. Their behaviour, when their
equilibrium is upset by mining, is extremely uncertain. Soft strata may flow,
crystalline rocks crumble, tough shales bend without fracture or massive rocks
fracture with sudden violence. Almost all stone is elastic when in bulk and
stores energy. Stratification planes or partings are planes of weakness and
allow of differential movement between one stratum and another. In old
coalfields, particularly those on the North-East Coast, the strata are
frequently disturbed and abnormal, owing to previous working by the
bord-and-pillar system. Thus, to attempt to treat the roof of a mine as
homogeneous is hopeless waste of time. The overlying rocks must be considered
as individuals, each with its own characteristics of strength and flexibility,
and each behaving differently under the same stress. Every effort should be
made to secure full information on the strata above and below a seam to be
worked. Sections from sinkings, borings, drifts and even exposed fault faces
and large falls, should be noted, indexed and studied when any problem of roof
support or subsidence requires elucidation.
The producer cannot, as yet, chemically alter his coal by the method of mining,
but ash-content and size can be improved. If the roof is kept good, ash from
outside the seam can be kept down and by applying the least possible crushing
pressure necessary for working, and by gentle handling of the coal when mined,
the quantity of fine coal can be reduced.
Extraction of the Seam. — Methods of working by longwall with
transport along the face to a Mothergate have requirements in common, no matter
what the machinery or system. The working space between the face and the goaf
must allow sufficient height for loading and operation of the transporting
appliance during the whole of the cycle of work (i.e., the working forward of
the coal, moving up of transport appliance, periodic withdrawal of supports and
building of packs). It must be kept safe for the worker and preserved against
collapse, and the correct pressure must be applied to the coal. It should be as
small as possible, its supports and dimensions exactly systematised, and its
forward movement as rapid and regular as possible. The amount of timber
required can then be minimised and supports can often be used over again. The
weight of roof necessary to handle is less, and therefore more easily
controlled. In general, it may be said that pressure is required on a longwall
face to render it easily worked by hand labour, and that little or none is
required when coal-cutters and explosives are employed.
Subsidence. — When a seam of coal is removed, the space left is
filled by the rocks from above and below, under the influence of gravity,
lateral thrust and pressure flow. The operation may be divided into : (I.)
Subsidence of the immediate roof and heaving up of the floor. (II.) Subsidence
of the ground above up to the limit of fractures or forming of cavities in the
rock. This may be termed secondary subsidence. (III.) Subsidence of the main
body of earth extending to the surface, or tertiary subsidence.
When the timber is withdrawn from under the roof of a mine, there is generally
a lapse of time before a fall occurs. The duration of this depends on the vast
array of varying local conditions. Some of the factors controlling this lapse
of time are (1) Flow of soft strata. (2) Bending of rocks. (3)
Fracture. (4) Friction with adjoining rocks. (5) Incipient
planes of fracture. (6) The supports slowly collapse also, either
compressing until they fail or grinding into the roof or floor if soft. (7)
Other possible factors are : Release of vacuum by air slowly percolating
through cracks ; release of gas or hydraulic pressure.
It is obvious that the faster a face moves, the more are the disruptive actions
left behind to happen without danger. In other words the roof is kept green.
Very few writers disagree with this. The only danger of going too fast appears
to be that the roof will collapse in such large pieces that there will be
danger of losing the face, and of crumps or weights on the haulage roads. It is
safe to say that the speed of a face depends on the regularity and partly upon
the frequency, with which breaks can be produced, except in the case of the
bending roof when the greater the speed is, the better.
Cantilever Conception. — H. W. G. Halbaum says that the
roof acts as a cantilever, whose power we may guide in such a way as to snap on
a fulcrum and so render it useless. As a longwall face advances, a projecting
shelf or cantilever of roof rocks is formed. Its behaviour depends on local
circumstances, and upon the strength characteristic of the rock, in shear,
tension and compression.
Collapse of the Cantilever. — (A) In the case of the strong roof,
the cantilever may grow to a certain length before collapsing under shear. (B)
In the case of the weak roof, its weight may be so great in relation to its
strength that it may shear off at or slightly before the coal-face. (C) In the
case of the bending roof it may bend without fracture, its weight resting more
or less upon the roof supports until raised by the floor or packs.
Collapse of the Strong Roof. — The strong roof will collapse in
two ways: (1) Where the shelf grows to considerable length without bending, and
then fracturing with more or less violence. (2) It may bend down very
gradually. Every effort should be made to promote fracture of the roof
regularly behind the last row of supports. In a properly designed system the
mode and periodicity of fracture is known almost to a certainty. The weight on
the working space is reduced to a minimum, supports of the necessary strength
can be used, the roof can be kept green, and complete systematisation and
co-ordination of effort can be attained. With either the hanging roof or the
gradually bending roof, the whole problem depends on the stiffness of the last
row of supports. In certain cases it may be necessary to use packs to preserve
this stiffness, but packs, excepting of course gateway packs, should be avoided
whenever possible.
Collapse of the Weak Roof. — Frequently a roof stratum is met
with, so weak in relation to its own weight and the shear stress thereby
exerted at the coal-face, that it fractures at or before the coal-face. In this
case, and where the roof does break immediately, but a very little distance
from the coal-face, every effort must be made to prolong the life of the
cantilever. If this is impossible, the weight on the working-space must be
reduced by reducing the continuity of the cantilever, and the weight operating
as shear force by breaking it off behind the working-space.
The Bending Roof. — Frequently a roof is met with, such as a tough
bind, which will bend gradually down without fracture. The bending commences at
the coal-head unless prevented by supports, beyond the supports the acuteness
of bending depends on the character of the roof. In reality the bending is more
or less of a fracturing process, but the cohesion of the stratum is not
entirely destroyed. With a bending roof, the weight is distributed more or less
evenly over all supports, and face-supports should be strong enough to avoid
any possibility of collapse, as an irregular bend due to some props subsidising
and others standing might cause a torsional strain resulting in a dangerous
break. There will not be any need for an extra strong last row when the roof
bends acutely, but where the bend is less acute, conditions become more like
that of the strong roof, which does not break until the cantilever has grown to
some length. In this case a strong last row to take the weight is an advantage
in preserving the working-space, where it can be readily withdrawn.
Heaving Floor. — In longwall working, the floor, if soft, will
almost always heave, reducing the size of the working-space, and nothing will
prevent it. Its effects are not so marked in the case of the fast moving face.
Penetration of props into a soft floor is inevitable ; the upward pressure of
the floor on the props tends to keep the roof up, but rigidity of timber is
difficult to attain when the floor is soft. Both the rise of the floor and the
penetration of timbers take time, so that generally a considerable weight can
be carried before depression of the roof takes place. This time is very
considerably increased by the use of stout sole-
pieces of wood or iron. Hard wood is preferable to soft, and iron better still,
though its recovery after use is not so easy except under the best
organisation. The heaving floor is an advantage in many ways where packs are
employed, as these are tightened up to the roof quickly and frequently prevent
it from fracturing where this is not aimed at.
Strength of Supports. — The support must be adequate for its
prescribed job, must have a little strength in hand for emergencies, and must
be capable of being used again, if possible, in the interests of economy. The
strength of a support is largely governed by the position of the break. If the
break occurs at the coal-head, then the whole weight of the broken stratum will
have to be carried by the face timber, while the breaking off or last row of
timber need not be very much stronger, as long as any cantilever weight can be
broken off and released there. If the break occurs behind the working-space
then lighter and less bulky supports may be used in the face. The supports for
any one purpose should be as nearly as possible of the same strength.
Irregularity of settlement and danger to the rest of the face may occur through
part of a batch of props being weaker than the others. A completely rigid
support is impracticable, as nothing whatever its strength will stop the slow
lowering of the roof. If a support was completely incompressible it would have
to be destroyed in order to effect its withdrawal, as it would be so tightly
gripped between roof and floor. Also it might break up the roof by penetrating
it, just as would a pick point. The whole weight of the overlying strata never
rests upon the supports, however, and the bending of the roof stratum may be
delayed and resisted, so long as the prop can be withdrawn and the roof not
harmed. The prop should then have a measure of compressibility, but it must be
unbreakable. A broken prop throws the weight on to its neighbours which
themselves may be near breaking-point. Generally wooden props have not a
sufficient margin of strength, while the rigid steel prop does not yield at
all. The Newbattle prop possesses all the qualities of the ideal support, viz.,
light, yielding though rigid, and cheap. The principle employed is that of the
tapered prop. The tapered prop itself is really too weak for most purposes as
its strength is not uniform, and it can break.
The Limit to the Application of Longwall. — Apart from
extraordinary thickness of seams, difficulty of obtaining packing material
where absolutely necessary, etc., the size of the working space is the limiting
factor. If sufficient height for the transport can be maintained during the
whole of the cycle of mining operations, then longwall will function. The
height depends upon the relative speeds of compression of the working-space and
advance of the face. In practice the question could be expressed as "what
will be the height over the conveyor line on Monday morning." If height is
reduced to an impracticable figure at the end of 24 hours, then another method
of working must be employed.
Pressure on the Coal. — The more rigid the supports, particularly
the last row, and the smaller the working-space and the more rapid the advance,
the more easily will pressure be controlled. With a very weak roof, the
pressure on the coal cannot be altered, but the more the supports can be made
to continue the upward pressure of the erstwhile coal-seam, the greater will be
the ease of control. If pressure is required, then subsidence of supports can
be arranged. The settling of soft wood caps on steel props, building cogs on
muck, and tapering props are some of the devices for attaining this end. These
devices may also be used when completely rigid supports would be unsuitable.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Friend, John Frederick Coop | | | |
| Halbaum, H. W. G. | | | |