16th June 1928, Page: 374, Column: 1
Mine Lighting And Accidents
Brief reference was made in issue dated 2nd June to the paper on "Electric
Mine Lamps and Better Mine Lighting," which was submitted by
Mr. William Maurice, at a joint meeting of the Mining Institute of Scotland,
the National Association of Colliery Managers (Scottish Branch), and the
Association of Mining Electrical Engineers (West of Scotland Branch). The
relation between lighting and accidents, he said, has been clearly indicated
wherever it has been investigated. Sooner or later it must be recognised that
the mines cannot stand apart from other industries in regard to lighting. When
they do come into line on a sufficiently large scale, they will make the
pleasing discovery that they have been missing a most important aid to over-all
cost reduction. For 15 years or more companies undertaking group insurance in
U.S.A. have given preference to well-lighted factories. Poorly lighted ones
have been penalised to the extent of from 2 to 5 per cent., and often insurance
is only given at all on condition that the lighting is improved. We can,
therefore, look to improved lighting to reduce the cost of insurance.
Then there is the cost of compensation. There are approximately 1,000 fatal and
200,000 non-fatal accidents in mines every year. The annual compensation cost
of these accidents is about 3¼ million pounds. Light, being one of the
three basic factors in the prevention of accidents, must therefore inevitably
help in the reduction of this heavy drain on humanity. It is directly
contributory to accident reduction because, as a general proposition, there is
always less danger where there is most light. It is indirectly helpful, because
the knowledge that risks have been lessened gives men greater confidence, and
in various psychological ways tends to increase their capacity for work.
Then there is the value of lost time. About 60,000 men are disabled for more
than three days in each year from falls of ground alone, and about 40,000 from
underground haulage accidents. The value of the time lost as a consequence of
these accidents cannot be less than £150,000, and may be any greater
figure, according to the average duration of disability.
The influence of light upon productivity is another factor of undoubted
commercial value which has been definitely established and recorded as to very
many occupations. When illumination is zero production must also be zero. When
illumination reaches the value of good daylight, production is at its maximum.
There is consequently a rising rate of production with increased illumination,
although it does not by any means follow that there is uniform progression.
Almost all processes consist of two distinct parts, one practically independent
of light and the other directly controlled by it. In practice the relation
between illumination and production is complicated by the fact that production
is partly a mental and partly a manual process, and, as to mining, Mr.
Maurice does not think these factors have yet been related and their
proportions determined. For other industries an attempt has been made to frame
a general equation connecting production and intensity of illumination. When
mines come to be illuminated a similar formula will no doubt ultimately
be evolved. Relatively high illumination is psychologically stimulating, and
this effect, by making work easier, leads to increased output. Increased output
may, however, involve increased fatigue. If it does there is something wrong
with the procedure, but not necessarily with the light. Every real advance in
the utilisation of labour must be ameliorative in its tendencies, or it is
radically unsound. All true progress must tend towards economy in human effort
and enable more work to be done with less fatigue. When we consider the
influence of light on the output of miners, Mr. Maurice proceeded to
say, we are up against a fairly general conviction that miners will only supply
a certain output, regardless of any new facilities that may be provided. If
this is the fact, he should expect to find, as explanation, a condition of
imperfect relationship between the men and the administration. As, however, it
takes all sorts to make a world, and sometimes the best management is thrown
out of gear by the mal-operation of external forces, Mr. Maurice said,
it might interest his hearers to know of a means whereby high candle-power
lamps were made to produce the required results. At a certain colliery where
2-volt lamps were in use some others, giving on the average about five times as
much light, were tested carefully and there was found to be a general average
increase in output of, say, half a hundredweight per shift. More high
candle-power lamps were bought, but were only given out on condition that the
user delivered his extra half hundredweight. Whenever he failed to fulfil his
contract he was given a 2-volt lamp. Mr. Maurice understands that this
procedure, established a considerable time ago, continues to "work."
It will be remembered that in his Newcastle lecture Mr. Maurice
indicated four possible ways in which underground lighting could be improved.
These are : (1) By the use of better hand lamps. (2) By the more extended use
of cap lamps of higher lighting value. (3) By the use of auxiliary lamps ; and
(4) By the adoption of some system of lighting from the mains.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Maurice, William | | | |