Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

20th October 1928, Page: 101, Column: 1

Spontaneous Combustion Of Coal

Concluded from page 92.

By Joseph D. Davis and D. A. Reynolds.

Determining Oxidising Tendency.

In summarising the work on methods for distinguishing coals with respect to relative tendencies to heat spontaneously two available methods may be cited as reliable in giving consistent results, as long as the conditions under which they are applied are kept constant. The methods depend on (1) the rate at which the coal absorbs oxygen at various fixed temperatures, as used by Winmill, Graham, Parr, and others, and (2) the rate of heating of coal under adiabatic conditions, as used by Winmill and Davis and Byrne.

Methods based on kindling temperature or glow point and relatively high-temperature methods that depend on the rise of coal temperature above that of the oven are of questionable application. They tell something of the behaviour of coal at high temperatures, from which its behaviour at atmospheric or storage temperatures is inferred. Not enough experimental work has been done to show that inference is justified. Furthermore, as the reactions involved in spontaneous heating are imperfectly known and methods for measuring their intensity must be wholly empirical, it is logical to test at temperatures which prevail in storage. The value of purely chemical methods, such as that based on absorption of iodine, has not been proved.

Results of laboratory tests can be used to compare heating tendencies of different coals under exactly comparative conditions — that is, same size, same moisture content, and equal previous exposure, etc. — but they must be used with caution in predicting comparative storage qualities. For example, a high-rank steam coal, shown to be insensitive in the laboratory test, has been known to heat when stored adjacent to a gas coal that did not heat, although shown by test to be sensitive. The reason was that the steam coal was very friable and the gas coal was not, therefore the steam coal produced by far the largest amount of fines on handling. The latter oxidised more rapidly than the lumps of the gas coal that was inherently more sensitive. The manner of piling in storage may also vary enough to reverse the order of heating tendency as determined by laboratory test; the same may doubtless be said of the amount of ventilation. In other words, in order to use information from laboratory tests under empirical conditions, one must be sure that the storage conditions under which such information is to be applied are comparative.

No one of the banded constituents of coal can be held mainly responsible for spontaneous heating ; in this respect the results of the work are negative. However, this fact does not impair their value as contributions to the general knowledge of spontaneous heating of coal.

Coal Solvents.

In summarising the results of research on the oxidation of the constituents of coal separable by solvents, one should remember that such separations are by no means clear-cut quantitative processes and may be subject to wide variation because of differences in temperatures, concentrations, and other conditions.

All investigators have found that residues insoluble in solvents are quite as readily oxidisable as, often more so than, raw coal. The fact that a certain portion of coal after its isolation by solvents is more readily oxidised than the coal itself should not lead one to conclude that this portion is the coal constituent responsible for self-heating. Extraction changes the physical character of all materials present in coal, and coal constituents when isolated do not necessarily behave the same as when in untreated coal. That the physical properties of the insoluble portion of coal are greatly altered by removal of the pyridine-soluble substances is evident from the fact that extraction with pyridine increases the capacity of the coal for absorption of methane as much as 30 per cent. Ordinarily, extraction residues are probably more porous and afford greater surface for attack by oxygen than raw coal. As soluble constituents are resinous they are less permeable to oxygen and should be dispersed in testing so that a large surface is exposed to oxidation ; otherwise tests of the soluble and insoluble portions of coal will not be comparable.

Evidence that the extractable portions of coal take part in the oxidising reactions which result in the self-heating of coal is found in the decreased yields of these constituents as coal weathers. This result has been observed in, extractions with pyridine, phenol and naphthalene. Investigators have found that oxidation of coal diminishes solubility but does not materially change the character of the extract as determined by chemical analyses ; that is to say, the oxygen content of the extract from oxidised coal is virtually the same as that of the extract from fresh coal.

The results of the researches outlined justify the conclusion that all constituents separable from coal by solvents absorb oxygen, and that in consequence all must take part in the reactions that under favourable conditions result in the self-ignition of coal. In other words, it is neither the resinic nor the cellulosic constituents of coal but the coal as a whole that should be considered in the investigation of self-heating and spontaneous combustion.

Mechanism of Weathering.

The work of Francis and Wheeler is of great theoretical interest because of its bearing on coal constitution and offers a plausible explanation of the mechanism of weathering. The evidence strongly indicates that weathering is essentially a process of decoalification which in the main involves regeneration of ulmic matter. There seems no reason to think that the laboratory method applied by Francis and Wheeler differs much from the weathering process in effect; both are suppressed oxidation processes in the sense that the excessive rise of temperature characteristic of spontaneous combustion is prevented. For this very reason it is somewhat difficult to trace the bearing of the work on the process of spontaneous combustion. The first periods of the oxidation process as carried out by Francis and Wheeler are perhaps the most indicative of what takes place in spontaneous combustion, for in practice spontaneous combustion occurs, if at all, within the first 8 to 12 weeks after storing. Thus the oxidation of vitrain indicates that "soluble ulmins were formed rapidly, the change by oxidation at 100° being apparently complete at the end of the first period of heating, and simultaneously that about 30 per cent. of both the beta and gamma compounds (amounting to 6 per cent. of the coal) were destroyed." Furthermore, the alpha compounds in the oxidised coal contained only about half the ulmins produced and the 9.9 per cent. beta compounds in the oxidised coal must therefore be regarded as largely ulmifled. The present writers believe this fact indicates that the beta and gamma compounds are the most sensitive to oxygen, particularly at the beginning of spontaneous heating, which may be considered the most critical time in respect to storage. Thirty per cent. of the beta and gamma compounds are actually destroyed (converted into the final oxidation products CO2, CO and H2O) ; obviously more heat is generated by this complete oxidation than by the process of ulmification which seems to consist mainly o{ formation of the so-called coal-oxygen complex.

Chemical Factors.

The conclusions of the authors of this paper may be summarised as follows :—

1. The rank of a coal (with which the chemical constitution of the coal substance varies) is known to affect the tendency to spontaneous heating. Other things being equal, the lower-rank coals heat more easily than the high-rank or older coals.

2. Pyrite, when present in a finely divided state, is known to be a contributing chemical factor in spontaneous heating, but whether pyrite is often the determining factor is doubtful. Coals in which pyrite content is very low have heated spontaneously.

3. Moisture is probably not a chemical factor except in so far as its presence is necessary for oxidation of pyrite. Coal in storage is never so dry that enough moisture is not present to take care of any catalytic requirements which might exist.

4. Organic sulphur contributes little or nothing to spontaneous heating.

5. Ozone, if present in the atmosphere, accelerates spontaneous heating: however, it is probably never present in sufficient amounts to warrant consideration as a factor.

6. Bacterial action is probably not a factor of practical importance.

Physical Factors.

Analysis of the results of work on the purely physical factors that effect spontaneous heating seems to indicate that the size of the coal and the initial temperature of exposure are by far the most important, provided always that enough oxygen is present to saturate the coal. Moisture may deter or promote heating, depending on whether it is being evaporated from the coal or condensed thereon. Occluded gases probably have little effect. The effects of heat capacity and conductivity are largely bound up with the moisture content and the size of the coal.

Recapitulation.

In this paper the results of chemical and physical research, particularly that of most recent date, have been assembled in abstract form and critically examined. It is appropriate that the writers state briefly the general conclusions that seem justified by their study and indicate how these conclusions have a practical bearing on the problem of coal storage.

1. All coals but anthracites undergo spontaneous heating; the liability to self-heating is greatest among coals of lowest rank. One should therefore use greater care in storing a sub-bituminous coal than in storing a high-rank bituminous coking coal. More pains should be taken to prevent segregation of fine coal in the storage pile, and foreign matter should be excluded more carefully.

2. Oxidation of the coal substance itself is the main cause of spontaneous combustion ; some of the organic constituents may contribute more to the heating than others, but it has not been shown that any one constituent exerts a preponderant influence to the exclusion of the rest.

3. The process of spontaneous heating may be considered to take place in two stages. The first stage is operative at room temperature as soon as freshly broken coal is exposed to the air. It begins with the physical absorption of oxygen and is continued by the formation of a solid chemical compound of coal and oxygen, which is gradually decomposed as the temperature rises. Decomposition is not complete, however, until the temperature reaches about 445°F. This first stage of the process generates heat, but not as much as the second stage. The coal increases in weight by the amount of oxygen retained. The second stage involves the breaking up of the solid compound of coal with oxygen and the formation of the final oxidation products — carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and water. With the Appalachian coals this stage begins to be appreciable at about 85°F. and increases in intensity as the temperature rises. With lower-rank coals the beginning temperature is lower. Both stages of the process go on simultaneously, therefore, from about 85° to 445°F. There is no sharp transition from one stage to the other. The rate of heating increases logarithmically with the temperature ; that is, no coal has as an inherent property a critical temperature at which there is a sharp transition from relatively slow to rapid heating. When the term "critical temperature" is used, it should be clearly defined as the temperature at which the rate of generation of heat becomes greater than its rate of dissipation under certain fixed Conditions. For other conditions the temperature will be different. For example, in a storage pile the heating usually starts in fine coal at a point about 6 feet from the surface. If combustion ultimately develops at this point, one may regard the temperature of the coal when placed in storage as its critical temperature in so far as critical temperature is determined by conditions that prevail at this particular point. At any other point where conditions (fineness of coal, rate of air supply, etc) are different the critical temperature will be higher. Results of laboratory studies in which critical temperatures of different coals are compared as a measure of relative ease of oxidation are valid only when the test conditions are strictly comparative.

4. Pyrite when finely divided can increase the tendency of a coal to heat spontaneously. Although it has been shown that coals containing virtually no pyrite have fired spontaneously, it has also been quite definitely shown that fine pyrite when present in the coal does increase the rate of oxidation. One would not, therefore, select for storage a coal containing fine pyrite.

5. Opinions differ as to what effect moisture in coal has on spontaneous heating. Probably the effect of moisture is determined by the conditions of storage. If one could be sure of wetting only those parts of the storage pile where spontaneous heating would otherwise develop, he could very probably prevent it; the heat required to vaporise the water would be more than the oxidising coal could supply. However, wetting down the surface of the whole pile changes the conditions of ventilation and may favour heating at points not reached by the water, where dangerous heating would not otherwise occur.

6. Chemical factors other than those touched upon have little or no influence on the spontaneous heating of coal.

7. Laboratory studies have indicated what kinds of coal heat the most readily, and their relative tendencies to heat can be measured by several methods. The effect of fine coal, pyrites, etc., has also been shown. The fact remains, however, that all bituminous coals have heated in storage when conditions were favourable. It is believed, therefore, that the most fruitful studies of the future will deal with storage conditions. Work is particularly needed on the effect of air supply.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Byrne, —      
Davis, —      
Davis, Joseph D.    U.S. Bureau of Mines  
Francis, —      
Graham, —      
Parr, —      
Reynolds, D. A.    U.S. Bureau of Mines  
Wheeler, Richard Vernon      Whos Who Page
Winmill, —      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
25 Aug 1928  Heating Of Coal In Storage (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 Oct 1928  Spontaneous Combustion Of Coal (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Oct 1928  Spontaneous Combustion Of Coal (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print