Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

1st December 1928, Page: 148, Column: 1

Points From The Inspectors' Reports

Explosions of Firedamp or Coal Dust

At the mines of Great Britain there were 11 fatal accidents by explosions of firedamp or coal dust during 1927, resulting in 72 deaths. Some comments by Sir H. Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, in his annual report, are of general interest, and readers are referred to extracts on page 17, in No. 2, Vol. 39, of this journal.

Scotland Division.

In this Division the separate fatal accidents numbered five, causing eight deaths, there also being 62 persons injured in 33 separate accidents. Mr. Masterton says that in four of the fatal cases the evidence, or failing evidence the deduction from observations, is that a naked light was taken where it ought not to have been and was forbidden. At Carriden Colliery a brushing shot was fired in circumstances in which it ought not to have been thought of. The Inspector infers that similar comment would be true in regard to many of the non-fatal accidents, and he declares that "lack of appreciation of the dangers of using naked lights or, what is nearer the truth, the deliberate risking of dangers from naked lights by workmen with the active connivance of officials, including in some cases the owners, is too common. Prejudices die hard, and that against the use of safety-lamps in this Division persists. So long as mines which occasionally produce firedamp are worked with naked lights, explosions will continue to occur." The concluding note on one of the accidents reads : The whole circumstances go to show the uselessness of half measures. The whole seam should have been worked with safety-lamps, and no matches or other smoking material allowed in the colliery.

Referring back to Mr. Masterton's remarks on the development of machine mining we find the following :

"I would here impress upon and warn the owners, agents and managers of mines in which inflammable gas is found that there are limits to the conditions under which electric plant can be used at the working faces. Inspectors have found instances where the gas carried in the air-current with good ventilation was so near to the permissible point — itself well below the danger point — that I am certain there are occasions when, with the ever varying atmospheric and other conditions underground, the permissible limit is passed, especially in the end places of machine-cut faces and in sheltered parts of waste edges between packs along the coal faces themselves. Where anything approaching these conditions exists immediate steps should be taken to improve the ventilation, and thereby secure a better standard of dilution of the gas. Should this prove impracticable, however, there is no alternative but to withdraw the electrical plant from the region of the working faces ; and in this event, compressed air driven plant can usefully be substituted. There need be no long lines of pipes back to the surface, for electrically driven air compressors situated at convenient centres in main intake airways are not only permissible but are to be recommended."

Mr. Masterton directs attention to "The Safety-lamp (Relighting) Order of 9th December, 1927," under which internal igniters are permissible for use by firemen, shotfirers, managers, under-managers and certain other authorised responsible officials. He says : "To make proper and thorough search for gas a fireman must not be afraid of losing his light, and until now this fear has always been before every fireman. This fear having been removed, one should find better examinations made, and the temptation to open and relight his safety-lamp, to which I fear many a fireman in the past gave way, sometimes with fatal results, will also be gone. I trust the provision of the safety-lamp with relighter will likewise put an end to the growing habit of managers and under-managers going round the workings equipped with electric lamps only. It is not right they should be without means of testing for gas, and the attention of several managers and under-managers has had to be called to this."

In his report Mr. Masterton says he is glad to see so many cap lamps are being used, but they are not yet entirely satisfactory, especially in low workings. Some alteration in the shape and bulk of the battery is necessary, and without taking anything from the safety of the lamp, the cable which connects the battery case to the headpiece could be much lighter and the lighting bulb in its case could be so arranged as to distribute the light better.

Northern Division.

The Inspector in Charge of the Northern Division, Mr. T. Greenland Davies, reports three fatal accidents involving eight deaths and injury to four persons, eight non-fatal accidents resulting in injuries to nine persons, making a total of 8 killed and 13 injured, as compared with 7 and 30 respectively in 1925. "Naked lights" were responsible for one death and nine persons injured ; "matches or smoking" caused three deaths ; "shot-firing" injured one person ; whilst an accident, "cause unknown," killed four persons and injured three others.

In some of the cases reported, it is worthy of note, says Mr. Davies, that there was a fault or disturbance of the seam at or near the point of ignition. This emphasises the advisability of introducing safety-lamps as a temporary precaution in the vicinity of all known faults or disturbances in the seam, in winning places, or in fact in any place where inflammable gas is likely to be found. The examination should always be made with a flame safety-lamp, and should be in every respect thorough. The fact that inflammable gas has not been seen for years, or not at all, does not guarantee any immunity for the future.

In this Division 424 dust samples were collected, and when the results proved unsatisfactory the matter was at once taken up with the collieries concerned ; special attention was then given to the roadways complained of, and follow on inspections usually revealed a satisfactory state of affairs. He has had no occasion to object to the use of any kind of inert dust on account of being injurious to health. On the whole, bearing in mind that most of the samples were collected at doubtful places, he considers the conditions in general are satisfactory.

Attention is directed by Mr. Davies to the fact that where gate-end tub loaders are installed or at any part where tubs are filled by mechanical means, it is not uncommon to find, as indeed, it is almost impossible to prevent, the accumulation of considerable quantities of coal dust in the neighbourhood, especially on pack walls and canch edges of the roadways. It is therefore of prime importance that all parts where tubs are filled by mechanical means should receive strict and systematic attention in regard to the cleaning up of the deposited coal dust and the application of stone dust, more particularly when shots are necessary in the canchwork.

In the section of his report on safety-lamps, Mr. Davies says : "In connection with the proper care and handling of safety-lamps underground in fiery mines, the following case is of particular interest and importance : The owners of Thornley Colliery, Durham, instituted proceedings against a landing lad who was charged with wilfully cutting the lead locking rivet out of his flame safety-lamp whilst inbye in the mine. The lad was convicted and fined forty shillings and the magistrates made an order that defendant was not to be allowed to work in the mine again. I heartily endorse their action."

Yorkshire Division.

Mr. H. M. Hudspeth in his report for this Division, mentions that there were only two explosions, both of firedamp, which caused injury to one and two persons respectively. The former accident, caused by a naked light, though not serious, was the direct outcome of an act of indiscipline — in fact, a contravention of General Regulation 9. The second explosion, classed under "Miscellaneous," was the result of spontaneous combustion.

The number of dust samples collected was 679, and Mr. Hudspeth points out that whereas the roads in general might be said to be sufficiently well stone dusted, a higher standard should be aimed at in proximity to coal faces, particularly in returns therefrom, and in loading conveyor gates. One of the danger spots in a mine is the face end of a return airway from a machine cut or conveyor face where ripping shots are fired, and a considerably higher percentage of incombustible dust than 50 should be constantly maintained in the vicinity of such places. Shots, the Inspector says, should not be fired when machines or conveyors are operating. Large accumulations of coal dust have been formed on occasion in gates where conveyors were delivering or transporting coal, and particular attention should be given where such operations are in progress.

North Midland Division.

Mr. J. R. Felton in his report, says it is pleasing to be able to record that there was no loss of life from explosions in 1927, and that only two non-fatal accidents occurred by which four persons were injured. This is the best record for a number of years.

In this Division 307 dust samples were collected, and only 18 contained more than 50 per cent. of combustible matter. Mr. Felton would suggest to managers of collieries at which conveyors and coal-cutters are in use (particularly if cutting is done in coal) the necessity for paying special attention to the return end of such faces and the return airway near the face, since the air-current travelling along the face is likely to deposit fine dust in greater quantity there than elsewhere in the workings. As an example of thorough stone-dusting he quotes the case of a Derbyshire colliery in which 300 tons of inert dust was applied to 29 miles of roadways, i.e., an average of one ton of dust for 170 yards of roadway.

Lancashire and N. Wales Division.

Mr. A. D. Nicholson, in his report for Lancashire, etc., regrets that 1927 did not afford the general immunity from serious accidents under "explosions" that has frequently been experienced in this Division in the past, two cases of ignition of firedamp being recorded, resulting in three deaths and injuries to four other persons.

The story of the accidents reveals that in each case the coalcutter was suspect, but omitting the details, the conclusion of the Inspector may be quoted to the effect that the whole question resolves itself into one of maintenance and keeping the coal-cutting machines in a flame-proof condition. Inspections made of other electrical coal-cutting machines showed that the conditions as regards missing bolts, etc., which contributed to both the accidents, existed at other collieries, and in consequence Mr. Nicholson considered it advisable to communicate with the management of all firms using electrical coal-cutters. In this letter he said that investigations of the accidents clearly indicates :

"(1) That the housing of the electrical parts of the coal-cutting machines should be flame-proof and so designed that bolt holes or stud holes do not afford a passage to any such part.

"(2) That frequent examination of the machines should be made to ascertain that they are maintained in a flame-proof condition. These examinations should be made by a person who has been trained to appreciate the difference between flame-proof enclosures and ordinary enclosures, and he should be specially informed with regard to the particular apparatus so that he may know where the potential danger points are.

"(3) That a system of inspection of all bolts and studs should be adopted, with a time limit between each inspection reduced to a minimum. These inspections should include plugged holes in the motor frame for draining oil. To this end I suggest that one inspection prior to the commencement of each working shift is not sufficient.

"(4) That a particularly close watch for firedamp is necessary while the machines are at work; this applies generally, but especially so in the vicinity of faults or disturbances, at the highest point of the face and near canches.

"(5) That the provisions of G.R. 132 apply to all working places in mines where safety-lamps are in use."

In his remarks on stone-dusting Mr. Nicholson says the danger zone connected with shot-firing may be said to have been moved to within 200 or 300 yards of the face where shots are fired in the ripping canches, along the faces and for a considerable distance into the return airways, especially airways on the return side of coal-cutting and conveying faces, and it is to these portions of the mine that special attention should be directed.

Cardiff and Newport Division.

In his report for this Division Mr. J. Macleod Carey refers to the disastrous explosion of firedamp at Marine Colliery, Cwm, on the 1st of March, 1927, entailing the loss of 52 lives and injury to 11 others. Particulars from the report of the disaster were given in this journal on page 279 in No. 18, Vol. 38.

There were also two non-fatal ignitions, involving slight injuries to three persons. In one case a person deliberately entered a fenced-off place for some purpose and ignited there a small quantity of firedamp, and in the other the two injured persons struck a match in a district of a mine where safety-lamps were in use and so ignited a small quantity of gas.

The seams worked in the steam coal area of South Wales are known to be exceedingly fiery and give off gas in large quantities, necessitating the circulation of air in large quantities to dilute and render it harmless. Mr. Carey says it is necessary, indeed it is a paramount consideration, to assure that the bulk of the ventilation is kept well up to the working face, and this consummation can best be achieved by maintaining sound packs behind the face line. Such packs will eliminate the possibility of large accumulations of gas collecting in cavities behind the face, in which cavities there is always the possibility of further falls taking place, driving gas on to the working face. When such packs are not maintained the wastes tend to become reservoirs for gas, and are difficult to ventilate owing to the impossibility of properly coursing the available wind.

Swansea Division.

Mr. W. J. Charlton is glad to be able to report that in the Swansea Division in 1927 there was no loss of life under "explosions, etc.," but nine explosions caused injury to 15 persons. Eight of the ignitions occurred in mines where open lights were in use, and one by the illegal striking of a match in a mine worked with safety-lamps. So long as open lights are used in coal mines, ignitions of gas therefrom will take place, says Mr. Charlton. When weeks and months pass without firedamp being found, officials and workmen become unwary and then, when the enemy unexpectedly appears, an accident follows. It is very important that firemen should make tests for the presence of firedamp in places where candles are used with as much care as in places where safety-lamps are used. Small percentages of methane in the air can only be detected by lowering the flame of the safety-lamp, and Mr. Charlton very much doubts whether this precaution is often taken.

It is deplorable, comments the Inspector, that the ignition in a safety-lamp colliery was caused by the striking of a match to enable two labourers to smoke. It was found that the searching of workmen at the colliery in question was not satisfactorily performed, and he recommends all colliery managers periodically to investigate the searching arrangements at their collieries.

In connection with the collection of dust samples, those from roofs and sides were for the most part satisfactory, but Mr. Charlton is not so satisfied with the floor samples. He remains of opinion that the prime cause of this condition is the general failure to maintain trams dustproof. He finds it hard to understand why this matter is not seriously tackled. The provision of buffers to all trams would constitute a big step towards better tram maintenance. Prom an economic standpoint, says the Inspector, it is surely bad policy to drop small coal all along the roads of a colliery, and then have to clean it away, together with the stone dust put down at great expense for protective purposes.

In the "dangerous occurrences" section of the report reference is made to an ignition of firedamp which took place in the undercut made by an electrically driven, chain type, coal-cutting machine. The trailing cable, which was carried over the machine, was caught under a fall of coal, forced down on to the cutters, and carried into the cut. Immediately firedamp ignited and continued to burn until extinguished by means of stone dust. Clearly, adds the Inspector, it is inadvisable to pass a trailing table over a machine, and the lay-out should be so arranged as to avoid this as far as possible.

Midland and Southern Division.

Five explosions occurred in 1927 in this Division, causing the death of one person and injuries to seven others. Four of the explosions were due to ignitions of small pockets of gas by naked lights, and caused injuries of a minor nature to four persons and severe injuries to one person which terminated fatally. One of the accidents, Mr. H. A. Abbott points out, emphasises the necessity of paying more than ordinary attention to the dust near the face in coal headings driven by means of coal-cutting machines holing in the coal, on account of the greater quantity of coal dust produced in the limited space of a heading, and especially if shot-firing is practiced therein.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Abbott, Henry Arnold    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Carey, Joseph Macleod    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Charlton, William John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Davies, Thomas Greenland    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Felton, John Robinson    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hudspeth, Henry Moore    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Masterton, John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Walker, Henry, Sir    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
11 Aug 1928  Accidents In 1927 (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Aug 1928  Steel Supports, Views at Mines Inspectors (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Nov 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, 1927 Statistical Record (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Dec 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Explosions of Firedamp or Coal Dust (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Dec 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Falls of Ground (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Dec 1928  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Falls of Ground (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Jan 1929  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Underground Haulage Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Jan 1929  Points From The Inspectors' Reports, Underground Haulage Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print