1st December 1928, Page: 154, Column: 1
The Grading And Sampling Of Coal
By Neville Simpkin, M.Sc.
From Paper read at the November Meeting of the Manchester Geological and Mining
Society.
There has been a marked tendency during recent years to pay more attention to
the sizing and constancy in composition of coals put on the market by the
individual collieries. This tendency has been influenced to a large extent by
economic conditions, and by the demands of the buyers for coals suitable for
different purposes. In order to supply the big consumers of coal, it is
necessary to-day to put on the market products of such a nature that their
variance in composition is only small and kept within well-defined limits. It
is only reasonable to expect that a buyer should pay for what he receives and
not what he should receive. This may sound rather drastic, but if any attempt
was made to sell other commodities on the same lines that a large percentage of
coal is sold at the present day, it is easy to imagine what would be the
results.
The selling of coal on a scientific basis, as it is sometimes called, is being
shown in the increased tendency to arrange contracts on a calorific value and
ash content basis, with penalties and bonuses depending upon whether the coal
is below or above a previously arranged standard. The problem leads naturally
to the question of coal purification. It is outside the scope of this paper to
treat this subject beyond referring to a few points which are related directly
with the question of variation in the composition of marketed products. In
addition to other advantages, the washing, or cleaning, of a coal, has a marked
tendency to give products of fairly even composition provided that the
purification process received adequate supervision. Putting it another way, the
ordinary run of mine coal if subjected merely to dry screening will, under
certain conditions, yield products each of which may vary considerably in
itself in ash content from day to day, or even during each day, due to the
nature of the seam and the method of working. Purification of the coal tends to
"even" the products and give sizes which in themselves maintain a
more constant ash content not varying to the same extent as in the uncleaned
coal. There are, of course, cases where this difference is not very marked, but
unwashed slacks are liable to wide variations in ash content.
According to the 7th Annual Report of the Secretary for Mines for the year
1927, 20.5 per cent. of the total output of saleable coal in Great Britain had
been washed or subjected to a dry cleaning process. It is rather interesting to
note that the figure for Lancashire and Cheshire was 19.2 per cent., the
highest being South Yorkshire with 38.8 per cent. and Cumberland and
Westmorland with a similar figure. The Report deplores the fact that no
previous figures are available for comparison purposes, but "it is
estimated that the quantity of coal washed or cleaned in 1927 was approximately
double the quantity so treated in 1913. The washing of 51½ million tons of
coal (the quantity washed in 1927) would result in the separation of (say) over
2½ million tons of dirt, allowing a removal of approximately 5 per cent. A
loss of 1 per cent. of coal in the dirt is equivalent to 25,000 tons of coal,
and this figure represents very good practice in coal washing. In many washers,
the loss is very much increased ; it is not very unusual for this to mount up
to 5 per cent., 10 per cent., and even higher, due frequently to insufficient
supervision and necessary adjustment of the washer. The choice lies between
efficiency in the washer with supervision or inefficiency and loss without it.
The buying and selling of coal by any means involving a regulation of price
according to the analysis involves the question of sampling. The sample taken
must contain coal and impurities in the same proportion as they occur in the
grade of coal which it represents. A further point which requires special
attention is the different sizes of coal in the product being sampled. As an
example, a 2-inch slack may contain (say) 10 per cent. of 1"-2", 20
per cent. of ½"-1", 17 per cent of ¼"-½",
and so on, each fraction containing a different percentage of ash and varying
in other properties such as calorific value, sulphur and so forth. The
following figures may be quoted obtained from screening slacks passing a
2" mesh into different sizes and determining the ash content of each
:—
Obviously it is necessary to ensure that each of these fractions is truly
represented in the sample. The easiest method of obtaining samples is when the
coal is in motion, e.g., being conveyed along a belt, picking belt, falling off
a chute, or from other similar places. Sampling is performed regularly at a
great number of power stations, electricity and gas works, industrial concerns,
and similar places. Why should it not be done at the pits so that the colliery
proprietors could know what was being sold and have a ready answer to any
complaint ? False sampling may often result in totally absurd figures. To show
the type of thing which does occur, I should like to quote two actual cases out
of several which have come to my notice. The first arose through a complaint
being made concerning delivery of some unwashed mixed coal of about 3-inch
downwards. The complaint was accompanied by a sample which consisted
principally of shale, shaly coal, and similar material, and was very high in
ash. Upon investigation it was found that the "sample" had been
obtained by carefully picking some dozen pieces of the dirty material from the
top of each wagon, no attempt being made to sample the whole. The second case
was due to a misunderstanding on the part of the man carrying out the sampling.
The bulk sample had been obtained in the proper way and was being coned and
quartered. The man who was doing the mixing was working so efficiently that
every time he saw a piece of dirt or dirty coal he picked it out and discarded
it. When sampling is done, it should be carried out by someone who understands
thoroughly what he has to do. It is no use leaving it to the indiscretions of a
convenient surface hand, for however good his intentions may be, he makes
mistakes simply because he does not understand exactly what he has to do and
the reason for doing it in a particular manner.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Simpkin, Neville | | S.M.R.B. | |