8th September 1928, Page: 64, Column: 1
The Kata Thermometer
In view of the recent article on the Kata thermometer on page 2, it may be of
interest to note some of the discussion on "A review of the engineering
aspect of improving temperatures and humidity conditions of mine atmospheres at
great depths," a paper read by Dr. J. H. Dobson before the South
African Institution of Engineers.
In a contribution which appears in the July issue of the journal of the
Institution, Dr. A. J. Orenstein says :
"1. Why I recommend the dry Kata by preference in our mining conditions.
"The reason is that, generally speaking, the Kata thermometer is used on
our mines as an anemometer principally, and for this purpose the wet Kata is of
no use.
"It must be borne in mind that the Kata thermometer as an instrument for
measuring comfort is only an approximate empirical instrument. The wet Kata
thermometer undoubtedly has advantages as a comfort measuring instrument in
extreme conditions of heat and saturation such as obtain in our mines, and for
that purpose it was definitely recommended in my report to the Chamber of
Mines, which is identical with the paper to which you refer. I quote the
relative sentence, which is the beginning of Section 50 of the report: For the
purpose of the mines the wet Kata thermometer may be taken as the best standard
of comfort, as it includes all the factors in cooling power on the body,
temperature, humidity and motion. This opinion has also been recently expressed
by Vernon.
"However, the wet Kata thermometer on the Rand even as a standard of
efficiency has its drawbacks, as for this purpose it is almost inevitable to
compare readings on the surface and underground. Now, the wet values on the
surface under Rand conditions will be relatively considerably higher on the
surface and relatively considerably lower underground for the same values of
the dry.
"As one is dealing with an empirical instrument, it is advisable to make
use of that variation of it, or such a method of its application, as will give
the most information with the least trouble, and therefore, for the reasons
enumerated above, I have come to the conclusion that on the whole the dry Kata
would suffice for our purposes. There is another slight advantage, and that is
that a nomogram has been constructed from which readings of air velocities can
instantly be taken by applying dry Kata readings and dry temperature bulb
readings. This nomogram is in the possession of our mines, and it would be
confusing to them if the wet readings were referred to from time to time for
some other purpose.
"I may say, however, that for experimental work, and the obtaining of data
we have always used both the dry and the wet Kata, as well as the dry and wet
bulb temperatures taken with a standard rotary psychrometer, such as is used by
metedroldgists in making their observations.
"2. The limitations of the dry Kata at temperatures exceeding 96°F.
"Both the dry and the wet Kata were constructed with a view to their being
used in moderate temperatures. Both are unreliable in extreme high
temperatures. The dry, however, can be read in negative values. It must be
borne in mind that, from the efficiency point of view, temperatures exceeding
95° in still air are of no great interest, as they produce grave
meta-bollic changes and are exceedingly dangerous. At any rate the Kata
thermometer is not a suitable instrument to apply to the measuring of
"comfort" at such temperatures at which there is no longer any
"comfort."
"More recently Yaglou and his associates have introduced what they call
the 'comfort zone' as a measure. This is based on calculations of 'effective
temperature,' taking into consideration all the factors affecting the
atmosphere. A nomogram has been constructed for this standard as well, and that
can be used for high temperatures, but there is grave doubt whether this
standard of measurement is of practical value, as extreme temperatures anyway.
There is a good deal of discussion in the technical press at the moment about
this matter.
"The principal point I would like to make is that on the mines the
practical application of the Kata is in the determination of what air
velocities will bring a given atmospheric condition within the efficiency limit
of working, and that When the atmospheric condition is such that it cannot be
brought within these limits the Kata thermometer naturally ceases to
function."
In his concluding remarks Dr. Dobson says the most important point which
emerges from the paper and discussion is that the problem of mine atmospheric
conditions on the deep level mines of the Witwatersrand is really not one of
temperature only, and, having regard to the limits of temperature which it is
expected will be encountered, it is chiefly the matter of devising means for
the supply of mine air at lower relative humidities than now exist, so that
there will be sufficient evaporative capacity to give the necessary cooling
effect on the underground workers. The limit of increasing the shaft
ventilation is, of course, the power absorbed in the fan, and the various
contributors have shown that there is great scope for investigation as to how
the power absorbed in increased mine ventilation can be reduced. What is more
important still, is the effect which has been proved on the Village Deep that,
with increased quantities of air, not only is there improvement of the wet Kata
thermometer readings due to the increased velocities, but each unit of the air
itself in the greater quantities due to the greater velocities does not pick up
as much moisture in traversing the mine air circuit as with smaller quantities,
and wherever it is possible to avoid the copious use of water underground it
will naturally be avoided.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dobson, J. H., Dr. | | | |
| Orenstein, A. J., Dr. | | | |