22nd September 1928, Page: 74, Column: 1
Washability Studies
In a paper read before the American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical
Engineers on "Cleaning Bituminous Coal," J. R. Campbell, of
the American Rheolaveur Corporation, emphasises that the need for standardising
methods of arriving at definite conclusions regarding the cleanability of a
given coal, and for measuring the performance of coal-cleaning equipment, is
constantly increasing. He gives a typical examination of coal to illustrate the
washability test procedure.
As regards methods of washing coal, the author says that very lately there has
sprung up a compromise school, advocating a dual process combining pneumatic
dry cleaning and wet washing, with water. Dry separation is certainly
attractive at first sight and probably will always have good application in
arid and frigid regions, but its problem is more complex than that of wet
washing. The paper gives a short survey of wet washing systems in America.
Concentrating Tables. — Considerable attention in late years has
been given to wet concentrating tables for handling fines. The principal tables
are the Campbell bumping table ; the Overstrom table; the Deister-Overstrom
table ; the Deister Machine "Plato" table. The chief difficulty of
the wet tables is their low capacity on fines, varying from 5 to 10 tons per
hour. The Robinson-Ramsay tube exemplifies the tub method of cleaning coal,
which has come back into favour within recent years for a certain class of
work. The Chance cone uses a fluid mass of sand and water as the flotation
medium. So far as known, there is only one installation on bituminous coal.
Recently the Menzies hydro-separator has made its appearance in bituminous
practice, especially in Southern West Virginia. It was first developed in the
anthracite industry, where it is used on steam sizes. The sponsors for the
machine in bituminous practice claim that it will handle all sizes from egg to
slack with a capacity of 25 to 40 tons per hour. The egg size is up to 4 and
5in., which, it is claimed, would eliminate hand-picking. The hydro-separator
would seem to have considerable application where small units are necessary. It
is small and self-contained. The opinion expressed by coal operators who have
had tests made on it is that on sized products, with no middlings to speak of,
the results are favourable as compared with older processes. Another classifier
is the hydrotator, which is a development of the Trent tank or thickener. This
machine is designed to handle fine coal. The Dorr machines are valuable
adjuncts in wet washing. Dry cleaning has many logical applications, but after
close observation of going plants, the author is satisfied that a modern
well-regulated wet washing job has a higher efficiency than a dry table job,
and for that reason wet washing must be used in difficult metallurgical
operations where sulphur is the important factor.
De-watering Methods. — Attention is being given to drying the coal
from wet washing. Washed coal is dewatered by various methods, the principal
ones being: Dewatering elevators and screens ; drainage bins and pits ;
centrifugal dryers, filters and presses ; direct heat dryers. The general
scheme is (a) to dewater the top sizes above ½ or 5/8in. by natural
drainage, (b) centrifugally dry the 5/8-in. to 48 mesh, and (c) dry the slimes
(- 48 mesh to 0) by heat, and thus obtain a wet-washed coal that is
sufficiently dry for all ordinary uses. Heat drying of the sludge or slimes, 48
mesh to 0, is a new development in the art, and operating data are not
available at present. The operating cost is estimated at from 5 to 8 c. per
ton, depending upon the character of the fuel used, which in most cases may be
a secondary coal recoverable from the refuse, but since the tonnage is small,
usually not over 5 per cent. of the feed coal, the net cost is low. A
bituminous wet washing plant now under construction in the Pittsburgh district
will develop all the above methods of drying. It is the feeling among coke oven
men that the extra heat required is not so important. What coke oven men do
object to is coal dripping wet, on the grounds of reduced oven capacity and
possible effect on coke structure ; objections which can largely be removed by
modern methods of drying wet washed coal. In certain other cases, good
by-product practice demands a coal containing moisture, and sometimes water has
to be added. For instance, swelling coals, which cause stickers and a deposit
of carbon, demand a moisture content of 5 to 6 per cent.
Washing Efficiencies. — The author also deals with washing
efficiencies. Some chemical engineers and practical operators believe that a
standard of 85 per cent. for qualitative efficiency and 99.5 per cent. for
quantitative efficiency, if the total reject is not excessive, is too high. The
author is convinced that quality and recovery can be obtained simultaneously in
a properly designed wet-washing system. For plant control the author uses the
Dela-testor because it is a standard machine for making sink-and-iloat tests in
the plant or laboratory. After a sufficient number of these tests have been
made to determine the character of the products produced by the washer,
chemical analyses may be relied upon to give sufficient control. Only one
gravity should be used in testing, and that is the gravity of washing. There
may be conditions wherein it is advisable to use two gravities for testing both
the sink in the washed coal and the float in the refuse. This would be
permissible where there is a considerable percentage of middlings near the
washing gravity. Where a dual gravity is used, the results should be converted
to a single gravity, that of the washing operation, before attempting to
calculate efficiencies.
The operating cost may be conveniently sub-divided into labour, power,
maintenance, depreciation (and interest), loss of input, or "conversion
cost." Conversion cost is considerably more important than many are
willing to understand. Under ordinary conditions coal can be washed in modern
and efficient equipment for from 20 to 25 c. per ton, including all items of
cost. The cost of washing can be predetermined very accurately from the known
factors in the washing problem — the washability, study and engineering
data.
The immediate effect of coal washing, of course, is the reduction of ash and
sulphur, both for commercial and metallurgical purposes. This can be translated
into dollars and cents by the blastfurnace man if an improved coke is demanded
by the exigencies of the case. The value of each 1 per cent. ash reduction in
the coke ranges anywhere from 10 to 25 c. per ton of pig iron, depending on
conditions. Several large steel companies are studying this subject very
intensively. Some figures compiled by a fuel engineer showed that with a long
freight haul 4 per cent. reduction of ash in the coal is worth 1 dol. per ton
to the consumer. Another blast furnace man has a graph in which 1 per cent. of
ash reduction in the coke is worth 40 c. per ton on pig iron on a certain
furnace. In inter-company business it is almost certain that a substantial
reduction of 3 or 4 per cent. ash in the coke will yield a good return on the
cleaning equipment to the holding company and doubly assure a uniform and
quality product of steel.
Another effect of washing, aside from the monetary consideration, is the
improved physical structure of the coke.
In commercial washing, where the washed coal goes on a "buyers'
market" in competition with an unwashed product, it sometimes is
considerably more difficult to justify the cost of washing.
The new era demands that the coal preparation equipment be just as efficient as
the modern by-product coke oven and blastfurnace. If a coal demands wet washing
it should be wet washed, but it should be wet washed well; if it demands dry
cleaning it should be dry cleaned, but that also should be well done.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Campbell, J. R. | | American Rheolaveur Corporation | |