8th September 1928, Page: 56, Column: 1
Steel Supports In Mines
By Louis Frost
[H.M. Inspectors of Mines have been collecting information regarding the use of
steel supports in mines, and in a recent issue of this journal (page 19) the
views of the Inspectors were reproduced in summary. This question is arousing
interest in the Dominions also, and at the annual meeting in June of the Mining
Society of Nova Scotia, under the caption "The Use of Steel Arches in
Supporting Underground Roadways," Mr. Louis Frost, of the
mechanical engineering department of the Dominion Coal Company, had much to say
in favour of steel. In his paper he referred to cases in British practice, and
quoted the views of home experts. Extracts from the paper are appended.]
The coal-mining industry of Nova Scotia, particularly of the island of Cape
Breton, to-day faced as no other industry with economic problems calling for
progressive engineering with production on an economic basis, must soon enter
upon a phase of reorganisation wherein all factors conducive to the cost of
producing coal relative to the prolongation of the life of the collieries with
the ultimate winning of the maximum submarine area must be closely reviewed.
Of late there has been a growing tendency amongst the scientific and business
men connected with the mining profession, especially in Great Britain and on
the continent of Europe, to consider the substitution of steel for timber
wherever possible in the underground workings, and there can be no doubt that,
from economic and safety considerations, this policy is justified and to be
recommended.
Structural engineers have long ago recognised that the basis of economy is
durability, and have eliminated the use of timber wherever possible; and mining
engineers are gradually becoming converted to this law in so far as the use of
steel underground is concerned. In considering the use of steel underground, we
must bear in mind also that the conditions under which this is used differ
somewhat from the conditions under which the same material is used on the
surface. In structural work on the surface, or in tunnelling at comparatively
shallow depths, the factors affecting the size and strength of the material
used for support can be correctly determined. Underground, however, at the
depths at which coal is usually mined, the conditions can hardly be ascertained
at all or only very approximately.
The actual top weight may be unknown, and, where estimated from the product of
boreholes, can at best be only very approximate ; also, complications may be
introduced where heavy floor and side pressures are encountered. Furthermore,
the pressures due to subsidence in longwall workings are not calculable at all;
hence the adoption of a support for underground workings is dependent largely
on the size fixed by experimental basis for the particular work in hand, and is
entirely dependent on local conditions.
The application of steel to the support of underground workings calls for
scientific and systematic methods of mining, which, apart from the cost factor
involved, have shown a considerable decrease in the accident rate. In Scotland,
where the accident rate is 10 per 1,000,000 man-shifts worked, an all-steel
colliery with which the writer was connected for a number of years showed an
accident rate of only two per 1,000,000 man-shifts worked, and fatal accidents
due to falls of ground were practically unknown.
Steel, while showing the highest safety efficiency, is also highly flexible,
and is applicable to practically all conditions where timber is employed,
whether in the support of the roof at the coal face or in the support of
roadways in the mine operating on the longwall system, and is also applicable
to longwall mining in steep seams. In the writer's own experience, steel
arching has been successfully used on roadways having a pitch of 50°, and
steel props in the support of faces on a pitch of 45°.
Generally speaking, the characteristics demanded of an underground support are
that it shall have considerable strength, be durable, resilient, light,
adjustable, and economical. It should be of a simple design, consistent with
the above qualities, and be easily erected or withdrawn. For the support of
roadways underground, whether of a temporary or permanent nature, the steel
arch of 'horse-shoe' or 'semi-horse-shoe' design alone meets these
requirements.
In considering any form of support, account must he taken of the physical
factors involved, and, in the support of any structure, it is a natural
corollary that the closer the design of support approaches the physical factors
acting and reacting upon the structure to be supported, the greater will be the
efficiency of the support. So it is with the use of the steel arch in the
support of roadways underground.
It is well known to mining and tunnelling engineers that when the roof caves it
falls to such a height that the excavation becomes self-supporting. The voids
resulting from the caves-in take a vaulted shape, nearing that of the parabola.
The height of the vaulted space has been found to be independent of the depth
of the overlying material, but, on the other hand, dependent on the width of
the excavation and the cohesion of the strata involved.
In supporting mine roadways, the aim is not to resist the pressure due to the
overlying strata but to regulate the pressure to such a degree that the settled
area conforms with the requirements for ventilation and transport.
When timber is used to regulate this pressure either wholly or partly, as lags
to support straight booms, the final area is a minimum, due to the deflection
of roof, sides, and floor. If, on the other hand, steel supports are employed
in the form of the 'horseshoe' or 'semi-horse-shoe' arch or closed arch,
reinforced with either brick or concrete between the webs, the final area is a
maximum, owing to the shape reacting uniformly against the physical action of
the roof, sides, and floor. The arches gradually take the shape of the roadway,
and, in spite of distortion where heavy pressures are encountered, continue to
support the roof and sides efficiently.
The life of a timbered roadway is comparatively short in unsettled ground,
frequent renewal of the timber being necessary if the roadway must be
maintained for purposes of ventilation or transport. Even in settled ground,
the life of timber supports is comparatively short and rarely exceeds three
years, when renewal is essential, and in return airways it may not exceed two
years, unless impregnated before use.
The maintenance of a wholly or partly timbered road is a source of expense from
the time a mine roadway is driven until its abandonment. With steel arching, on
the other hand, the first cost is the only cost to be considered. Once erected,
steel arching maintains a road for an indefinite number of years, there being
no maintenance cost due to failure of the arches.
Steel arching is at its best when supporting weak roofs and where side
pressures are encountered. If efficiently lagged between the girder and the
strata, no over-riding of the arch can take place. While the employment of
steel arches as a means of support shows the greatest utility in longwall
mining, they may also be economically employed in the support of main airways
in pillar mining, where the roof is tender and the sides of a friable nature,
and especially in the roadways forming the main returns for the ventilating
current.
It is common practice in the more progressive mines in Great Britain, where
longwall mining with total extraction and mechanised loading is practised, to
employ steel arches for the support of roadways, immediately following the
extraction of the coal in the first ripping, and within the writer's own
experience such arches are being economically employed in this manner in seams
ranging from three to seven feet in height.
Roadways are brushed 11 feet wide and eight feet six inches high, to give a
finished height of eight feet by 10 feet, the arches being erected by the
brushers, and the cost of erection included in the brushing price. The arches
employed are of the standard section used throughout the subsidiary main roads
in the mine. They are five inches by three inches, H-section, steel beams, in
two pieces, bent into the shape of an arc — the radius of the curve
commencing at a height of three feet — and joined in the crown by
fish-plates.
It has been observed that, where this system is employed in the first ripping,
a more regular subsidence of the roadway is obtained, and the building of
expensive packs at the road-side can be dispensed with, the road-sides being
packed entirely with stone from this ripping. An added advantage is that there
is an entire absence of roof falls, dead-labour costs from this source being
therefore a minimum; and in spite of the fact that the steel arches are so
badly distorted, by the pressure due to subsidence, that they have to be
replaced in the second ripping — which follows eighty to a hundred yards
behind the face — they give efficient support to the roof and sides. The
girders withdrawn during the second ripping are sent to the surface to be
straightened and are again used for the same class of work, their strength
being only slightly impaired.
Generally, the steel arches erected during the second ripping are built with
brick between the webs. Brick 4½-in. by 3-in. by 9-in. is used in one
lengthways course, the brick fitting into the flanges of the girder. While the
girder supports the main load imposed by the strata, the bricking considerably
strengthens the arch and prevents side buckling, and, to some degree, protects
the strata from the atmosphere, an important feature in the construction of
permanent roadways in strata subject to relatively rapid disintegration.
The steel arches usually employed in the construction of main and secondary
roadways may be in two sections, joined in the crown, or in three sections with
the joint in the shoulder of the arch. Where heavy side pressures are
encountered, small rubble or ashes as packing material between the brickwork
and sides has been found very efficacious in some Scottish collieries.
Where brushing is necessary in seams of moderate height, the amount of
excavation required for the steel arch is somewhat less than for a rectangular
roadway, the arch having a smaller perimeter for the same area.
It may also be noted, in connection with ventilation, that where steel arching
with brick or concrete filling is employed, the coefficient of friction is
considerably reduced.
An essential property required of the steel employed in the manufacture of
arches is that it be sufficiently ductile to conform with the natural shape
rather than rigidity to resist the stresses imposed upon the excavation by
subsidence or the natural pressure of the overlying strata.
While the erection of steel arches as roadway supports, or in the construction
of underground engine-rooms and man-holes, presents no difficulty, and the time
required is little more than that required to erect a steel boom in a roadway
of the same dimensions, care is necessary in the erection relative to the pitch
of the roadway.
To obtain a maximum efficiency from the arch as a support, it should be given a
suitable underset to the pitch of the roadway. The amount of underset necessary
will be slightly less than the underset required in the setting of props on
similar inclinations. The time required to erect a steel arch varies in
accordance with its area; for example, three men will erect a 9-ft. by 10-ft.
steel arch in about 80 minutes.
In the construction of permanent roads it is the best practice to brick or
concrete between the webs of the arches immediately the movement of the strata
has ceased. The type of material employed will be dependent entirely on local
considerations as to cost and the function of the roadway.
At the Lingerwood pit of the Newbattle collieries in Scotland, where the
haulage is also the main intake airway, a concrete lining was used consisting
of cement and hard ashes in the proportion of one cement to four ashes. This
gave a perfectly smooth and compact lining. Whilst the inclusion of ashes in
concrete mixtures may be open to criticism, their use was admissible in this
instance, there being no great pressure on this roadway. Furthermore, the
arches were placed comparatively close.
The cost of preparation of ground for steel arches is about the same as for a
timbered or steel boomed roadway of the same area. The ultimate cost per yard
is dependent on the spacing of the arches and the method employed for filling
in between, and it may be conceded that in Great Britain, where brick at the
collieries is comparatively cheap, the cost for concrete filling will be
slightly greater than for brick. Here in Canada, however, this position would
be reversed.
A decided economic feature in the employment of steel arches is the fact that
they can be withdrawn from abandoned roadways and reset over and over again,
their life being practically unlimited. Where they are so bent or twisted that
they cannot be reset, they are sent to the surface to be straightened and they
can, in a suitable press, be readily restored to their original shape, the
structural weakening of the steel being infinitesimal. When only slightly
twisted, they are straightened cold, but when very badly twisted they are
treated in the hot state.
Before being sent into the mine, steel arches should be painted with tar or
lead compound to prevent atmospheric deterioration, and when employed in ground
where the water is acidulated they should be given a concrete shoe.
Failure of a steel arch is of rare occurrence, though it sometimes happens that
where the pressures are very heavy an arch will fracture in the shoulder.
However, no damage is done when this happens, and the girder may be easily and
safely replaced.
The system of roof support adopted in any colliery is entirely a question of
ultimate economies, and after a number of years' experience with steel supports
underground, the writer is of the opinion that where conditions — due
either to the method of working or to the nature of the strata — warrant
its employment, the steel arch is the only economical method of securing a
roadway, in spite of the fact that the first cost is higher than for timber.
We may summarise the advantages in the use of steel arching as follows: (a)
Reduced excavation necessary. (b) Better ventilation and less frictional
resistance to the air-current, (c) Reduced cost in the production of
ventilation, (d) Less area for dust attachment, and, when lined, dust does not
stick so readily as on the coal sides, (e) Greater ultimate economy than where
timber is employed, (f) Safer working conditions, (g) Fireproof character, (h)
Permanent character of roadways.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Frost, Louis | | Mechanical Engineer | |