3rd November 1928, Page: 123, Column: 1
Indian Miners And High Temperatures
In his paper presented at the 39th annual general meeting of the Institution of
Mining Engineers, on "Atmospheric Conditions in Indian Coal Mines (15th
Report to the Committee on 'The Control of Atmospheric Conditions in Hot and
Deep Mines')," Dr. David Penman, Principal, Dhanbad School of
Mines, opens with the statement that most of the coal-mines in India are
comparatively shallow. Up till a few years ago, indeed, there was hardly any
working which was more than 500 or 600 feet below the ground-level. In recent
years, however, several shafts over 1,000 feet deep and one pair of shafts
1,500 feet deep have been sunk and are now dealing with the raising of coal.
The ventilation in small and shallow mines is almost invariably obtained by
natural means — unless the presence of inflammable gas necessitates an
artificial ventilating device — and is generally fairly good. Many of
these mines have several openings to the surface — inclines and shafts
— and the number of the openings undoubtedly aids in the ventilation of
the mine. Shafts from 400 to 600 feet deep are common. The airways and
galleries are generally of large dimensions, giving low resistance.
Temperature records and readings are given, and Dr. Penman recalls that
various opinions have been expressed as to the limits of wet-bulb temperatures
beyond which physical work becomes difficult. In the First Report of the
Committee on "The Control of Atmospheric Conditions in Hot and Deep
Mines" it is stated that "even with the wet-bulb temperature at
78° continuous fairly hard work in still air was impossible." The
Committee further stated that a wet-bulb temperature of about 80° Fahr.
might be assumed as the upper limit even with an air-current such as might be
expected along a well-ventilated working-face. From figures given for Indian
mines, the Indian miner has often to work in an atmosphere showing wet-bulb
temperatures higher than those given by the Committee as the limit for physical
work. A wet-bulb temperature of 78° Fahr. would be considered comparatively
cool in an Indian mine, and as Dr. Penman points out wet-bulb
temperatures of 85° Fahr. and even higher are common. Moreover, the air in
most of the working-places is practically still, or at the best very sluggish.
Yet the miners work day after day uncomplainingly, and not only without
mishaps, but apparently without any ill-effects.
It is well-known that persons accustomed to hot damp air are able to work with
comfort under hygrometric conditions which would be very trying to men who had
not become acclimatised to such conditions. The Indian is acclimatised to high
temperatures, and it may be that for that reason he is better able to stand
heat than the average white man. The calorific value of the "minimal
metabolism" of the individual varies with different races, and is lower
for Indian than for European workmen. Consequently, the Indian can as a rule
withstand the higher temperatures of a tropical climate with less strain than
the European, owing to the tax on the sweating system being less severe. The
pigment of the skin may also not be without some effect. The Indian miner,
indeed, prefers to work in a warm place. He would prefer, for example, a
gallery in which the temperature was, say, 75° Fahr. to one in which it was
50° Fahr. Nor does he like to work in a strong breeze. He works with
practically no clothing, whether the mine atmosphere is warm or cool. Thus
practically his whole body is exposed to the drying and cooling action of the
air. Again, he works irregularly. He may work steadily for about an hour and
then come out to a cooler place and rest for fifteen minutes or even more.
While he is working he works hard. It is not likely, however, that he works at
a rate equal to the British collier. He is as a rule shorter in stature and of
much lighter build than his British contemporary, and consequently expends less
energy in physical exertion. As a rule, he dislikes any change in the
temperature conditions to which he is accustomed. For example, a group of
miners who had been accustomed to work in places where the temperature was
88° Fahr. and the humidity 98 per cent., objected to being transferred to
working-places where the temperature was nearly 20 degrees lower.
There is another point worthy of consideration, concludes Dr. Penman.
Except perhaps at the working face, the conditions in a coal-mine in India
during a large part of the year, and particularly during the hot dry season,
are much more pleasant than those on the surface. When the dry-bulb temperature
during the day on the surface is, say, 110° Fahr. or higher, throughout the
mine (with the exception of the working-face) it may be, say, 75° to
85° Fahr. — a considerable difference. It is therefore often a
welcome relief to the miner to escape from the heat and glare of the tropical
sun into the comparative coolness and the darkness of the underground workings
of the mine.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Penman, David, Dr. | | Principal | |