22nd September 1928, Page: 73, Column: 1
Causes Of Absenteeism
The report presented to the Industrial Fatigue Research Board (No. 51) on
"A Study of Absenteeism in a Group of Ten Collieries," by
Dr. H. M. Vernon and Dr. T. Bedford, represents an investigation into the
records of absenteeism relating to about 23,000 miners working at a group of
collieries in the same district, covering periods of 21 months to six years.
Excerpts from the report are appended, the authors summing up by saying:—
Our chief conclusions relate to the extraordinary sensitiveness of the miner to
his conditions of work and his general environment. Any and every change of
condition affects not only his voluntary absenteeism, but in addition the time
lost by sickness and accidents as well. Our results suggest that the most
valuable method of reducing absenteeism is to improve the conditions of work.
We have seen, for instance, that there is probably a certain narrow range of
air movement underground which is associated with a minimum of accidents, and
that at lower or higher velocities the accident frequency rises rapidly. Our
conclusion that accident and sickness rates increase when the air velocity
rises above a moderate figure was unexpected, and it is important that further
information on the subject should be obtained. Probably the adverse effect of
two rapid air-currents is due to their tendency to chill the overheated and
perspiring men, who usually are very scantily clad when at work. Almost
unavoidable delays occur from time to time (e.g., in the provision of tubs),
which necessitate the men standing idle for periods which sometimes exceed
twenty minutes in duration. Hence they may easily catch a chill, and in
addition such delays may cause them to become temporarily more stiff and clumsy
in their movements, and thereby to run an increased chance of accident. Even if
improved ventilation does cause a slight increase in sickness and accidents, it
may be worth while to introduce it, for it tends to reduce the high temperature
of the air, and we saw that temperature is associated to a marked extent with
absenteeism from sickness and accidents. Also improved ventilation would reduce
the risk of explosion in mines rich in gas.
In addition to atmospheric conditions, we saw that other conditions, such as
the distance walked by the men from pit bottom to working-place, appeared to
influence absenteeism greatly, and it is obvious that this distance could be
reduced in many cases by an extension of the system of mechanical transport.
There are other underground conditions requiring improvement which we did not
subject to statistical investigation, and probably the most important of these
is illumination. Such improvements are hound to affect the absenteeism of the
miner.
The effects of improving the conditions above ground may be equally important,
for we saw that such conditions greatly influence the large amount of time lost
by other causes than notified sickness and accidents. We found that miners
living 2½ miles from the colliery showed nearly double the voluntary
absenteeism of those living 1½ miles from it, and there can be little
doubt that the introduction of an adequate system of housing in the
neighbourhood of a colliery would do much to reduce absenteeism and labour
turnover. We obtained no information about the effect of pithead baths, but it
seems probable that their introduction would make for increased contentment,
and would in consequence reduce absenteeism.
In its summary of results the report says :— The total absenteeism of the
men varied with the depth of the workings. In coal face workers the time lost
at a depth of 650 feet averaged 13.8 per cent., whilst that at a depth of 2,160
feet came to 17.0 per cent., or 23 per cent. more. The haulage men and others
working underground showed less absenteeism, but a greater variation, for
absenteeism in the deepest pits was 46 per cent. greater than in the shallowest
pits.
Absenteeism from sickness varies greatly with the underground temperature. A
rise of 13° F. in the dry bulb temperature was associated with a 63 per
cent. increase of sickness in the coal face workers, while a rise of 10 degrees
was associated with a 74 per cent. increase of sickness in the other
underground men. Presumably this influence depends chiefly on the sudden change
of temperature experienced by the men on coming to the surface.
Absenteeism from sickness is associated with air velocity, for the average time
lost by underground workers other than those at the coal face was 85 per cent.
greater at a velocity of 260 feet, than at one of 90 feet. This effect of
air-currents is probably due to the liability of the very lightly clad men to
catch chills.
Absenteeism from accidents is likewise related to air velocity. Accidents to
underground men other than those at the coal face increased steadily at all
velocities from 70 feet per minute upwards, and at a velocity of 264 feet they
were 68 per cent. more numerous than at one of 87 feet. Accident frequency
varies greatly with underground temperature, though accident severity shows but
little response as the effect is confined to minor accidents.
The accident rate is greatly affected by the thickness of the seam. One seam
was found to vary in thickness from 44 to 72 inches at six collieries, and the
accidents from falls of coal and side were four times more numerous when the
seam was at its thickest than when at its thinnest.
The average output of coal per man at the coal face varied in the proportion of
1 to 2 at different pits, and accident frequency varied with output. At pits
where output was 50 per cent. greater than in other pits, the minor accidents
(causing less than 10 days' disablement) were three times more numerous, but
accidents causing 20 or more days of disablement showed no increase.
Accident frequency is related to labour turnover, for minor accidents causing
less than 20 days' disablement were three times more numerous at pits where the
annual labour turnover was 20 per cent. or more, than at those where it was
less than 10 per cent. However, accidents causing over 20 days' disablement
were not affected.
Accident rates vary considerably with the age of the men, and reach a minimum
at the age of 30 to 39. In comparison with this minimum, coal face workers over
60 years of age showed a 41 per cent. excess in frequency rate, and a 100 per
cent. excess in severity rate, whilst the other underground men showed smaller
increments.
Accident frequency varies greatly at different hours of the shift, and in coal
face men working at high temperatures it reached a maximum in the last full
hour of work but one. In those working at low temperatures it did not reach a
maximum till the last full hour.
The time lost by "voluntary" absenteeism (i.e., all absenteeism not
definitely attributed to sickness and accidents) was found to vary with the
distance walked by the men underground, for men who walked 2,800 yards showed
58 per cent. more absenteeism than the men who walked 1,330 yards. It is
related to labour turnover, the men at pits with an annual turnover of 27 per
cent. showing 24 to 75 per cent. more voluntary absenteeism than those at pits
with a turnover of 10 per cent. Again, it is related to the distance of the
men's homes from the collieries, men living 2.6 miles away showing 80 per cent.
more voluntary absenteeism than those living 1.6 miles away. It is likewise
influenced by the proximity of large towns.
Surface workers showed less absenteeism from voluntary causes than underground
men, but greater seasonable fluctuations in absenteeism from sickness.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bedford, T., Dr. | | Industrial Fatigue Research Board | |
| Vernon, H. M., Dr. | | Industrial Fatigue Research Board | |