|
20th December 1928 Oughterside Colliery FatalityInquest On Dearham MinerAn inquest was held in the Reading Room, Dearham, on Monday, on John Osborne Blackburn, aged 35, coal hewer, of Row Beck, Dearham, who was killed at Oughterside Colliery on Saturday afternoon. After eating his bait, deceased was proceeding with his mate, John Logan, of Grasslot, to the coal face to resume work when he said, "Whist, John, there's something nestling." Next he shouted "Look out," and both set off to run. Logan ran up towards the "forehead" of the dilly brow and got clear, but deceased was crushed under a heavy fall and when extricated was dead, his skull having been fractured, his ribs crushed and his thighs broken. Deceased leaves a widow and five children, the eldest being eleven and an invalid. The inquest was conducted by Mr. D. J. Mason, and others present were Mr. W. B. Brown, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. T. Cape, M.P., representing the relatives; and Mr. O. F. Ormrod, Whitehaven, representing the Oughterside Colliery Company. I. Johnson was the foreman of the jury, all of whom were miners. Joseph Dobie, Hensingham, mining student at Harrington Collieries, produced a plan of the scene of the accident, and said it showed the fall to be 36 feet in length. It was in a roadway with tub rails laid. The roof was supported "out by" by props with head pieces at intervals of six feet. "In by" it was supported by props with short "trees" (T pieces on the top). It was a big fall and had evidently all come down in one piece or in big slabs. The road was about 10 feet wide at the point. Edward Roden, deputy, Crosby, said he examined the place of the accident about 11-5 a.m. and then saw no signs of "slips" in the roof. It appeared quite safe. There were three "head gears" six feet apart and two props with head pieces on the "in by" side. He had left the pit when the accident occurred. Change of Timbering System.
Mr. Brown: There was a change over from side props with head pieces to middle props with head pieces? — There was a change in the system of timbering. Mr. Brown: Why? — The idea was to support the roof by side props and head trees later. What was the distance from the coal face to the head pieces with two side props? — Eight or nine yards. And to the nearest baulk supported by side props? — About 11 yards. Wouldn't it be a better system to set these long supports right to the coal face? — Oh yes. Mr. Cape: What is the recognised distance regarding props? — Six feet to four feet. What is the reason then for there being five or six yards without putting heads in? — Witness said it was the system that had been followed at the colliery since 1912. Mr. Cape: How many heads were there in that 36 feet that fell? — Three, I think. Mr. Cape: And there should have been six. In reply to further questions witness said the fallen part of the roof would have been exposed four or five days. There had been "slips" in it at the "out by" end, but these could not be seen with the eye. Mr. Ormrod: A "slip" is a stone with a sort of slant back? — Yes. Edward Bellis, Barton Villas, Oughterside, deputy, said he fired three shots in the working place of Blackburn and Logan about 4-15 p.m. He passed along the road where the fall took place and was satisfied that the timbers were all in place and there was no connection between the firing of the shots and the fall of roof. One of the headgears was supported on the left hand side by a short prop supported on the coal. When he got nine or ten yards from the present working place to the old working, where the "following" in the roof was already down, there was no sign of the roof breaking back. A juryman: Was the stone which came down parallel with the brow? — Yes, the full width of the brow. Further questioned, witness said that the coal face was nine or ten yards from the edge of the "holing" and there was not a single "head" in the nine or ten yards. He had passed the "head" with the short prop several times and thought now that perhaps it ought to have been changed. The under manager was the man with the authority to tell the shiftmen where to timber. He was called to the scene of the accident and Blackburn was dead when they got him out. He had a fractured skull and broken thighs. "Look Out!" John Logan (23), 28, Grasslot, who was suffering from shock, said he was working with Blackburn on Saturday and they had come out of their place and had their bait while Bellis fired three shots. Bellis passed under the roof which subsequently fell and they were going back to work when deceased said. "Whist, John, there's something nesting," Next he shouted. "Look out," and witness ran up into the "forehead" and heard a crash behind him. As he got clear he turned round and saw his mate's lamp as it dropped. He dare not return over the same ground so he got through the old working and sent a message to Bellis, and subsequently helped to extricate his mate's body. Questioned, witness said it seemed to be a very good roof and quite safe. Norman Beaney, Barton Villas, Oughterside, the manager of the pit, was questioned by Mr. Cape. He said he had been a manager five years and had worked his way up, starting in the collieries as a boy. He left the pit at 1 p.m. and Bellis was in charge of the shift. There was no certificated man there after he left, no one of higher status than Bellis. He was in that place twice last week and noticed the "head" with a short prop, which was put there in order to get the lines past. Mr. Cape: Could the tubs have gone past with a prop to the floor? — Yes. You are the only man who can give orders for timbering? — No, there is Mr. Corley, the overman. Has he a certificate? — Only a deputy's certificate. Mr. Brown: Would it be right to say there was an adequate supply of timber? — Yes. You will agree that it would be better to get down this "following" stone? — I certainly do and it will be done in future. Summing Up. The Coroner, summing up, said the jury would have no difficulty deciding how deceased died, what they had to consider was whether there was any criminal negligence on the part of anybody. They had heard that the "slips" in the roof were not seen, but the evidence as to whether it was timbered properly was a different matter. However, as far as he could see whether there was negligence or not it was certainly not criminal negligence. The system of timbering might be improved, and with regard to the advice given by Mr. Brown that a change in the method would be beneficial, an undertaking had been given that the system would be changed. The Foreman said the jury found a verdict of accidental death. They thought it desirable for a change in the system of timbering. Where the manager had the "following" taken down six feet would be ample for the "gears," but where he did not have this taken down they suggested four feet with the "heads" taken right up to the face. They though it would be much safer.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||