Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th December 1928, Page: 178, Column: 1

Points From The Inspectors' Reports

Falls of Ground

Concluded from page 170.

Yorkshire Division.

Mr. H. M. Hudspeth reports 92 deaths from falls, 277 persons reported injured to the inspectors, and 10,956 persons disabled for more than three days. When investigating accidents careful attention has been paid to the question as to how far observation of the recommendations made in the Report by the Support of Workings in Mines Committee (so far as it affects Yorkshire) would have reduced the number of accidents, and Mr. Hudspeth says it is interesting to note from the Inspectors' reports that 57 per cent. of the accidents would probably not have happened had they been carried out. A point to which he directs attention is the need for closer regard to the requirements of the Coal Mines Act, Sections 49 to 52, in reference to the support of roof and sides. On at least thirty occasions inspectors found that Section 51 was not observed, a sufficient supply of timber or other materials suitable for supports not being available. In most cases failure of the distribution system was the alleged cause of the trouble. Under such circumstances Mr. Hudspeth says work must stop until the deficiency is remedied. Non-compliance with timbering rules were observed on 883 occasions, and although the number of accidents directly resulting from such contraventions is comparatively few, the Inspector deems the figure too high. He says that workmen should be provided with the necessary means for safely withdrawing timber. The "ringer and chain" is old-fashioned, and if a "Sylvester" is unequal to the occasion, some twisting appliance such as the "Wrester," "Rensha," or "Thackeray" should be available. Mr. Hudspeth describes some of the accidents which present features of interest and from which lessons can be learned, and in connection with one of them he mentions that whilst the Coal Mines Act, Section 73, makes provision that a coal-getter shall not work alone until he has had two years' experience, there is no such necessary provision in regard to stone workers. Both the men involved in the accident had had very short experience, and, the Inspector adds, should not have been working alone. An examination of the circumstances under which some of the accidents happened due to collapse of roof support's suggests to him the need for more attention being paid to the strutting or lacing of roof and side supports, with a view to preventing them from swinging out. At the site of one of the accidents an unsupported cavity had been left above the roof girders.

North Midland Division.

Falls of ground accounted for 49 deaths and 278 cases of serious injury, the number of persons injured for more than three days being 7,351. Mr. J. R. Felton reports that of the accidents investigated 31 per cent. resulted from breach of regulations or lack of ordinary care. At gate-end ripping lips, and at or near gate-ends, there were 12 fatal and 81 non-fatal accidents, equal to 29 per cent. of all the accidents from falls of ground, and indicating in the view of the Inspector the area requiring most attention. He believes the East Midland Support of Workings Report has served to focus attention upon accidents from falls and to stimulate the managements to further efforts to reduce the accident-rate from this cause. Three directions in which these efforts have been manifest are cited, viz. :—

(1) The more extensive use of Sylvesters (instead of the ringer and chain) for withdrawing timber. At all the pits of one large colliery company "Sylvesters" have been introduced throughout, while at several other mines in this coalfield the number of "Sylvesters" in each district has been considerably increased, and the ringer and chain is being gradually superseded. "Wresters" are also being tried at a few collieries, and Mr. Felton hopes to see their use extended.

(2) At quite a number of collieries steel props of varous makes) are being tried. The results so far secured with some of these props have been entirely satisfactory. The use of steel arches is also being extended considerably, and at one colliery it is being used within 150 yards of the coal face.

(3) The more extensive use of bars at the face, and particularly at way-ends, where the greatest danger from falls exists.

Mr. Felton repeats the view that a reduction of accidents from falls could be effected generally by attention to discipline, individual care, and the more thorough use of roof supports. If these points were properly appreciated and applied he is confident the results would amply justify the effort, and he describes some accidents emphasising these points.

Lancashire and North Wales Division.

According to the Report prepared by Mr. A. D. Nicholson, in 1927 there were 63 deaths in this Division, 108 persons were reported injured, and 6,135 were disabled for more than three days in accidents due to falls of ground. Falls were responsible for 56.8 per cent. of the deaths, and practically 70 per cent. occurred at the working face. The Inspector estimates that 10 per cent. of the fatal accidents and 15 per cent. of the non-fatal reportable accidents could probably have been avoided by strict adherence to the timbering rules or the exercise of greater care. Cases of neglect to set timber and sprags were very frequently reported. A more extensive use of bars at the face and edges or rippings, instead of props and lids (the latter sometimes hardly worthy of the name) would, Mr. Nicholson is satisfied, tend to reduce accidents. When it is pointed out to the management after an accident that the use of bars instead of props might have prevented the accident, bars are usually adopted, but their general use, the Inspector feels sure, would result in an appreciable reduction in the number of accidents, and from that point of view alone would in the end be more economical; unfortunately, he says, it is sometimes difficult to get managers to take this view until an accident has occurred. Several fatal accidents are described as being typical of many others ; some might have been avoided by greater care and strict compliance with the timbering rules. One of the most fruitful causes of accidents from falls of ground is the neglect to set temporary supports.

Cardiff and Newport Division.

The record from "falls" in this Division last year was 80 deaths, 330 reported injured, and 11,351 disabled for more than three days. Mr. J. Macleod Carey says regarding falls that by far the heaviest mortality is caused by accidents at the face, which are caused by the presence of a treacherous roof in its neighbourhood. This kind of accident he believes can only be tackled by the exercise of greater care and vigilance on the part of the persons whose business it is to work in such places. A similar view is expressed regarding accidents to repairers, who themselves are actually removing an active danger throughout all their operations. Referring to the operation of ripping, usually done by the collier himself in whose stall the necessary height for his tram of coal has to be made, Mr. Carey is afraid that too often a risk is taken when, possibly, by the erection of a temporary support, it might be avoided. With regard to the general incidence of accidents due to falls it appears that there were (a) eight cases of defective practice ; (b) no cases of neglect by officials ; (c) fourteen cases where the workman had neglected some necessary precaution ; (d) fifty-eight cases where the fatalities were caused by circumstances beyond human control.

Mr. Carey returns to the subject of timbering in his "general remarks," and he compliments the workmen in his Division on being "good timbermen and careful, as a general rule, to comply with the requirements of the timbering rules." He enumerates shortly the practical advantages of a good pack behind the working face. It ensures an even and gradual settlement of the roof bedding from the edge of the coal back, with advantageous consequences to the working of the coal itself by diminishing the crushing effect on the seam, thus giving more round coal, and probably making it easier for the collier to hew ; it renders the roof itself less liable to break across the bedding planes, and consequently to fall at hitherto unseen slips ; it enables more timber to be withdrawn after the packs have been built up near to the freshly advanced face ; it prevents the possibility of cavities being formed in the back area to become receptacles for accumulations of gas ; it causes less repair work to be necessary on the roadways behind the working faces ; and finally, it ensures that the bulk of the ventilation is kept up to the coal face itself, resulting in the freshly given off gases being carried harmlessly away and physiologically rendering the human machine at work there more efficient.

Mr. Carey says that timbers are too often left in and pack walls built around them, the result having a twofold and adverse effect on the stability of the working place. Timber left standing under a tender roof tends to break that roof instead of supporting it, and if pack walls are built around the prop to support the roof and the prop, and it frequently does, breaks, the pack is rendered useless by being displaced. It should always be arranged that the packs are built behind and close up to the last row of props so that the props can be easily and safely withdrawn, and thus allow for a gradual subsidence of the roof on to the gobs behind. A steel prop of satisfactory design suitable to the onerous conditions prevalent in the steam coal seams should be simple in construction, easily handled by the men, and capable of taking a gradual downward pressure without destruction to its main members. When such a prop is discovered, the most important result Mr. Carey should look for would be a reduction in the accidents from falls of roof.

Swansea Division.

Deaths in this Division attributed to falls numbered 53, persons reported injured numbered 141, and those disabled more than three days numbered 3,919. Mr. W. J. Charlton, following investigations, apportions responsibility in the case of 136 of the accidents to neglect of officials, 2.2 per cent. ; neglect of workmen, 15.4 per cent. ; carelessness of workmen, 41.9 per cent. ; unavoidable, 40.5 per cent. There are allowances made concerning local circumstances, and the Inspector has some good advice to give. It is common practice to drive a road in solid coal and open out a longwall face on one side only, with the natural result that the roof of the opening out road becomes broken and expensive to maintain. If later, it is decided to open out a face on the other, or solid side, a great amount of dangerous work has to be done which, with more thought in opening out in the first instance, could have been avoided.

In steep measures levels are driven, and top holes or stalls worked therefrom to the rise. The opening out level is driven wide enough to take a low side pack, and then a skip follows on the upper side, forming out the top holes or stalls. Mr. Charlton does not like this system, and is of opinion that levels should be driven sufficiently wide to take both high and low side packs, openings being left on the high sides as required. The maximum distance fixed between supports on roads and at the face, should be reviewed from time to time, so that changing conditions may be met. Managers should take personal interest in the methods employed for dealing with falls on roads, and should give special attention to the methods of support at junctions, where many accidents take place.

It is to the firemen as a body that Mr. Charlton mainly looks to effect a reduction in the accident-rate from falls of ground. It is essential that firemen should be men not only of experience, but of force of character, and this latter characteristic can only be developed by encouragement and support from their superior officials. They should be qualified to form sound opinions, and should have sufficient confidence in their judgment to insist on their instructions being carried out. The visits of a qualified fireman to a working place are of great value, as he often sees dangers which have escaped the collier who is working in the place all the time. Indeed one of the Inspector's assistants recently suggested to him that a fireman on going round his district in the reverse way to that in which he usually travels sees dangers not observed before, and without doubt there is substance in this view. Mr. Charlton continues his comments on common causes of accidents and his closing remarks on this question may be quoted in full:—

The responsibility on firemen is heavy indeed, more particularly where boys are employed at the face, as is the custom in this Division. He knows the more common causes of accident, and should be constantly on the look-out, so that a warning may be given to the erring workman. Common causes of accident to colliers are : Failure to comply with the timbering rules ; failure to set props in the best positions, having regard to breaks and slips in the roof ; failure to set sufficient props at loose ends ; failure to set supports at ripping lips ; failure to set sufficient supports at road heads ; failure to use flats where the roof is broken up ; failure to dress rippings carefully after shots have been fired ; failure to set sprags before commencing holing; failure to set sufficient sprags ; failure to set all props and sprags on to a hard bottom, and tighten them ; failure to use substantial lids to props and sprags ; failure to get clod down on to the floor ; failure to leave room to jump clear in case of need ; failure to refine broken props ; and failure to draw props and sprags in dangerous positions with safety appliances.

As well as the above items of omission by colliers, the fireman must bear in mind the acts of commission liable to lead to accidents, some of which are : Attempts to get too much coal down at one time ; working under unsupported clod after an attempt has been made to get it down; passing in front of a length of coal from which the sprags have been drawn; passing under the rippings after props have been drawn; passing under the rippings while a shot hole is being drilled ; performing for the shotsman some of the operations he is required by the regulations to perform himself ; standing in a tram to cut rippings; cutting rippings without setting temporary props ; using a pick where a bar could be used ; leaving props standing inside packs, or chocks ; and putting off erecting a prop until a tub has been filled, or any other reason.

Firemen on repair shifts have constantly to keep in mind the mistakes likely to be made by repairers, and in consultation with them should always plan out a scheme of work before operations are commenced. Mr. Charlton suggests some rules for their guidance:—

First of all, strengthen supports which have not to be removed, and do this on a liberal scale.

When making height, do not try to get down too much ground at once.

Never interfere with the sides of an old road without previously supporting the roof and sides.

Use a safety appliance as much as possible for withdrawing supports.

Do not expose yourself to risk unless it cannot be avoided.

Use struts and stringing deals liberally.

Never leave vacant cavities over covering wood.

Do not leave any place where repair work has been done unless supported in accordance with the manager's posted notice.

If working on a road on a steep gradient, take precautions against timber sliding down to the danger of workers below.

If using a tram on a steep road, take precautions against it getting out of control and becoming a runaway.

Protect yourself against runaways from above.

Do not set props close to a tub road.

At junctions, protect props against the danger of being knocked out.

Always support the lip of a canch in the roof.

Midland and Southern Division.

No less than 55 per cent. of the underground fatal accidents in this Division in 1927 were due to falls of ground, which accounted for 50 per cent. of all the underground accidents reported to Mr. H. A. Abbott, the Divisional Inspector. Sixty-four per cent. of the fatal accidents and 77 per cent. of all accidents from falls of ground occurred at the coal face. The total deaths from falls numbered 53, with 202 persons reported injured, and 4,324 disabled for more than three days. The Inspector gives short details of some of the accidents from falls of ground, which present features of interest and instructive guidance. One of the accidents occurring in the waste caused the death of a contract collier, and the Inspector concludes his reference by remarking that procrastination in the withdrawal of timber from wastes at the proper time enhances the danger to those whose duty it is to do the work. Managers should insist on systematic withdrawal of timber at the proper time.

Sufficient reference has been made to the Reports of H.M. Inspectors, with extracts therefrom, to emphasise the seriousness of the danger from falls of ground. Readers of this journal should avail themselves of the opportunity to read the Reports in full. It would be to their advantage to do so, and as the Reports are issued at 1s. net, the investment would be a sound one.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Abbott, Henry Arnold    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Carey, Joseph Macleod    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Charlton, William John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Felton, John Robinson    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hudspeth, Henry Moore    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
11 Aug 1928  Accidents In 1927 (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Aug 1928  Steel Supports, Views at Mines Inspectors (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Nov 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, 1927 Statistical Record (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Dec 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Explosions of Firedamp or Coal Dust (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Dec 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Falls of Ground (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Dec 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Falls of Ground (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Jan 1929  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Underground Haulage Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Jan 1929  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Underground Haulage Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print