|
11th August 1928, Page: 19, Column: 1 Steel SupportsViews at Mines InspectorsIn his report for 1927 Sir H. Walker, the Chief Inspector of Mines, says that the total death-rate per 1,000 persons employed underground from falls of roof and sides, viz., 0.68, compares with a rate of 0.61 for the year 1925. He recalls that in his last report he ventured to express the view that the question of support was resolving itself into one of materials rather than of methods, and it is gratifying to be able to report that the question is now being put to the test in many mines in the different coalfields. The results of these tests are being awaited with great interest. In the meantime, he is fortified in his opinion by the facts given by several of the Divisional Inspectors in their reports. For example, Mr. Hudspeth (Yorkshire) states :— "Steel is being used more extensively both for face and road support with satisfactory results. The growth in the use of steel props is, however, small. Types of steel props at present in use are being tried out at other collieries and special types elsewhere. There is no evidence to show that steel props are more dangerous than the usual timber supports aad they are undoubtedly more economical." In regard to steel arches for support of roads, Mr. Hudspeth remarks that they have proved to give better support than any other method. Also that "the cleanliness of a road supported with well lagged steel arches is remarkable, and their greater use would not only result in a reduction of accidents from falls of ground but also from haulage." In this last paragraph Mr. Hudspeth endorses the view the Chief Inspector says he has previously expressed, namely, that by improving the conditions under which haulage operations are performed, and one means of improving these conditions is by the use of steel arches for the support of roads, the number of accidents not only from falls but also in connection with haulage operations can be materially reduced. Mr. Felton (North Midland) remarks :— "At quite a number of collieries steel props of (various makes) are being tried. This is welcome evidence of the desire of managers to try out any new method which may tend to the safer and more economical working of their mines ; the results so far secured with some of these props have been entirely satisfactory. The use of steel arches is also being extended considerably throughout the Division ; at one colliery 2½ miles of such arching is installed, while several others each have a mile or more. Steel arching is being used at one colliery within 150 yards of the coal face." On the same subject Mr. Nicholson (Lancashire and North Wales) states :— "In connection with the Support of roadways, I am pleased to be able to report that a very determined effort to use steel arches has been made at several mines, and from particulars furnished me I find that at 15 mines over 8,000 steel arches have been erected during the year. The cost generally compares favourably with the usual methods of support, and on the whole their introduction appears to be very satisfactory. I feel sure, now, that their adoption has got beyond the experimental stage in Lancashire, and their use will be largely extended. "The use of steel props at the face is very limited, and where a few have been tried in the past the results do not appear to have justified their more general adoption. A much simpler form of steel prop has, however, been in use for some time at collieries belonging to the Hulton Colliery Company, and appears to have been fairly successful." In regard to Mr. Nicholson's remark in reference to the results of the trials of steel props in the past not having justified their more general adoptions the Chief Inspector says it is apposite to remark that the British Colliery Owners' Research Association has recently appointed a technical investigator (Mr. J. S. Carson) to conduct personal investigations at those collieries where steel supports are being used, and to collect all the available information for circulation throughout the whole of the industry for the information of colliery managers. Mr. Carson has had considerable experience with steel supports at Newbattle Colliery in Scotland and at Ashington Colliery in Northumberland, and the knowledge he has thus acquired will be of much service to colliery managers and probably save a great deal of experimental work. He will be able, too, to help those colliery managers who, as Mr. Nicholson remarks, have not found the results of their trials of steel props in the past to justify their general adoption. In addition, this appointment of Mr. Carson is a fair rejoinder, and one for which the Chief Inspector is grateful, to a paragraph in his report for 1926, which reads :— "It is difficult to understand why steel supports have not been made use of generally. Considerable experience has been gained of the benefits to be derived from the use of such supports, but the information has not been disseminated. It is quite understandable that with competition existing in an industry, methods from which economies are derived at individual collieries are naturally not published broadcast, but when viewed from the point of view of safeguarding life, the question is raised to a higher plane. With this aspect in view, it is to be hoped that owners and managers of mines will give the whole question their most earnest and serious attention." Mr. T. Greenland Davies (Northern Division) reports :— "It is pleasing to record, especially in view of the economic position of the industry, that the use of steel supports, both on the faces and in roadways, is extending. Managers are becoming converted to the view that although the initial capital outlay is increased the ultimate saving is very considerable. Arched steel girders are receiving most attention, and it is interesting to note that in not a few cases managers have only become converts to their use after a visit to some colliery where such girders have been used in large numbers for many years and have proved a complete success. The use of steel supports at the face, with perhaps three exceptions, is limited to very small scale experiments at a few collieries, but I have no doubt that their use will extend in the near future." It is to be hoped that Mr. Davies is correct in his surmise ; a little launching-out and enterprise and less faithful attachment to old methods would, the Chief Inspector feels, be well repaid in the Northern Coalfield. Mr. Charlton (Swansea Division) in his observations in his Report, after narrating the general steps necessary to prevent accidents from falls, refers to steel arches for the support of roads, and states that he does so "in unhesitating terms of commendation." Mr. H. A. Abbott (Midland and Southern Division) reports that the support of the main roadways in mines in that Division by steel arching has been carried on in some of the larger mines to a marked extent. Thousands of tons of steel supports have been put into use, carried, in some cases, right up to the coal face. The safety of the workers on the haulage roads is much enhanced, heavy falls of roof and consequent dislocation of districts of a mine are to a very large extent eliminated. Referring to the publication of the report by the Support of Workings in Mines Committee of the Safety in Mines Research Board on the East Midland Coalfield, Mr. Felton believes that the report has served not only to focus attention upon accidents from falls of ground, but also to stimulate those engaged in the management of collieries in the coalfield to further efforts to reduce the accident rate from this cause, and he indicates directions in which their efforts have been manifest, namely :— (1) The more extensive use of "Sylvesters" instead of the "ringer and chain" for withdrawing timber ; (2) The trial at many collieries of steel in place of wood props ; (3) The extended use of steel arches for the support of roads; and (4) The more extensive use of bars at the face and particularly at way ends, where the greatest danger from falls exists. Mr. Felton hopes that still further progress will be made and that in the near future appliances of the "Sylvester" type for withdrawing timber will be much more used than they now are; that steel props and arching will become common, and that the use of bars instead of props and lids will be very greatly extended. It is, of course, too early to make comparisons, but nevertheless it may be recorded that the number of deaths from falls in the Division of which Mr. Felton has charge (the North Midland Division), was 49 during 1927, as compared with 61 during 1925. Mr. Hudspeth, putting the recommendations made by the Committee to test, instructed the members of his staff to pay careful attention when investigating accidents during 1927 to see how far observance of those recommendations would have reduced the number of accidents. He found that 57 per cent. of these accidents would probably not have happened had the recommendations made been carried out.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||