6th October 1928, Page: 81, Column: 1
Air Losses In Mine Entries
Bulletin No. 170 of the Engineering Experiment Station of the University of
Illinois, prepared by Messrs. Alfred C. Callen and Cloyde M. Smith
(Professor and Research Associate respectively in Mining
Engineering), deals with "The Measurement of Air Quantities and Energy
Losses in Mine Entries." In an introduction the Authors explain that this
investigation is a continuation of that which was reported under the same title
in Bulletin 158, the primary object of which was "to see whether
pitot-tube traversing methods could be applied with reasonable accuracy at any
desired location in a mine entry without building a measuring station and
without special preparation of the section. As a secondary feature it was
planned to secure pressure-loss data in conjunction with the velocity
measurements in order to obtain information on the magnitude of so-called
"friction" losses, as well as of the losses due to splitting, special
resistances, etc." The previous work had been carried on at a mine where
operating conditions made it inadvisable to vary the quantity or distribution
of the air, so that it was necessary to conduct the tests with the normal
velocities of the air-current. It was desired, therefore, to continue the
investigation at a mine where air quantities could be varied at will so as to
permit the measurement of quantities and energy losses under a wide range of
conditions. Fortunately, such a mine was available, not only offering freedom
to vary air quantities as desired, but also presenting a range of entry
characteristics that afforded an opportunity to apply the pitot-tube method
under both excellent and very bad entry conditions.
The tests are discussed in detail, the following conclusions being drawn as a
result of the investigation:—
(1) Experience in measuring mean velocities ranging from 350 to 1900 feet per
minute in mine entries of different degrees of uniformity (shape, area,
alignment, and roughness) abundantly confirms the conclusions reached as a
result of the work described in Bulletin 158 : namely, that it is possible to
measure air quantities with reasonable accuracy in coal-mine airways by
pitot-tube traversing methods, at practically any desired location, and without
special preparation of the section, provided extreme care is used in every
detail of the work.
(2) An increase in the number of sub-sections in a given cross-section gives
mean-velocity results somewhat lower than are obtained with a smaller number of
sub-sections, due to the fact that a greater portion of the cross-section is
being covered by the traverse. There is no end to the number of sub-sections
that may be used other than the limitations caused by the time required and the
accuracy desired.
(3) The "centre constant," or ratio of mean velocity to centre
velocity for a given cross-section, is primarily a function of the section
itself, including its shape and the characteristics of the entry, and varies
but slightly with velocity changes.
(4) If extreme care is used a centre constant, correct within one or two per
cent., may be obtained for a given cross-section by making two or three
traverses for a given condition of air-flow.
(5) Results obtained by anemometer traversing indicate that while a certain
degree of accuracy can be had by calibrating the anemometer against pitot-tube
traverses at a given cross-section, yet the anemometer data are less consistent
than the pitot-tube data, the average residuals for the former being twice as
great as for the latter.
(6) The kata thermometer was tried as an instrument for determining velocities
in direct comparison with the pitot tube. The results obtained were very
erratic, two velocities determined in immediate succession by the same observer
generally differing from each other by more than ten per cent. These trials
were made at velocities of about 400 and 900 feet per minute, and do not
suggest much possibility of satisfactorily using the kata, thermometer for
measuring velocities. It is possible, however, that at lower velocities,
requiring a longer time for cooling, it might give more consistent results.
(7) Simultaneous readings on the Ellison and Wahlen gauge throughout complete
traverses not only give a good agreement between the mean velocities computed
from these data, but indicate that the Ellison gauge can be used with accuracy
at comparatively low velocities. Almost exact checks were secured at mean
velocities of 400 feet per minute and less.
(8) The expression for energy loss, ksV3 derived from the
Atkinson formula, leads to the statement commonly made that, other conditions
remaining the same, the energy loss varies as the cube of the velocity. This,
of course, presupposes that k is a constant at all velocities, a
supposition that is not entirely correct. In these experiments, by the
logarithmic plotting of energy losses against velocities, it was found that the
exponent of V varied from 2.18 to 3.92, although for the long unit
N1 — N3 and the composite units Q1
— Q4 and P1 — P4 the value of the
exponent approximated 3.0, being 3.03, 3.19, and 2.98 respectively. An
examination of the individual values indicates with one exception that only in
the case of short units (considerably less than 100 feet in length) did the
exponent depart very far from the commonly assumed value of 3.0.
(9) The magnitude of the energy losses under different entry conditions is
shown by these experiments. With normal air flow for this mine, about 45,000
cubic feet per minute in each main split, the horse-power required per hundred
feet of the several types of entry represented ranged from 0.1 to 1.6.
(10) The value of k in the Atkinson formula, calculated on the
assumption that pressure losses vary as the square of the velocity, ranged from
12 x 10-10 to 143 x 10-10, depending on the type of
entry. For an entry lined with smooth concrete a straight unit gave k =
12 x 10-10, while for a somewhat sinuous unit k equalled 35 x
10-10. For the composite unit k was 25 x 10-10. A
very similar unit but having cross bars of 30-pound raps on about six-foot
centres had a value of k of 51 X 10-10. The great effect
produced by comparatively small obstructions is noteworthy. For unconcreted air
courses ft ranged from 41 X 10-10 for a fairly straight entry
without timber, but with gob pack walls forming the sides, to 86 x
10-10 for a somewhat similar entry partly timbered, and to 143 x
10-10 for a sinuous entry with timber and pack walls. The composite
unit gave k = 100 x 10-10.
(11) Pressure losses due to bends, the inner radius being about 12 feet,
expressed as a function of the velocity pressure, were about 1.0 velocity
pressure at one bend and about 0.5 velocity pressure at another. It should be
noted that these were not sharp turns but had rather easy inner radii.
(12) Attention should again be called to the fact that k is not a
coefficient of friction alone but a factor covering all energy losses of
whatever nature, particularly those losses caused by extraordinary turbulence.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Callen, Alfred C. | | Professor of Mining Engineering | |
| Smith, Cloyde M. | | Research Associate of Mining Engineering | |